Medieval Weapons Master Rates 11 Weapons And Armor In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
Insider・16 minutes read
Medieval armor in cinema is often portrayed inaccurately, with shows like "Vikings" featuring 16th-century helmets and leather clothing, which is historically rare. Accuracy in depicting historical combat techniques and armor design is crucial for authenticity in films, as seen in "The Mandalorian" and "Game of Thrones."
Insights
- Medieval armor is designed to closely fit the wearer, allowing for mobility and strategic maneuvering in combat, showcasing the sophistication of craftsmanship during that era.
- Historical accuracy in film depictions of arms and armor is crucial for authenticity, highlighting discrepancies like anachronistic helmets in "Vikings" and exaggerated weapon designs, emphasizing the importance of meticulous research for creating believable portrayals of medieval warfare.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
How does medieval armor protect knights in combat?
Medieval armor is designed to withstand significant physical punishment, allowing knights to strategically take hits in combat. Real armor from the late Middle Ages and Renaissance is tailored to fit the wearer closely, moving with their body to provide protection without hindering movement. This design enables knights to absorb blows and continue fighting effectively, showcasing the durability and functionality of historical armor.
What influences the design of armor in films like "The Mandalorian"?
The armor worn by characters in films like "The Mandalorian" draws inspiration from ancient Greek and Renaissance styles. These influences contribute to the aesthetic appeal and authenticity of the armor depicted on screen, blending historical elements with creative interpretations to create visually striking and culturally rich designs that captivate audiences.
Why is accuracy in depicting historical combat techniques crucial in film?
Accuracy in depicting historical combat techniques, such as unhorsing opponents, is crucial for authenticity in film. By faithfully representing the techniques and strategies used in historical battles, filmmakers can immerse viewers in the world of the past, creating a sense of realism and credibility that enhances the overall storytelling experience and showcases the skill and precision required in combat.
How do weaponsmiths create new armor without fully melting iron ore?
Weaponsmiths avoid fully melting armor to create new armor, as seen in "Game of Thrones." By heating iron ore to separate iron from silicates and other impurities without fully melting it, craftsmen can shape and mold the metal into intricate armor pieces that retain their strength and durability. This process preserves the integrity of the material while allowing for the creation of custom armor designs that reflect historical accuracy and craftsmanship.
What are some common inaccuracies in the portrayal of historical armor in films?
Inaccuracies in historical armor are prevalent in films like "Vikings," where characters are depicted wearing 16th-century helmets despite the setting being in an earlier time period. Additionally, leather clothing is often portrayed inaccurately in historical contexts, as it was rare compared to its frequent appearance in films. Rectangular shields, which were not used in medieval times, are also commonly misrepresented, with shields being circular, made of boards, and properly sealed for battle. These inaccuracies detract from the authenticity of the portrayal of historical armor and weaponry in film, highlighting the importance of thorough research and attention to detail in creating realistic depictions of the past.
Related videos
Insider
Medieval Weapons Expert Rates 7 More Weapons Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
Jahmez
Armor Expert Reacts to Elden Ring Armor
Modern History TV
Is it hard to wear MEDIEVAL ARMOUR?
Sideprojects
The Biggest Misconceptions About Historical Warfare
IGN
Sword Expert Reacts To The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
Summary
00:00
Medieval Arms and Armor in Cinema
- Toby Capwell, curator of arms and armor at The Wallace Collection, discusses medieval arms and armor in cinema.
- Medieval armor can withstand significant physical punishment, allowing knights to strategically take hits in combat.
- Real armor from the late Middle Ages and Renaissance is designed to fit the wearer closely, moving with their body.
- The armor worn by characters in films like "The Mandalorian" draws inspiration from ancient Greek and Renaissance styles.
- The show "Vikings" features inaccuracies in historical armor, with characters wearing 16th-century helmets.
- Leather clothing in historical contexts is rare, contrary to its portrayal in some films.
- Helmets are essential in battle, and characters like Ragnar Lodbrok would have worn elaborate armor and accessories.
- The use of metal in armor creates a distinct appearance and behavior that cannot be replicated with plastic or rubber.
- The portrayal of weapons like maces in films often exaggerates their size and design for dramatic effect.
- Accuracy in depicting historical combat techniques, such as unhorsing opponents, is crucial for authenticity in film.
14:44
Medieval Weaponry and Techniques Unveiled
- Iron ore is heated to separate iron from silicates and other impurities without fully melting it.
- Weaponsmiths avoid fully melting armor to create new armor, as seen in "Game of Thrones."
- Flails, derived from farm implements, are lower-class infantry weapons with a chain added for weaponization.
- Rectangular shields were not used in medieval times; shields were circular, made of boards, and sealed properly.
- Lance technique in jousting sequences is critiqued for being inaccurate, emphasizing the need for proper control and timing.
