Medieval Weapons Expert Rates 7 More Weapons Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
Insider・10 minutes read
Analysis of historical accuracy in cinema focusing on fire arrows, armor design, knighting portrayal, mail armor, heraldry, arrow wounds, gilding, cavalry charges, visor closure, and gorget placement. Various aspects of medieval warfare and armor depiction in movies are critiqued and rated for accuracy.
Insights
- The analysis provides a focus on historical accuracy in cinema, highlighting discrepancies in armor design, knighting portrayal, and the use of real mail armor versus plastic alternatives.
- Detailed discussions on armor aesthetics, heraldry, and combat tactics shed light on the intricacies of medieval warfare depicted in films, offering insights into the nuances often overlooked in cinematic representations.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
How historically accurate are fire arrows in cinema?
Fire arrows in cinema are commonly depicted with historical inaccuracies, but this analysis sheds light on a more authentic portrayal.
What is the critique of Éomer's helmet in "Lord of the Rings"?
The design of Éomer's helmet in "Lord of the Rings" is criticized for not being properly fitted for protection, highlighting a flaw in its authenticity.
Why is metal armor superior to plastic for dwarves in movies?
The armor of dwarves in movies is discussed, emphasizing the superiority of metal over plastic due to the need for a blocky aesthetic and durability.
What inaccuracies are found in the portrayal of knighting in films?
The portrayal of knighting in films is criticized for inaccuracies such as unnecessary repetition, highlighting discrepancies from historical accuracy.
How important is real mail armor with rivets compared to fake plastic mail in movies?
The importance of real mail armor with rivets is highlighted, contrasting it with fake plastic mail often used in movies, emphasizing the significance of authenticity in armor portrayal.
Related videos
Insider
Medieval Weapons Master Rates 11 Weapons And Armor In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
IGN
Sword Expert Reacts To The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
Tod's Workshop
Real Medieval Fire Arrows! (Sorry Hollywood)
Insider
Ancient-Warfare Expert Rates 10 More Battle Tactics In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
Tod's Workshop
ARROWS vs ARMOUR - Medieval Myth Busting
Summary
00:00
Historical Accuracy in Medieval Film Armor
- Fire arrows were commonly used in cinema but are shown with more historical accuracy in this analysis.
- The design of Éomer's helmet in "Lord of the Rings" is critiqued for not being properly fitted for protection.
- The armor of dwarves in movies is discussed, emphasizing the need for a blocky aesthetic and the superiority of metal over plastic.
- The portrayal of knighting in films is criticized for inaccuracies, such as unnecessary repetition.
- The importance of real mail armor with rivets is highlighted, contrasting it with fake plastic mail often used in movies.
- The significance of heraldry in medieval armor for visual identification is explained, with a rating of seven out of 10 for accuracy in a film.
- The scene of a character getting shot with arrows in a film is praised for showing the non-instantly fatal nature of arrow wounds.
- The process of gilding armor with gold is discussed, with a rating of four out of 10 for the accuracy of the portrayal in a film.
- The effectiveness of a cavalry charge formation, the importance of closing a visor, and the incorrect placement of a gorget are analyzed in a film scene.
