The PROBLEM with the combat in DUNE

Recent questions

• How effective are the soldiers' weapons and armor in the Dune films?

  The effectiveness of soldiers' weapons and armor in the Dune films is a topic of discussion. The combat in Dune involves shields that can only be penetrated by slow-moving blades, which raises questions about the armor underneath the shields. Armor is introduced in Dune Part Two, worn by soldiers including the Fremen, which changes the dynamics of combat. Testing is planned with different blades to determine their effectiveness in penetrating thick clothing or armor. The debate touches on the use of advanced materials in armor and the necessity of sharpness and force to penetrate armor effectively.

• What is the design and functionality of the sandworm dagger from Dune?

  The sandworm dagger from Dune, a replica by United Cutlery, is being analyzed for its design and functionality. The sharpness and design of the sandworm tooth dagger are discussed, questioning its ability to penetrate armor effectively. The absence of a hilt on the sandworm dagger is noted, potentially affecting its ability to push through resistance. The thickness of the sandworm dagger may hinder its ability to cut through resistant materials effectively. The discussion also involves testing the sandworm dagger against different materials like armor and chain mail.

• How does the honu legionary dagger compare to the sandworm dagger in Dune combat?

  The honu legionary dagger is a serious weapon being compared to the sandworm dagger for testing in Dune combat. The design of the blade is compared to soldier swords, highlighting differences in blade shape and functionality. The conversation also delves into the importance of blade tip optimization for combat effectiveness. Testing is planned with the honu legionary dagger and the sandworm dagger to determine their effectiveness in penetrating thick clothing or armor. The idea of finding gaps in armor for effective combat strategies is discussed, emphasizing the importance of strategy in combat.

• What is the significance of slow-moving blades in combat in Dune?

  Slow-moving blades are emphasized in combat in Dune due to the shields that can only be penetrated by them. The first test involves a blade against a shield, with the conclusion that slow-moving blades are more effective. Ice pick knife fighting is mentioned as a common technique, highlighting the importance of technique in combat. The conversation also shifts to testing the blades against chain mail, concluding that slow-moving blades are necessary to penetrate it. The debate touches on the use of advanced materials in armor and the necessity of sharpness and force to penetrate armor effectively.

• How important is attention to detail in world-building and combat logic in storytelling?

  Attention to detail in world-building and combat logic in storytelling is deemed crucial in the discussion. The concept of unparalleled sharpness and its impact on combat effectiveness is debated, with a focus on the blade's ability to cut through advanced materials. The discussion concludes with a call for attention to detail in world-building and combat logic in storytelling, emphasizing the importance of creating a coherent and believable combat system within the narrative of a story.