LoginGet started

Rings of Power: The Anti-Lord of the Rings

Despot of Antrim・2 minutes read

The show "Rings of Pyre" is heavily criticized for poor quality, straying from Tolkien's lore and lacking in depth and urgency. Characters like Sauron and Galadriel are portrayed in a negative light, deviating from their original depictions and facing issues of poor writing and lack of strategic thinking.

Insights

  • The show "Rings of Pyre" faces severe criticism for its poor quality, seen as disrespectful to Tolkien and the fans, highlighting a significant gap between the adaptation and the source material's richness.
  • The portrayal of key characters like Elrond and Galadriel in "Rings of Pyre" diverges drastically from their original depictions in "Lord of the Rings," showcasing a lack of understanding and respect for the established lore, ultimately leading to a flawed narrative and character development.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • Why is "Rings of Pyre" criticized by viewers?

    "Rings of Pyre" faces criticism due to its poor quality, ranging from cringe-inducing moments to disappointing outcomes. Many viewers see the show as an insult to Tolkien and the fandom, failing to capture the essence of the original source material and lacking the depth and authenticity expected from an adaptation of such a beloved series.

  • How could "Rings of Pyre" have been successful?

    To achieve success, "Rings of Pyre" could have focused on hiring the best talent available, sticking closely to the lore established by Tolkien, and following successful models like "The Mandalorian." By prioritizing these aspects, the show could have potentially avoided the pitfalls that led to its negative reception and disappointment among viewers.

  • What are the criticisms surrounding the portrayal of Elrond in "Rings of Pyre"?

    The portrayal of Elrond in "Rings of Pyre" is compared unfavorably to the original "Lord of the Rings" trilogy, with viewers highlighting the weak and unimpressive depiction of the character in the show. This discrepancy in portrayal contributes to the overall dissatisfaction with the adaptation and the perceived lack of respect for the source material.

  • Why is the character of Sauron praised in "Rings of Pyre"?

    Despite the show's attempt to portray Sauron negatively, viewers praise the character for his loyalty and heroism, contrasting with the show's interpretation. This unintentional inversion of hero and villain roles adds an interesting layer to the character, making him more admirable than intended by the creators of "Rings of Pyre."

  • What are the criticisms surrounding the gender-swapped roles of Frodo and Sam in "Rings of Pyre"?

    The gender-swapped roles of Frodo and Sam in "Rings of Pyre" are criticized for lacking the depth and urgency present in the original "Lord of the Rings" story. Viewers find the relationship between Frodelma and Samays uninteresting and lacking the compelling dynamics seen in the original characters, contributing to the overall disappointment with the adaptation.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Rings of Pyre: Poor Adaptation Criticized"

  • The show "Rings of Pyre" is criticized for being of poor quality, ranging from cringe-inducing to disappointing, seen as an insult to Tolkien and the fandom.
  • The focus shifts to why the show is considered bad, questioning how such a poor adaptation was made despite the source material's richness.
  • Suggestions are made on how the show could have been successful, emphasizing hiring the best talent, sticking to the lore, and following successful models like "The Mandalorian."
  • The portrayal of Elrond in "Rings of Pyre" is compared to the original "Lord of the Rings" trilogy, highlighting the former's weak and unimpressive depiction.
  • The character of Sauron in "Rings of Pyre" is praised for his loyalty and heroism, contrasting with the show's attempt to portray him negatively.
  • The unintentional inversion of hero and villain roles in the show is discussed, with Sauron being viewed as a more admirable character than intended.
  • The gender-swapped roles of Frodo and Sam in "Rings of Pyre" are criticized for lacking the depth and urgency present in the original "Lord of the Rings" story.
  • The relationship between Frodelma and Samays in the show is deemed uninteresting and lacking the compelling dynamics seen in the original characters.
  • The man-elf relationship in "Rings of Pyre" is compared unfavorably to the beautiful love story of Aragorn and Arwen in the original trilogy, seen as boring and irrelevant to the plot.
  • The subplot involving a black elf and a village wench in "Rings of Pyre" is criticized for being unexplained, slowing down the story, and adding to the overall boredom of the series.

14:04

"Conqueror in Mud Village: Rings of Pyre"

  • The guy is a conqueror from a high civilization serving as an occupying soldier in a Land of mud and [__] Village.
  • The Village wench is a middle-aged single mother peasant who cleans animal filth and performs menial tasks to survive.
  • The son of the Village wench is criticized for his abysmal acting skills in the show.
  • A comparison is made between the cave troll battles in Lord of the Rings and Rings of Pyre.
  • The cave troll battle in Lord of the Rings is built up with tension and takes several minutes for the Fellowship to defeat.
  • The cave troll battle in Rings of Pyre lacks build-up, is quickly resolved by Galadriel in 15 seconds, and lacks the same impact.
  • The show's casting is criticized for incompetent choices, especially in the role of the Village wench's son.
  • Rings of Pyre is faulted for its lack of urgency and sense of time pressure compared to Lord of the Rings.
  • The potato Hobbits in Rings of Pyre are deemed irrelevant, boring, and a waste of screen time.
  • The show's use of Irish accents for the potato Hobbits is criticized for stereotyping and lack of depth in character development.

28:40

Critique of "Rings of Pyre" flaws

  • The text criticizes Amazon's implication that the Irish are akin to locusts or sub-humans, highlighting potential backlash if the characters had accents attributed to Black Americans.
  • It discusses the presence of mystery boxes in the show, labeling it as a dated trope that reached its peak in the 2010s and was overused in shows like "Lost."
  • The text mentions the use of imitation Shakespeare dialogue in "Rings of Pyre," ridiculing it as amateurish and laughable.
  • It critiques the lack of a clear creative framework in "Rings of Pyre," highlighting the suffocating rules and regulations imposed on the project, hindering originality and creativity.
  • The text questions the attempt to modernize Tolkien's world in "Rings of Pyre," arguing that it dilutes the magic and authenticity of the original source material.
  • It discusses the flawed battle strategy in the show, pointing out nonsensical decisions made by characters that defy basic military tactics.
  • The text highlights numerous plot holes in "Rings of Pyre," including inconsistencies in character actions, unrealistic scenarios, and questionable decisions made by key figures.
  • It criticizes the portrayal of Galadriel in the show, questioning her ineffective pursuit of Sauron and the lack of strategic thinking in her actions.
  • The text ridicules the lack of military knowledge displayed by characters like Legolas, despite their supposed experience as professional soldiers.
  • It questions the logic behind certain character behaviors and plot developments in "Rings of Pyre," pointing out instances of poor writing and unrealistic scenarios.

42:55

"Rings of Pyre" Strays from Tolkien's Legacy

  • The commander of the Invasion Force leaves her soldiers after a volcano erupts, leading to potential violent arguments, revenge killings, bribery, political intrigue, and civil war among the tribes.
  • The ethnography of the potato Hobbits and Numenoreans in the show lacks coherence, with racially diverse characters existing in isolated tribes, contradicting the logical development of ethnically homogenous groups over time.
  • The racial diversity in "Rings of Fire" is criticized as lazy box-ticking without historical or biological sense, contrasting with the ethnographic consistency seen in "Lord of the Rings" where diversity was explained by the presence of mercenaries from outside Middle Earth.
  • The character Galadriel in "Rings of Pyre" is portrayed as a detestable villain, deviating from the heroic depiction in "Lord of the Rings," embodying the show's flawed writing and departure from Tolkien's lore.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.