Rings Of Power Sucked | The Ultimate Review
The Movie Cynic・2 minutes read
The Rings of Power is criticized for lacking compelling writing, acting, and dialogue, heavily relying on nostalgia from Peter Jackson's films. Despite visually stunning aspects, the show is deemed to lack substance, struggling to match the beloved interpretations of Tolkien's characters and facing challenges due to limited rights.
Insights
- The Rings of Power is heavily criticized for its poor writing, acting, and reliance on nostalgia for Peter Jackson's films, lacking a compelling original story and depth in character development.
- Despite visually stunning aspects, the show is deemed boring and lacking heart, with cringe-inducing dialogue, contrived storytelling, and a focus on visuals over narrative strength, ultimately failing to engage viewers and falling short in execution.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are the main criticisms of Rings of Power?
The show is criticized for poor writing, acting, and dialogue, lack of original story, and reliance on nostalgia.
How does Rings of Power handle character development?
Characters are described as flat with shaky motivations.
What are the positive aspects of Rings of Power?
The relationship between Duran and Elrond is highlighted as a positive aspect.
How does Rings of Power compare to Peter Jackson's films?
Rings of Power struggles to match the beloved interpretations of Tolkien's characters.
What are the major themes in Rings of Power?
Rings of Power focuses on revenge, leadership, and questionable actions.
Related videos
Despot of Antrim
Rings of Power: The Anti-Lord of the Rings
Nerd of the Rings
A Long-expected Review: The Rings of Power Season 1
Jon Solo
The Messed Up Origins™ of The Rings of Power | Folklore Explained
The Cosmonaut Variety Hour
Lord of the Rings - All Movies Reviewed
Like Stories of Old
Heroism and Moral Victory – The Lord of the Rings
Summary
00:00
"Rings of Power: Lackluster Nostalgia Over Substance"
- The Rings of Power is criticized for its poor writing, acting, and dialogue, being likened to "poop" and "aggressive diarrhea."
- The show heavily relies on nostalgia for Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings films, lacking a compelling original story.
- The costume design is criticized for its poor quality, with outfits compared to CW-level standards.
- The show is described as lacking substance, focusing more on grand scenery and CGI rather than story and acting.
- The narrative is filled with cringe-inducing dialogue and poorly written metaphors, leading to embarrassment for viewers.
- Characters often contradict their actions, with dialogue used for effect rather than logical consistency.
- The show is accused of using mystery boxes to mask its lack of a coherent story, with uninteresting plotlines and predictable reveals.
- The storytelling is criticized for being contrived, relying on luck and convenience to progress the plot.
- The showrunners admit to not having answers to their own mystery boxes, suggesting a lack of planning for the series.
- Despite visually stunning aspects, the lack of a compelling story in Rings of Power is highlighted, with critics focusing more on visuals than narrative strength.
12:52
Rings of Power: Struggles with Tolkien's Legacy
- The show struggles to match the beloved interpretations of Tolkien's characters from Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy.
- The series lacks depth in writing despite impressive digital effects and aesthetic appeal.
- The show faces challenges due to limited rights, leading to a reliance on nostalgia and member berries.
- The writing is criticized for lacking originality and depth, resorting to rehashing familiar themes.
- Characters in Rings of Power are often flat, with shaky motivations and unengaging storylines.
- Galadriel, the main character, is portrayed as unlikeable and selfish, with questionable actions.
- The show's flaws are attributed to poor writing and direction, resulting in unconvincing performances.
- The relationship between Duran and Elrond stands out as a positive aspect amidst other faults.
- The show is seen as a money-making venture for Amazon, lacking the artistic merit and respect of Jackson's films.
- The show's attempts to generate buzz through controversy and fan-baiting tactics are criticized.
27:03
Critics Slam Rings of Power Fan Fiction
- Fan fiction for Rings of Power is criticized for attempting to improve on a beloved intellectual property.
- The show is accused of having cringe-inducing dialogue, relying on luck in the plot, and poor CGI.
- The protagonist, Galadriel, is portrayed as a strong female leader seeking revenge for her brother's death.
- The show attempts to evoke nostalgia from Peter Jackson's films but falls short in execution.
- Galadriel defeats a snow troll single-handedly, defying expectations.
- The show's pacing is criticized for being slow and lacking excitement.
- The dialogue in the show is compared unfavorably to Tolkien's original works.
- The characters in the show are described as wooden and uninteresting, lacking depth.
- The show is accused of lacking narrative cohesion and failing to engage viewers.
- Despite some positive aspects like practical effects and costumes, the show is overall deemed boring and lacking heart.
41:16
"Show lacks character depth, originality, and engagement."
- The show evokes intense sadness through its music, lacking character attachment.
- Strong women's facial expressions and interactions are analyzed in detail.
- Chad impresses with a clever line, showcasing a rare positive moment in the show.
- A potential fight scene falls flat due to slow, dull choreography.
- The creators struggle to capture the fun of hobbiting, leading to awkward scenes.
- The episode ends with a CGI creature and recycled sound effects, lacking originality.
- The show introduces various characters and storylines, struggling to engage the audience.
- The episode features a mix of action sequences, character interactions, and plot developments.
- The show's music is criticized for being misplaced and overbearing, detracting from the scenes.
- The characters' actions and dialogues are scrutinized for lacking depth and believability.
58:17
"Contrived device creates Mount Doom in show"
- Mount Doom and Mordor are created through a contrived Rube Goldberg device in episode 7 of the show.
- Elrond is denied a thrilling moment due to Durian's Dad in the Southlands, which is revealed to be Mordor.
- Galadriel seems indifferent to people suffering from smoke inhalation or injuries.
- Characters prioritize personal interactions over aiding injured individuals, showcasing questionable leadership.
- Leaf coming back to life is deemed cheesy, but the acting in this scene is praised.
- Characters show inconsistency in their established traits, especially in helping others in need.
- The final episode reveals Sauron's identity, portraying him as an incel, and Galadriel receives a ring of power.
