What If Neville Was The Chosen One - FULL STORY | Harry Potter Film Theory

SuperCarlinBrothers・2 minutes read

The pivotal moment in Wizarding World history occurred on October 31st, 1981, when Voldemort attacked the Potters, marking the night he lost his powers and involved the prophecy of the chosen one. Neville and Harry's intertwined destinies pivot on Voldemort's choice between them, leading to unforeseen consequences and sacrifices that ultimately defeat the Dark Lord.

Insights

  • Voldemort's choice between Harry and Neville was influenced by his belief in pure-blood superiority, leading him to select Harry as the greater threat.
  • Neville Longbottom, raised by his parents in seclusion, is unaware of his potential role in the Wizarding World due to Dumbledore's secrecy.
  • Neville discovers a lightning scar on his chest, a result of Voldemort's failed curse and Harry's sacrifice.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What happened on October 31st, 1981?

    Voldemort attacked the Potters, targeting baby Harry.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Voldemort's Choice: Harry or Neville?"

  • The pivotal moment in Wizarding World history occurred on October 31st, 1981, when Voldemort attacked the Potters, attempting to kill baby Harry.
  • This event marked the night Voldemort lost his powers and involved the prophecy of the chosen one, foretelling the one who would defeat the Dark Lord.
  • Harry was chosen as the prophesied one, but Neville Longbottom was a viable alternative, being born to Order of the Phoenix members who defied Voldemort and born at the end of July.
  • If Voldemort had chosen Neville, the story would have shifted significantly, impacting the fate of both Harry and Neville.
  • Voldemort's choice between Harry and Neville was influenced by his belief in pure-blood superiority, leading him to select Harry as the greater threat.
  • Dumbledore knew both Harry and Neville were candidates for the prophecy and took steps to protect both families using the Fidelius Charm.
  • The Potters, despite potentially being less likely to be murdered, would still have faced attacks due to their defiance of Voldemort and membership in the Order of the Phoenix.
  • In a scenario where Neville was chosen, the Potters would have been tortured by Death Eaters to extract information about the Longbottoms' whereabouts.
  • Bellatrix, known for her cruelty, would have been sent to torture the Potters, leading to James' death and Lily's survival due to Snape's appeal.
  • The aftermath of the attack would have seen Snape finding baby Harry and Lily, bringing them to Dumbledore, while the Longbottoms remained hidden under the Fidelius Charm.

14:56

Neville Longbottom's Hogwarts Journey Begins

  • Quirrell has switched sides, and Harry Potter, raised by Sirius Black, misses his deceased best friend killed by Voldemort.
  • Voldemort has not marked Neville or Harry as the chosen one due to lack of access, but he believes Neville is the dangerous one based on a prophecy.
  • The Wizarding World enjoys peace for a decade, speculating on Voldemort's disappearance, focusing on the Potters and the Longbottoms.
  • Neville Longbottom, raised by his parents in seclusion, is unaware of his potential role in the Wizarding World due to Dumbledore's secrecy.
  • Dumbledore hand-delivers Neville's Hogwarts letter to ensure his safety, taking him to Diagon Alley for supplies, including his first wand.
  • Neville struggles to find the right wand until Ollivander presents him with one that sparks red, signifying the correct match.
  • Hagrid reveals to Neville the history of his family's bravery against Voldemort, leading to their seclusion for protection.
  • Neville, excited to attend Hogwarts, boards the train and meets Draco Malfoy, who hints at Neville's family history and Hogwarts houses.
  • Harry Potter interrupts Draco's conversation with Neville, showcasing a magical trick with his toad, Hedwig, and asserting his presence.
  • Harry saves Neville from Draco's taunts, introducing himself and his toad, Hedwig, while hinting at Draco's future house placement.

28:49

"Harry and Neville's Hogwarts Journey"

  • There are four houses at Hogwarts: Gryffindor, Ravenclaw, Hufflepuff, and Slytherin.
  • Neville Longbottom meets Harry Potter on the train to Hogwarts and they bond over Wizarding World knowledge.
  • Harry buys a lot of candy from the trolley witch, including chocolate frogs with collectible cards.
  • Harry shows Neville a spell to turn a toad golden, impressing Neville with magic.
  • Neville and Harry make their way to Hogwarts, where Neville worries about being sorted into Hufflepuff.
  • Neville is surprised to be sorted into Gryffindor, not Hufflepuff, and joins the house with Harry.
  • In classes, Neville excels in Herbology, while Harry faces challenges in Potions with Professor Snape.
  • Harry and Neville have a flying lesson where Harry excels, but Neville struggles until Malfoy interferes.
  • Harry and Neville have a midnight duel with Malfoy, leading to Harry's detention in the Forbidden Forest.
  • Rumors spread that Harry attacked Mrs. Norris, leading to suspicion and tension among the students.

41:17

"Chamber of Secrets suspicions spread at Hogwarts"

  • Harry and Neville discuss the Chamber of Secrets, with Neville sharing information about Hagrid's involvement and the giant spider Aragog.
  • Neville questions if other spiders could be in the castle, leading to suspicions about the recent attacks.
  • Professor Quirrell introduces defensive spells in class, including the Disarming Spell Expelliarmus, and encourages students to report anything unusual.
  • During a class exercise, Neville successfully disarms Ron Weasley multiple times, while Hermione also masters the spell.
  • Harry and Hermione excel in the Disarming Spell, with Hermione even knocking Harry across the classroom, earning points for Gryffindor.
  • Neville and Harry discuss Hermione's absence from class and the recent attacks, leading to suspicions about Harry's involvement.
  • Rumors spread throughout the school, with Draco Malfoy appearing smug, Dumbledore possibly being expelled, and students distancing themselves from Harry.
  • Harry's absence from a post-match party raises suspicions, and Neville discovers Harry asleep over a blank book with the initials TMR.
  • Neville decides to stay at Hogwarts for Christmas, joining Terry in planning adventures with an invisibility cloak.
  • The Christmas holidays bring a lighter atmosphere to the castle, with Professor Quirrell intensifying efforts to locate the Chamber of Secrets.

52:58

Harry and Neville uncover Chamber of Secrets

  • Harry and Neville plan to explore the castle while Ron Weasley sleeps, needing to wait until he falls asleep to sneak out under an invisibility cloak.
  • Ron finally retires to bed after 11 pm, having stayed up late playing exploding snap with his brothers.
  • Harry, fully dressed, ignores Neville's whispers and heads out of the dormitory without the invisibility cloak.
  • Harry encounters no resistance from Filch, teachers, or prefects as he heads to the girl's bathroom on the second floor.
  • Neville follows Harry to the bathroom, where Harry speaks to a sink in a hissing voice, opening a doorway to the Chamber of Secrets.
  • Neville, shocked, realizes Harry is the one opening the Chamber of Secrets and attacking students.
  • Neville encounters Dumbledore in the Great Hall, who praises him for his loyalty and courage, hinting at the true enemy.
  • Neville, conflicted, uses the rememberall to identify Voldemort as the real enemy, leading him to confront Harry about the attacks.
  • Harry confesses to Neville about being manipulated by Tom Riddle and blacking out during the attacks.
  • Harry and Neville decide to inform Professor Quirrell about the diary and suspicions of dark magic, leading to the resolution of the situation and a lighter mood as Christmas approaches.

01:05:40

Gryffindor Triumphs in Quidditch Match and Discovery

  • Harry was back to his normal self after the winter holiday, feeling safe at school since the diary was given to Coral.
  • Many students didn't return for the spring semester due to fear after Ron's attack and Dumbledore's departure.
  • Neville felt confident about everyone's safety as no attacks occurred in the first month.
  • Professor Sprout announced the mandrakes were almost ready to revive the petrified victims.
  • Neville assured Harry of his innocence in the attacks, believing the diary was the real culprit.
  • Gryffindor prepared for a Quidditch match against Hufflepuff, with Harry determined to win.
  • Hufflepuff initially led the match, but Harry's skills and determination turned the game in Gryffindor's favor.
  • Harry and the Hufflepuff Seeker raced for the snitch, with Harry ultimately catching it and securing Gryffindor's victory.
  • Celebrations erupted as Gryffindor won, with Neville feeling immense joy and Gryffindor leading for the house cup.
  • Neville and Harry discovered the entrance to the Chamber of Secrets in the bathroom, encountering Tom Riddle and learning of his sinister plans involving Neville.

01:18:07

"Neville's Sacrifice Defeats Voldemort, Chosen One"

  • Harry sacrifices himself to save Neville from Voldemort's spell, resulting in Harry's death.
  • Neville, devastated by Harry's death, stands up to Voldemort, who attempts to kill him but fails due to Harry's sacrifice.
  • Dumbledore explains to Neville that Harry's sacrifice invoked ancient magic of love, protecting Neville and backfiring on Voldemort, ultimately destroying him.
  • Neville discovers a lightning scar on his chest, a result of Voldemort's failed curse and Harry's sacrifice.
  • Dumbledore hints at Neville's potential as the chosen one to defeat Voldemort, symbolized by Neville's possession of Godric Gryffindor's card, given to him by Harry.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.