LoginGet started

Wal Thornhill is a Complete Fraud (Thunderbolts Project Debunked)

Professor Dave Explains・2 minutes read

The debunked pseudoscientific theories promoted by Wal Thornhill, including Venus's birth from Jupiter and electric arcs shaping planets, are discredited with scientific evidence against his claims, despite his continued denial. Thornhill's misinformation about comets, black holes, and general relativity highlights his lack of understanding of physics, particularly the importance of mathematics in physics for making accurate predictions and experimental tests.

Insights

  • Wal Thornhill's promotion of pseudoscientific theories, including myths about Venus's birth from Jupiter and electrical arcs shaping planets, is debunked, highlighting his lack of credentials and reliance on mythology.
  • Despite Wal Thornhill's denial of established physics principles like general relativity and the existence of black holes, scientific evidence, including observations of black holes and the precision of general relativity in predicting astronomical phenomena, refutes his claims, emphasizing the importance of accurate mathematics in physics for consistent predictions and experimental tests.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What are some debunked pseudoscientific theories?

    Electric Universe, SAFIRE project, Sky Scholar, Suspicious0bservers.

  • Who is Wal Thornhill and what criticisms does he face?

    Wal Thornhill promotes mythological space fantasies and science denial.

  • What are some of Wal Thornhill's predictions about comets?

    Thornhill's predictions about comets involve their formation and composition.

  • How does Wal Thornhill view modern physics?

    Thornhill denies modern physics, claiming it is based on mathematics.

  • What is the significance of the Higgs boson in particle physics?

    The Higgs boson gives elementary particles mass through the Higgs mechanism.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Debunked Pseudoscience: Thornhill's Electric Universe Myths

  • Various debunked pseudoscientific theories include Electric Universe, SAFIRE project, Sky Scholar, and Suspicious0bservers.
  • Wal Thornhill, associated with the "Thunderbolts Project," is criticized for promoting mythological space fantasies and science denial inspired by Immanuel Velikovsky's ideas.
  • Thornhill's claims involve Venus being birthed from Jupiter, electrical arcs shaping planets, and Ancient Aliens-like narratives.
  • Thornhill's lack of credentials and reliance on mythology are highlighted, leading to his dismissal of legitimate physicists as lost in dogma.
  • Thornhill's predictions about comets, including their formation from violent events and negative charges, are debunked.
  • Thornhill's predictions about the Deep Impact mission's failure due to electrical interference are proven wrong when the mission succeeds.
  • Thornhill's misinterpretations of the comet's composition, including the absence of ice, are refuted by the actual findings of water ice, dust, and organic materials.
  • Thornhill's continued deception and lies regarding subsequent comet missions, like Epoxi and Rosetta, are exposed as the missions successfully gather data contradicting his claims.
  • Thornhill's theories about comets' magnetic fields, composition, and electrical activity are debunked by scientific measurements and observations.
  • Thornhill's insistence that water on comets is not actually water but oxygen anions forming hydroxyl radicals is refuted by numerous scientific detections of water on comets.

13:10

"Debunking Wal's Pseudoscience with Evidence"

  • The mechanism suggested for the production of hydroxyl radicals is electric discharge machining, a man-made process carried out under controlled laboratory conditions.
  • Multiple missions have sent probes to pass by or land on comets, collecting data and finding water, refuting claims made by Wal about comets.
  • Despite evidence against his claims, Wal continues to promote videos denying reality about comets on platforms like YouTube.
  • Wal denies modern physics, claiming it is based on mathematics, which he and his followers prefer to ignore.
  • Wal attempts to discredit scientific breakthroughs like the detection of gravitational waves by LIGO, claiming they are fake.
  • Wal's denial of the speed of gravity and the detection of gravitational waves is refuted by scientific evidence.
  • Wal falsely claims that recipients of the 2017 Nobel Prize for Physics are mathematicians, when they are actually physicists.
  • Wal's criticism of general relativity is baseless, as observations of stars and planets have consistently supported the theory.
  • Wal's misinformation about science is highlighted, emphasizing the importance of understanding mathematics in physics.
  • The text concludes with a promotion for Brilliant, an educational platform offering courses in various scientific and mathematical subjects.

26:42

Misunderstanding Physics: Wal's Denial of Black Holes

  • Wal's criticism of relativity showcases his lack of understanding on the topic, particularly when it comes to general relativity phenomena.
  • Award-winning science author Jim Baggott's quote emphasizes the importance of getting the math right in physics to make consistent predictions and experimental tests.
  • Physics involves both math and science, contrary to Wal's misleading claims, with general relativity aligning well with existing observations and making accurate predictions.
  • Newton's theory, while effective for non-relativistic situations, lacks the accuracy and predictive power that general relativity offers in relativistic scenarios.
  • Mathematics serves as the language of physics, with mass and energy remaining undefined concepts, despite high school definitions.
  • Black holes, though once hypothetical, have been observed and predicted within the framework of general relativity, debunking Wal's skepticism.
  • Einstein's general relativity accurately predicts black holes, contrary to Wal's claims, showcasing the evolution of physics beyond Einstein's time.
  • The Event Horizon Telescope's 2019 image of a black hole directly contradicts Wal's denial of their existence, highlighting his resistance to new evidence.
  • Plasma cosmology, an alternative to black hole theory, proposes the existence of plasmoids at the center of galaxies, challenging traditional gravitational models.
  • Wal's denial of black holes and promotion of plasmoids lack scientific basis, as evidenced by the precision of general relativity in predicting astronomical phenomena.

40:59

"Exploring Fundamental Physics Concepts"

  • The Higgs boson is a hypothetical particle that gives elementary particles mass through the Higgs mechanism.
  • Quarks, which make up particles like protons, interact with the Higgs field to obtain a portion of their mass.
  • The majority of a particle's mass is intrinsic to the particle itself, not from the Higgs boson.
  • Gravity is explained through the warping of spacetime, not by a physical fourth dimension.
  • Light does not require a medium to travel through, unlike sound waves.
  • The speed of light in a vacuum, denoted as c, is a universal constant and does not depend on the medium.
  • The universal gravitational constant, G, is a constant that is used in equations to describe gravitational forces.
  • Mass is not an electrical variable, and G is a constant that is measured with slight variations due to measurement methods.
  • Newton's equations can answer questions about gravitational forces and orbital mechanics, contrary to claims made by critics like Wal Thornhill.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.