Top 20 Worst Hollywood Remakes Of All Time
WatchMojo.com・17 minutes read
Remakes of iconic films like Nightmare on Elm Street, Swept Away, Jacob's Ladder, and Total Recall failed to capture the magic of the originals, leading to critical disappointment and lack of cult classic status. These remakes lacked the unique elements, performances, and storytelling that made the originals beloved by audiences and critics alike.
Insights
- Remakes of classic films often struggle to capture the essence and appeal of the originals, as seen in various examples like "The Nightmare on Elm Street," "Swept Away," and "Total Recall," where the remakes failed to resonate with audiences due to various shortcomings compared to the beloved originals.
- Many remakes suffer from a lack of unique elements that made the original films successful, such as iconic performances, visual style, narrative voice, or thematic depth, as evidenced by the failures of remakes like "Jacob's Ladder," "Oldboy," "Red Dawn," and "Arthur," highlighting the importance of preserving the distinctive qualities that made the originals memorable.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
Why did the 2010 Nightmare on Elm Street remake fall short?
The 2010 Nightmare on Elm Street remake with Jackie L Haley failed to live up to the original franchise due to the beloved portrayal of Freddy Krueger by Robert England. Fans missed England's iconic performance, leading to disappointment with the remake.
What caused Madonna's film Swept Away to be a critical failure?
Madonna's 2002 film Swept Away, a remake of an Italian classic, became the lowest-rated movie of her career due to critical failure. The film lacked the charm and appeal of the original, failing to resonate with audiences and critics alike.
Why did the 2019 Jacob's Ladder remake not capture the original's cult classic status?
The 2019 remake of Jacob's Ladder failed to capture the original's cult classic status due to the lack of hallucinogenic imagery and standout performance from Tim Robbins. These key elements were missing in the remake, leading to its inability to resonate with fans of the original.
What caused the 2012 Total Recall remake to be forgettable?
The 2012 Total Recall remake lacked the unique characters and effects that made the original memorable. Without these key elements, the remake failed to leave a lasting impact on audiences, resulting in a forgettable sci-fi film.
Why did the 2012 Red Dawn remake fail to capture the original's essence?
Despite Chris Hemsworth's star power, the 2012 Red Dawn remake failed to capture the visceral stakes and thematic subtext of the original. The remake lacked the depth and impact of the original, leading to its inclusion on the list of failed remakes.
Related videos
Friendly Space Ninja
Tired Franchises Hollywood Refuses To Let Die
Despot of Antrim
Disney Remakes Need to Die (and Peter Pan and Wendy is Unwatchable Trash)
MandaloreGaming
Dead Space Remake Review
The Thrifty Typewriter
The Terminator Universe Explained: Multiverse & Time Travel
The Cosmonaut Variety Hour
Every Star Wars Movie Reviewed - Pt. 2 - The Prequels
Summary
00:00
Remakes that fell short of originals
- The original Nightmare on Elm Street franchise was beloved for Robert England's portrayal of Freddy Krueger, making the 2010 remake with Jackie L Haley fall short.
- Madonna's 2002 film Swept Away, a remake of an Italian classic, was a critical failure and the lowest-rated movie of her career.
- The 2019 remake of Jacob's Ladder lacked the original's hallucinogenic imagery and standout performance from Tim Robbins, failing to capture the same cult classic status.
- The Wolfman 2010 remake, despite Benicio del Toro's performance, fell flat compared to other werewolf movies with more believable creatures.
- The 2012 Total Recall remake lacked the original's unique characters and effects, resulting in a forgettable sci-fi film.
- Spike Lee's 2013 remake of Oldboy failed to resonate with audiences, lacking the unique narrative voice seen in his other films.
- The 2012 Red Dawn remake, despite Chris Hemsworth's star power, failed to capture the visceral stakes and thematic subtext of the original.
- The 2010 Clash of the Titans remake suffered from rushed CGI effects and lacked the story and spectacle balance of the original.
- John Carpenter's 2005 The Fog remake failed to capture his signature style and star power, resulting in a lackluster tribute to the original.
- Russell Brand's 2011 Arthur remake couldn't match Dudley Moore's likability and balance of comedy and drama, leading to its inclusion on this list.
17:32
Failed Remakes: Godzilla, Wicker Man, Rollerball
- Godzilla was so poorly received that it led to the creature being renamed Zilla in Japan to avoid confusion, marking a significant departure from the original character.
- The 2006 remake of "The Wicker Man" by Neil LaBute, starring Nicholas Cage, failed as a horror film due to its reliance on cheap scares and the absence of the original's palpable atmosphere, urging viewers to opt for the 70s classic instead.
- The 2002 remake of "Rollerball" sacrificed the original's social commentary on class, money, and power for mindless action, resulting in a film devoid of substance and brainless entertainment, diverging significantly from the original's thematic depth.
