THE DISTURBING TRUTH ABOUT "MAHATMA GANDHI"
Too Harsh・2 minutes read
Mahatma Gandhi, known as the Father of the Nation in India, faced criticism for his extreme views on race and caste, including advocating for the removal of Africans from certain areas. Despite controversies surrounding his personal life and experiments, Gandhi's evolving views eventually led to a call for the abolition of the caste system in 1935, although his role in India's independence was questioned by British leaders in comparison to other movements like the Royal Indian Navy Revolt of 1946.
Insights
- Gandhi's early beliefs in racial superiority and caste discrimination were heavily criticized by historians and scholars, but his later evolution towards advocating for the abolition of the caste system in 1935 showcases a significant shift in his views over time.
- British Prime Minister Clement Attlee's discussion with Bengal Governor Justice PV Chakraborty highlighted doubts about Gandhi's impact on India's independence, with the decision to leave India primarily attributed to military activities like Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the Royal Indian Navy Revolt of 1946, rather than Gandhi's movements, emphasizing the minimal influence of Gandhi's actions on British decision-making.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
Who is Mahatma Gandhi?
Mahatma Gandhi, known as the Father of the Nation in India, was a controversial figure during the pre-independence era. He played a significant role in India's freedom struggle through nonviolent means.
What were Gandhi's views on race?
Gandhi initially held extreme views on race and caste, including beliefs in white superiority and advocating for the removal of Africans from certain areas. However, over time, his views evolved, leading to a call for the abolition of the caste system in 1935.
What controversial practices did Gandhi engage in?
Gandhi engaged in controversial practices such as sexual experiments, celibacy practices, and close relationships with young women in his ashram. These practices, including encouraging followers to sleep and bathe together while maintaining chastity, caused controversy and criticism.
How did Gandhi's colleagues view his actions?
Gandhi's colleagues, including Sardar Patel and Subhash Chandra Bose, criticized his controversial practices and experiments. Despite disapproval, Gandhi continued his actions, leading to further separation from other freedom fighters.
What was the British Prime Minister's view on Gandhi's role in India's independence?
The British Prime Minister, Clement Attlee, questioned Gandhi's impact on India's independence movements. He emphasized the significance of military activities like the Royal Indian Navy Revolt of 1946, stating that Gandhi's influence was minimal in their decision to leave India.
Related videos
BuzzFeed Unsolved Network
The Dark Side of Mahatma Gandhi
Firstpost
Who Drove the British Away - Mahatma Gandhi or Subhas Chandra Bose? | Flashback with Palki Sharma
Digraj Singh Rajput
Nationalism in INDIA | New One Shot | CBSE Class 10 History 2024-25
bookboxinc
Mahatma Gandhi, The Salt March, The Dandi March: Learn English (IND)
Vedantu Master Tamil
Nationalism in India Class 10 CBSE Social Science | Shimon Sir | V Master Tamil
Summary
00:00
Gandhi: Controversial Father of Indian Nation
- Mahatma Gandhi, a controversial figure in pre-independence India, is known as the Father of the Nation by many.
- Gandhi's early life involved struggles with legal studies in London and Bombay, leading to a realization of his lack of confidence in Indian law.
- In 1893, Gandhi faced racial discrimination in South Africa, sparking his beliefs in white superiority and the uncivilized nature of Africans.
- Gandhi's extreme views on race and caste, including advocating for the removal of Africans from certain areas, were criticized by historians and scholars.
- Over time, Gandhi's views on the caste system evolved, eventually leading to a call for its abolition in 1935.
- Gandhi's personal life included controversial sexual experiments, celibacy practices, and interactions with young women in his ashram.
- Gandhi's experiments with celibacy involved encouraging followers to sleep and bathe together while maintaining chastity.
- Gandhi's close relationships with young women, including sleeping without clothes, were documented in letters and diaries, causing controversy within his ashram.
- Despite criticism from colleagues like Sardar Patel, Gandhi continued his experiments, leading to further disapproval and eventual separation from other freedom fighters like Subhash Chandra Bose.
- A conversation between British Prime Minister Clement Attlee and Bengal Governor Justice PV Chakraborty suggested that Gandhi's role in India's independence was questioned, with doubts raised about the impact of his movements on British decision-making.
11:55
Netaji's Role in British Exit from India
- The main reason cited by the British Prime Minister for their decision to leave India was the military activity of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the Royal Indian Navy Revolt of 1946, which reduced the loyalty of the military towards Britain. Despite being asked about the influence of Gandhiji's actions, the British PM stated that it was minimal, emphasizing the significance of the Royal Indian Navy Mutiny in their departure.
