Testosterone | Lecture by sociomedical scientist Rebecca Jordan-Young
Radboud Reflects・58 minutes read
The lecture focuses on the societal implications of testosterone, challenging traditional beliefs about its role in masculinity and behavior, ultimately highlighting the complexity and unpredictability of its effects. Testosterone is linked to various social phenomena, including aggression and risk-taking, with narratives and cultural beliefs shaping scientific research and societal perceptions of masculinity.
Insights
- Testosterone is intricately linked to societal constructs of masculinity, impacting various aspects of human behavior and social dynamics beyond traditional views as a male sex hormone, challenging simplistic narratives and highlighting its complexity.
- The study of testosterone reveals the entanglement of scientific research with social narratives, emphasizing the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration to enhance accuracy, challenge biased views, and explore how social practices influence biological processes, urging a shift towards a more holistic understanding of gender identities and human characteristics.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What is the lecture about?
Testosterone and its societal implications
Who will discuss testosterone's impact?
Rebecca Jordan Young
What is testosterone associated with?
Masculinity and social phenomena
Who will moderate the discussion?
Simone Koosman
What are some societal implications of testosterone?
Inequalities, aggression, and anti-social behavior
Related videos
Iman Gadzhi
The 5 Habits Keeping MEN Weak
DW Documentary
Testosterone — new discoveries about the male hormone | DW Documentary
unbubble
Männer zu weich geworden? Moderne vs. traditionelle Männlichkeit | 13 Fragen | unbubble
RootsofEmpathy
Dr Lise Eliot - The story of pink and blue
The Infographics Show
Weird Facts About Testosterone in Men
Summary
00:00
"Testosterone: Masculinity, Society, and Health Implications"
- The lecture focuses on testosterone, exploring its role in masculinity and societal implications.
- Rebecca Jordan Young, a gender and diversity studies expert, will discuss testosterone's impact.
- Testosterone has been historically linked to masculinity and various social phenomena.
- The lecture will last approximately 40 minutes, followed by a discussion with historian Stefan.
- Simone Koosman, a philosopher at Harvard University, will moderate the discussion.
- Rebecca Jordan Young is a professor at Barnard College, while Stefan is a professor at Howard University.
- Testosterone has been associated with rejuvenation experiments and various claims of health benefits.
- Researchers have explored testosterone's effects on sexual development and differences between genders.
- Testosterone's influence extends beyond sexual characteristics to impact various biological processes.
- The lecture highlights the complexity and unpredictability of testosterone's effects, challenging the notion of it as solely a male sex hormone.
18:04
"Testosterone's Role in Gender Inequality"
- Tea is often blamed for inequalities between men and women in various aspects of life.
- Testosterone is linked to aggression and anti-social behavior, leading to more men being incarcerated.
- Far-right politicians have associated migrant men with being "Islamic testosterone bombs" to justify anti-immigration sentiments.
- "Tea talk" refers to the intertwining of folklore and science around testosterone, validating cultural beliefs about masculinity.
- Testosterone and estrogen are framed as a binary pair, perpetuating the idea of a "war of the sexes."
- Testosterone is often used as a substitute for evidence in arguments, giving them a scientific veneer.
- Testosterone is symbolized as a biological force, embodying values of objectivity and science.
- Testosterone is anthropomorphized in narratives, with the molecule being portrayed as a conscious being with intentions.
- Scientific research on testosterone is influenced by the sex hormone concept, shaping how information is gathered and interpreted.
- Research on testosterone and risk-taking is structured around assumptions in behavioral neuroendocrinology, linking high testosterone levels with risk preferences.
36:55
Testosterone's Role in Risk-Taking and Entrepreneurship
- Entrepreneurship and testosterone association explored by evolutionary psychologists and a business professor.
- Money projection into deep human history, connecting to evolution.
- Risk and status linked to testosterone and occupational status.
- Iowa gambling task used to measure risk-taking, not aligning with evolutionary story.
- Study on young male traders in London linking testosterone to risk-taking.
- Testosterone influenced by various factors, not just a hormone.
- Study on male traders showing higher testosterone on profitable days.
- Lack of data supporting the hypothesis of rising profits leading to more risk.
- Finance portrayed as pinnacle of risk, overlooking other factors.
- Testosterone regulation in women athletes causing harm, challenging static views of testosterone.
56:26
"Testosterone, Masculinity, and Social Narratives"
- The aging market is targeting younger men to capitalize on insecurities about masculinity, suggesting even men in their twenties should boost testosterone.
- Research indicates men in lower-status occupations have higher testosterone levels, leading to impulsive, aggressive behavior and struggles in education and professional life.
- There is a narrative linking testosterone levels to class structure, with too much testosterone hindering success in higher education and professional roles.
- Testosterone is seen as a precision technology allowing men to choose specific aspects of masculinity, potentially stabilizing concerns about masculinity.
- Testosterone is viewed as a solution to threats to masculinity, seemingly rendering manliness immune to social and historical influences.
- Studies on testosterone often lack interdisciplinary collaboration, leading to essentializing narratives that may not accurately reflect social realities.
- The field of testosterone research is complex due to the social meanings attached to testosterone levels, requiring rigorous examination of implications.
- The presence of narratives in scientific research is common, with stories shaping scientific endeavors and interpretations.
- Interdisciplinary research could lead to more accurate scientific findings and challenge narratives that support social hierarchies.
- It is crucial to consider the influence of stories on science and vice versa, as well as promoting interdisciplinary collaboration to enhance the accuracy of scientific research and challenge biased narratives in social discourse on gender identities.
01:14:47
"Social analysis redefines testosterone research boundaries"
- Bringing social analysis into the study of testosterone could lead to a shift in focus towards understanding how social practices and hierarchies influence our bodies at a molecular level, a perspective largely unexplored in current research.
- New approaches in neuroscience, such as the Neuro Gendering Network, challenge traditional binary gender distinctions by examining a wide range of traits associated with masculinity and femininity, revealing a more complex and nuanced understanding of human characteristics beyond rigid gender norms.
- The current scientific approach to studying testosterone is deeply entrenched in established research methodologies and funding structures, making it challenging for researchers to deviate from traditional paths, potentially hindering the integration of new perspectives and findings into broader social and cultural narratives.
