Login Get started

Something Deeply Hidden | Sean Carroll | Talks at Google

Talks at Google・46 minutes read

Quantum mechanics is explained and explored, challenging conventional wisdom around its complexity and understanding. The Copenhagen interpretation and Everett's many-worlds theory offer contrasting views on wave function collapse and the nature of reality in quantum mechanics.

Insights

Contrary to popular belief, quantum mechanics is considered comprehensible by the speaker, challenging Richard Feynman's assertion that no one truly understands it.
The debate between the Copenhagen interpretation and Hugh Everett's many-worlds theory highlights fundamental disagreements in quantum mechanics, focusing on the observer's role and the treatment of wave function collapse, with implications for the nature of reality and the understanding of quantum phenomena.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

What is quantum mechanics?
The study of subatomic particles and their behavior.
Who proposed the Copenhagen interpretation?
Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg.
What is the measurement problem in quantum mechanics?
Uncertainty surrounding when and how measurements occur.
What is the many-worlds interpretation?
Theory proposing multiple parallel universes.
How does quantum mechanics relate to gravity?
Quantum entanglement may provide insights into gravity.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Decoding Quantum Mechanics: Understanding the Unseen

Quantum mechanics is the topic of discussion, aiming to make it more understandable.
The speaker believes quantum mechanics is comprehensible, contrary to popular belief.
Richard Feynman famously stated that no one truly understands quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics is crucial for understanding various phenomena, from the sun shining to transistors working.
Physicists have focused on making predictions rather than deeply understanding quantum mechanics.
The traditional model of the atom, with electrons orbiting the nucleus, is flawed due to energy loss.
The concept of the electron as a wave function, rather than a particle, was introduced to address stability issues.
Erwin Schrodinger's equation describes the behavior of electron wave functions.
The behavior of electrons in experiments like cloud chambers challenges the understanding of quantum mechanics.
The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics involves wave function collapse upon measurement, leading to probabilistic outcomes.

12:23

Debates on Quantum Reality: Perspectives and Implications

The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics raises concerns about the wave function's representation of reality, leading to debates on whether it is a complete description or just a predictive tool.
Einstein proposed hidden variable theories, suggesting that the wave function coexists with particles, challenging the idea of the wave function as reality.
Physicists using quantum mechanics prioritize predictions over understanding reality, highlighting a divide in perspectives within the field.
The measurement problem questions what constitutes a measurement, who can perform it, and when it occurs, with the Copenhagen interpretation failing to provide clear answers.
Hugh Everett's interpretation simplifies quantum mechanics by emphasizing the universal wave function and the Schrodinger equation as the sole rules governing reality.
Everett's approach incorporates the concepts of entanglement and treating observers as quantum systems, challenging the traditional divide between classical and quantum realms.
Entanglement, exemplified by the Higgs boson's decay into entangled electrons, showcases how quantum mechanics necessitates considering the entire system's wave function rather than individual components.
Einstein's contribution to understanding entanglement, despite his reservations about quantum mechanics, highlights the phenomenon's implications for the measurement problem.
Schrodinger's cat experiment illustrates the concept of superposition in quantum mechanics, contrasting the Copenhagen and Everett interpretations in explaining the cat's state before and after observation.
The differing views on the observer's role in quantum mechanics, as seen in Copenhagen and Everett interpretations, reflect fundamental disagreements on the nature of reality within the field.

24:18

"Many-Worlds Theory: Quantum Mechanics and Reality"

In the Copenhagen interpretation, the cat in a superposition is observed by Niels Bohr, causing the wave function to collapse into either the cat being awake or asleep based on the observer's measurement.
Hugh Everett's quantum mechanics theory rejects wave function collapse, advocating for following the Schrodinger equation to predict outcomes without collapse, leading to a superposition of the cat being awake and asleep.
Decoherence, understood in the 1970s, explains how the environment interacts with the cat before observation, entangling with the cat's quantum states based on its awake or asleep status.
Everett's theory posits that the universe's wave function evolves into separate branches, creating distinct worlds where observers see different outcomes, without the need for separate wave functions.
Everett's many-worlds interpretation suggests that the wave function naturally splits into separate branches, evolving independently, leading to the existence of multiple worlds.
The number of worlds in Everett's theory is uncertain, with possibilities ranging from infinitely many to a finite but vast number, depending on the dimensionality of Hilbert space.
Rather than special events causing universe splits, Everett's theory implies a constant subdivision of the universe into different branches, with each event like radioactive decay duplicating the universe.
Objections to many-worlds theory based on the abundance of universes are countered by the theory's alignment with quantum mechanics, where the potential for multiple worlds always existed.
The testability of Everett's theory is emphasized, with the ability to falsify it by finding variables beyond the wave function or observing deviations from Schrodinger equation predictions.
Probability in quantum mechanics, absent in Everett's postulates, arises from self-locating uncertainty, where observers within the wave function branches are uncertain of their specific position until observation, aligning with the Copenhagen interpretation's probability rule.

36:26

Quantum Mechanics: From Classical to Gravity

Physicists typically create quantum mechanical models by starting with a classical description and then quantizing it.
Graduate school or undergraduate education teaches rules for converting classical descriptions into quantum theories, resulting in a wave function in Hilbert space.
Nature is presumed to be inherently quantum mechanical, not needing a classical theory first.
Many-worlds quantum mechanics, like Everett's approach, is leaner, focusing on wave functions and the Schrodinger equation.
Other quantum mechanics approaches incorporate classical features to explain why the world appears classical.
Quantum gravity remains a challenge, as classical general relativity cannot be successfully quantized.
String theory and loop quantum gravity are alternative approaches to understanding gravity.
The relationship between geometry, entanglement, and energy in quantum field theory suggests a way to understand gravity.
Entanglement in quantum field theory correlates with energy and geometry, hinting at a connection between them.
The emergence of space and its geometry from quantum entanglement is a promising avenue for understanding gravity.

49:01

"Branching Universe: Quantum Mechanics Simplified"

The wave function of the universe branches when observing particles, allowing for different interpretations of how this branching occurs.
Branches of the wave function are human constructs to understand the universe, with descriptions that can be instantaneous or slower than the speed of light.
Two major research questions in this view of the universe are the probability question and the structure question, which remain unanswered.
If the universe has a finite number of branches and branching occurs continuously, there is a possibility of running out of branches, leading to a state of thermal equilibrium.
Quantum mechanics involves math that is not overly complex, making it accessible for those interested in studying the foundations of physics.
Resources like David Albert's book "Quantum Mechanics and Experience" and David Wallace's book "The Emergent Multiverse" are recommended for individuals wanting to delve into the foundations of physics.

Try it yourself — It’s free.