Overview of the American Legal System and the Life of a Case (2019)

University of Virginia School of Law・2 minutes read

Heytens discusses key legal concepts such as the types of law, courts, and the hierarchy of the U.S. legal system, stressing the importance of understanding these fundamentals. The U.S. judicial system is complex, involving state and federal courts, multiple levels of courts, and various stages in the life cycle of a case, with limited appeals and preclusion doctrines in place.

Insights

  • Understanding the hierarchy of law in the United States is crucial, with federal law always taking precedence over state law, even in conflicts between the two unless federal law is proven invalid.
  • The U.S. legal system is intricate, comprising 51 separate judicial systems with both state and federal courts operating in each state, leading to a complex web of interactions and overlaps between different court systems.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What are the main topics covered in the discussion?

    Types of law, types of courts, case life cycle

  • What forms of law are discussed in the legal system?

    Constitutions, treaties, legislation, regulations, common law

  • How does the hierarchy of law function in the US legal system?

    Federal law supersedes state law

  • What is the role of appellate courts in the US legal system?

    Assess trial court decisions

  • How does the life cycle of a case progress in the legal system?

    Commencement, pretrial, trial, appeal, preclusion

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Introduction to US Legal System Essentials"

  • Toby Heytens aims to introduce the United States legal system in the next 15 minutes, emphasizing the introductory nature of the discussion.
  • Heytens reflects on his own experience as a law student without lawyers in his family, highlighting the importance of understanding basic legal concepts.
  • The discussion will cover three main topics: types of law, types of courts, and the life cycle of a case.
  • Types of law encompass sources, forms, and hierarchy, emphasizing the need for a law giver in the legal system.
  • Law in the United States derives from either the federal government or state governments, with local laws ultimately stemming from state or federal authority.
  • Forms of law include constitutions, treaties, legislation, regulations, and common law, each playing a distinct role in the legal system.
  • Constitutions serve as the highest form of law, treaties are international agreements, legislation is enacted by legislative bodies, regulations are issued by administrative agencies, and common law is judge-made law.
  • The hierarchy of law dictates that federal law supersedes state law, as outlined in the supremacy clause of the federal constitution.
  • Understanding the hierarchy is crucial, with federal law always taking precedence over state law, regardless of the level or type of law involved.
  • Heytens stresses the importance of grasping these fundamental legal concepts, as they form the basis for further exploration throughout legal education.

12:17

Hierarchy of US Legal System: Federal vs State

  • In conflicts between federal and state law, federal law supersedes state law unless proven invalid.
  • Federal law may not apply in certain situations, allowing state law to govern.
  • If federal law is deemed invalid due to violating the Constitution or exceeding federal authority, state law remains in effect.
  • The Constitution always prevails over statutes, even at the state level.
  • Constitutions and statutes take precedence over common law, which can be overridden by legislation.
  • Trial courts are where most disputes begin, involving juries, witnesses, and evidence.
  • Appellate courts do not involve juries and rely on written arguments.
  • The US legal system includes 51 separate judicial systems, with each state having its own courts.
  • Each state in the US has both state and federal courts operating simultaneously.
  • Federal courts of appeals and state supreme courts are subject to the US Supreme Court but not to each other, creating tension.

23:44

"Multiple Courts Hear Disputes in US"

  • Disputes can be heard by more than one court, not limited to one court only.
  • Most disputes can be heard in multiple courts, including state to state and state to federal.
  • Disputes can be brought in both state and federal courts.
  • State courts can hear federal law cases, and federal courts can hear state law cases.
  • No court can hear every dispute, each court has limits on the cases they can handle.
  • State courts apply both state and federal law, while federal courts apply both state and federal law.
  • State courts can apply laws from other states in certain cases.
  • The U.S. judicial system is complex and involves various court systems.
  • The life cycle of a case includes commencement, pretrial, trial, appeal, and preclusion stages.
  • Commencement involves filing a complaint or indictment to initiate litigation and notifying the defendant.

35:47

"Summary judgment favors defendants in trials"

  • Defendants find it easier to obtain summary judgment at trial compared to plaintiffs.
  • Defendants typically argue that the plaintiff lacks evidence to support their case.
  • Settlement or one party giving up is common throughout the pretrial phase.
  • Few civil cases proceed to trial due to the likelihood of summary judgment or settlement.
  • Criminal law involves plea bargains, equivalent to civil case settlements.
  • Very few cases actually go to trial, with trial advocacy and evidence courses covering trial rules.
  • Appeals are limited to cases decided by trial judges or those that go to trial.
  • Appellate courts follow standards of review to assess trial court decisions.
  • Preclusion doctrines prevent relitigating resolved disputes, with claim and issue preclusion being key concepts.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.