Monetization will ruin the internet (again)

Rosencreutz・2 minutes read

The text discusses the impact of monetization and algorithms on platforms like YouTube and Twitter, focusing on the challenges creators face in balancing creativity with production and understanding platform dynamics and rules. It also mentions the resistance against algorithmic control and the interconnected nature of digital platforms, emphasizing the complexities of navigating online spaces.

Insights

  • Monetization on platforms like YouTube and Medium has shifted the focus from genuine creativity to production, impacting content quality and user engagement.
  • The introduction of paywalls on platforms like Medium raises debates on balancing profitability with information dissemination, potentially hindering access to critical content.
  • The collapse of platforms like Lunyr due to flawed monetization schemes underscores the importance of aligning user incentives with platform goals to ensure sustainability and quality.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How do platforms like Instagram adapt to market trends?

    Platforms like Instagram adapt to market trends by changing their site layouts and designs to stay relevant. For example, Instagram transformed into a TikTok-like platform to keep up with the popularity of short-form video content. This adaptation showcases how platforms evolve to meet user preferences and behaviors, ensuring they remain engaging and competitive in the digital landscape.

  • What is the impact of paywalls on digital journalism?

    Paywalls in digital journalism present challenges in balancing profitability with information dissemination. While they can generate revenue for publishers, they may limit access to crucial information for readers who cannot afford subscriptions. Big journalism sites often have paywalled articles on significant topics like elections or pandemics, raising questions about the accessibility of vital news and the ethics of monetizing information.

  • How does YouTube's algorithm influence content creation practices?

    YouTube's algorithm plays a significant role in shaping content creation practices by influencing what type of content gets visibility and engagement. Creators often navigate the algorithm's nuances, such as rules on clickbait and viewer retention, to optimize their videos for success. The lack of transparency in the algorithm leads creators to rely on folk practices and survivorship bias, like creating numerous videos to increase chances of success. Understanding and manipulating the algorithm has become crucial for creators to thrive on the platform.

  • What challenges do content creators face on platforms like Twitter?

    Content creators on platforms like Twitter face challenges such as navigating evolving monetization strategies and dealing with corporate censorship. Twitter's resistance to advertisers and emphasis on user curation can impact content visibility and reach. Additionally, the presence of bots as a nuisance on the platform adds another layer of complexity for creators to manage. Elon Musk's proposed changes to Twitter, like a paid verification system and reduced ads, have sparked skepticism and humor, reflecting the platform's ongoing struggle with monetization and user experience.

  • How do platforms like Medium and Lunyr monetize content?

    Platforms like Medium and Lunyr monetize content through various models, such as paywalls and ad revenue. Medium offers premium articles behind a paywall, with paying members supporting creators through a kudos system based on likes. This model incentivizes writers to produce high-quality content that resonates with readers. On the other hand, Lunyr aimed to monetize articles through ads, but its reliance on user-generated content led to quality and plagiarism issues. Understanding how these platforms monetize content is essential for creators looking to leverage them for their work.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Monetization and Recognition in Online Platforms

  • The video is a reflection on the creator's first year on Youtube, exploring platforms, attention economies, and the desire for recognition in creative works.
  • It delves into the monetization of creativity, highlighting how it can hinder true creativity by incentivizing production over genuine creation.
  • The focus shifts to the twofold path of monetization: attracting advertisers and compensating content creators, leading to a shift from creation to production.
  • Changes in site layouts and designs, like Instagram's transformation into a TikTok-like platform, showcase how platforms adapt to market trends.
  • The text introduces a fictional site, Embler, illustrating its evolution from a picture-sharing platform to a text-based forum, emphasizing user interaction and personality.
  • Embler eventually introduces a payment program for top contributors, altering the content tone and encouraging users to aim for recognition and follower growth.
  • Medium, a platform for longer-form content, is likened to "Youtube for sapiosexuals," offering a space for writers to monetize their articles.
  • Medium's monetization model involves premium articles behind a paywall, with paying members supporting creators through a kudos system based on likes.
  • The platform's culture revolves around advice on succeeding within the platform, fostering a productivity-focused environment.
  • The summary concludes by highlighting the productivity cult within Medium, where content is geared towards achieving success on the platform.

12:33

Debate over paywalls in digital journalism

  • Majority of articles encountered were paywalled guides to success, even in incognito mode.
  • The decision to implement paywalls is debated, with arguments for and against it.
  • Paywalls offer five free uses a month, potentially not fully blocking critical information.
  • Digital journalism faces challenges balancing profitability with information dissemination.
  • Big journalism sites have paywalled articles on crucial topics like elections or pandemics.
  • Medium, a platform, emphasizes the paywall for famous individuals to post content.
  • Medium's paywall is not solely altruistic but a means of earning.
  • Lunyr, a decentralized Wikipedia-like platform, aimed to monetize articles through ads.
  • Lunyr's model incentivized articles for views, potentially compromising quality and content diversity.
  • Lunyr's reliance on user-generated content and decentralized moderation led to quality and plagiarism issues.

25:09

Decentralized platform fails due to poor quality.

  • People began translating articles into foreign languages using Google Translate, leading to poor quality content being shared without recourse for quality control.
  • The competitive collaboration model of the platform disincentivized article improvement, resulting in a flawed monetization scheme.
  • The platform's premise of being decentralized and free from censorship was questioned, especially as initial articles were of low quality.
  • The company Lunyr, with only three employees, faced failure due to incompetence rather than malicious intent.
  • The platform's collapse highlighted the importance of aligning user incentives with the platform's goals.
  • Transitioning to YouTube, the narrator found a community focused on creating content and navigating the platform's algorithms.
  • YouTube communities emphasized hustle and mysticism around the platform's algorithm, shaping content creation practices.
  • The Algorithm on YouTube is revered and mystified, influencing content creation practices and standards.
  • YouTube's rules on clickbait are nuanced, focusing on deceptive practices rather than predictable curiosity fishing.
  • The lack of transparency in YouTube's algorithm leads to creators relying on folk practices and loose science to navigate the platform.

38:13

YouTube Success: Beware Survivorship Bias

  • Elon Musk reply guy Mr Beast advised making 100 videos for success, showcasing survivorship bias.
  • Many individuals, including middle schoolers, followed Mr Beast's advice to create 100 videos.
  • People lower in the advice hierarchy also fall for survivorship bias, analyzing large channels for success patterns.
  • Blindly analyzing large channels for success overlooks the journey to success and presumes a universal path.
  • The assumption that success from 1 to 1 million subscribers follows the same rules is a massive blind spot.
  • YouTube's attention economy challenges the idea that everyone can succeed with the right tactics.
  • Communities built around YouTube aim to exit and establish their own communities, emphasizing self-reliance.
  • Collaboration among YouTubers is crucial to weaken the algorithm's hold and support each other's growth.
  • A collective called F the Algorithm aims to circumvent YouTube's algorithm through community support.
  • YouTube's monetization culture influences creators at all levels, shaping creativity and production practices.

51:27

Navigating YouTube's Monetization Culture and Challenges

  • The bartender's outfit and the drink listed on the sandwich board outside the bar are key indicators of the boss's potential disapproval of music taste.
  • Corporate censorship on platforms like YouTube is driven by corporations rather than concepts like the First Amendment or cancel culture.
  • Content creators like Evie Lupine face challenges navigating the platform's rules and facing inconsistent bans.
  • Monetization on YouTube has shifted content creation incentives, with success often tied to understanding and manipulating the algorithm.
  • Channels dedicated to teaching about the algorithm paradoxically rely on their audience's desperation for success.
  • Larger channels can pivot content due to their established niche, while smaller channels struggle to gain traction.
  • Advice from YouTube gurus is subjective and often focuses on growing within niches rather than rapid pivots.
  • YouTube's monetization culture has led to the commodification of content and the creation of guides for aspiring creators.
  • The internet's commodification of human interaction and content creation has long been a business-driven endeavor.
  • Twitter's evolving monetization strategies, like paid verification, reflect broader issues with online platforms and their ownership.

01:04:22

Twitter's Role in Activism and Monetization

  • Twitter is a platform with practical uses for activists and outreach programs, aiding in organization and information dissemination during events like the Floyd protests and the Arab Spring.
  • Twitter's features allow for easy content circulation and curation of one's feed, with a focus on following individuals rather than ideas.
  • The platform's resistance to advertisers is notable, with the ability to block ads and advertisers easily, emphasizing user curation.
  • Bots are a more significant nuisance on Twitter than ads, but they can also be blocked effectively, with the platform offering tools for user curation.
  • Elon Musk's plans for Twitter, including a paid verification system and reduced ads with Twitter Blue, are met with skepticism and humor, highlighting the platform's resistance to monetization.
  • Musk's lack of understanding of Twitter's user experience and culture is evident, leading to concerns about the platform's future direction.
  • The text explores the impact of monetization on platforms like Twitter, emphasizing the challenges of content creation and production within these spaces.
  • Efforts to resist the algorithm and change the dynamics of platform control are mentioned, highlighting the complexities of navigating digital spaces.
  • The text concludes with reflections on the limitations of online communities, the influence of monetization, and the interconnected nature of digital platforms and the concept of the Digital Commons.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.