Katana VS Longsword - The Sad TRUTH!
Cerberusarms・2 minutes read
The comparison between katana and longsword highlights their unique strengths and weaknesses, with each sword serving different purposes based on personal preference and intended use. European perspectives criticize the praise given to katanas in pop culture, showing bias towards their own ancestral swords.
Insights
- European perspectives often criticize the praise given to katanas in movies and anime, showing bias in comparisons to their own ancestral swords, revealing cultural influences on weapon preferences.
- The comparison between the katana and longsword highlights their unique strengths and intended purposes, akin to a 1911 versus a Glock, emphasizing that personal preference and intended use determine the better weapon, showcasing the importance of individual context in evaluating these iconic swords.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are the key differences between a katana and a longsword?
The katana has a shorter blade made of 1060 through hardened steel, focusing on speed and slashing, while the longsword has a longer blade made of 1075 spring steel, emphasizing range advantage, thrusting, and defense. Each sword has unique strengths and weaknesses, catering to different fighting styles and preferences.
How did katanas impact American pop culture?
Katanas had a significant influence on American pop culture, particularly during the 90s when martial arts movies and anime gained popularity. Their portrayal in media as iconic weapons of honor and skill contributed to their widespread recognition and admiration among audiences.
Why do European perspectives criticize katanas in comparison to longswords?
European perspectives often criticize the praise given to katanas in movies and anime, showing bias towards their own ancestral swords like the longsword. This criticism stems from a sense of cultural pride and historical significance attached to European swordsmanship, leading to differing opinions on the effectiveness and value of katanas.
What fighting styles do katana and longsword emphasize?
The longsword focuses on defensive cuts, thrusting, and follow-up attacks with its double-edged blade, while the katana emphasizes a brutal, victory-or-death approach with lightning-fast slashing and cutting techniques. Each sword's fighting style reflects its design and intended use, catering to different combat strategies and preferences.
Are katanas and longswords equally valuable in their own right?
Yes, both the katana and longsword are well-made entry-level blades with unique advantages and disadvantages. The katana excels in slashing and cutting, while the longsword is better suited for thrusting and defense. Personal preference and intended use determine the better weapon, highlighting the distinct roles and purposes of each sword in combat.
Related videos
Skallagrim
Samurai with a Longsword? - A Kenjutsu Master's Perspective
Let's ask Seki Sensei | Learn Katana Skills Online
How Would a Samurai Master Fight with a Longsword? (Shocking Findings)
Shadiversity
KATANA MYTHS PUT TO THE TEST!!! - Can a katana cut through armor? | #FUNCTIONALFANDOM
Modern History TV
GRUESOME result of medieval SWORD strike on HEAD.
The Shogunate
Samurai Swords: Evolution and Overview
Summary
00:00
Katana vs Longsword: A Comparative Analysis
- The comparison between katana and longsword is a long-standing debate, both being iconic weapons of their time.
- The swords were purchased from the same manufacturer, Ronin, priced at around $350 each.
- The katana has a 30-inch blade made of 1060 through hardened steel, while the longsword has a 36-inch blade made of 1075 spring steel.
- European perspectives often criticize the praise given to katanas in movies and anime, showing bias in comparisons to their own ancestral swords.
- Katanas had a significant impact on American pop culture, especially during the 90s when martial arts movies and anime were popular.
- The longsword offers a range advantage, allowing for safe thrusts and follow-up attacks with its double-edged blade.
- The longsword's cross guard provides reliable protection and can be used as a bludgeoning weapon in close combat.
- The katana's speed compensates for its lack of range, enabling lightning-fast strikes but requiring the user to close the distance.
- The fighting style differs between the two swords, with the longsword focusing on defensive cuts and the katana emphasizing a brutal, victory-or-death approach.
- The katana excels in slashing and cutting, while the longsword is more suited for thrusting, with each sword having its unique advantages and disadvantages.
17:54
Katana vs Long Sword: Unique Strengths Compared
- The katana and long sword are both well-made entry-level blades, with the katana excelling in slashing while the long sword is better for thrusts and defense, highlighting their distinct roles and intended purposes.
- The comparison between the katana and long sword is akin to a 1911 versus a Glock, emphasizing that personal preference and intended use determine the better weapon, with both swords having unique strengths and weaknesses that make them equally valuable in their own right.
