LoginGet started

JPL and the Space Age: The Breaking Point

NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory・71 minutes read

Failure is crucial for scientific success, emphasizing the thin line between success and failure. NASA's Mars missions faced challenges due to design flaws and coordination issues, leading to critical failures and a reevaluation of risk management practices.

Insights

  • Learning from failures is crucial for progress in science, with NASA emphasizing the need to focus on fixing problems rather than assigning blame, promoting collective learning and improvement in space exploration endeavors.
  • The Mars Climate Orbiter mission's failure due to a unit discrepancy between English and metric measurements underscored the importance of meticulous attention to detail and effective communication, leading to a reinvention of the Mars program post-failure to ensure stringent flight rules and increased support for successful missions.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • Why is failure considered crucial for success in science?

    Failure is viewed as an essential component of achieving success in science because it allows individuals to learn from their mistakes and improve their approaches. People who experience failure tend to appreciate success more than those who do not face setbacks. The fear of personal anguish and reputation damage can hinder boldness in endeavors, but understanding that success and failure outcomes are closely intertwined emphasizes the importance of learning from failures and trying again. This process of trial and error is crucial for progress in scientific endeavors, as it leads to valuable insights and advancements in various fields.

  • What were the key strategies for NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in the late 1990s?

    In the late 1990s, NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) implemented several key strategies to usher in a new era of space exploration. The plan involved reducing staff, partnering with aerospace companies, and prioritizing cost-effective missions. Emphasizing smaller, less expensive, but more numerous missions, JPL aimed to optimize resources and enhance efficiency in space exploration endeavors. The successful launch of the Mars Global Surveyor, the first of nine US-based crafts planned for Mars exploration, showcased the effectiveness of these strategies in achieving mission objectives while maintaining fiscal responsibility.

  • What challenges did the Mars Global Surveyor mission face during its journey to Mars?

    The Mars Global Surveyor mission encountered several challenges during its journey to Mars, highlighting the complexities of space exploration. A solar array panel malfunction at launch posed potential mission-threatening issues, requiring engineers to identify and address secondary failures in the solar array. Delays in fixing the solar array disrupted orbit plots, necessitating the creation of a new sunlit orbit plan. Additionally, the spacecraft underwent aerobraking for a longer duration than planned, impacting budgets and schedules. Despite these obstacles, the spacecraft successfully entered Mars' orbit, leading to significant scientific discoveries about the planet's climate and atmosphere.

  • How did the Mars Climate Orbiter mission face critical issues leading to its failure?

    The Mars Climate Orbiter mission faced critical issues that ultimately led to its failure upon attempting to enter Mars' orbit. Navigation discrepancies arose due to a software error and the lack of GPS, relying on deep space network antennas for communication. Solar panel issues two months before Mars arrival required urgent fixes, adding to the mission's challenges. Despite concerns about navigation, a decision not to conduct an emergency maneuver was made, leading to a miscalculation in altitude that prevented the spacecraft from entering Mars' orbit. The mission's demise was attributed to poor communication, lack of staffing, and design flaws within the navigation team, underscoring the importance of meticulous planning and coordination in space exploration missions.

  • How did the Mars Polar Lander mission face scrutiny and challenges during its descent to Mars?

    The Mars Polar Lander mission faced intense scrutiny and challenges during its descent to Mars, highlighting the complexities of space exploration missions. The entry, descent, and landing process required precise mechanical activities, including parachute and heat shield separations, to ensure a successful landing. Communication sacrifices for cost-saving measures posed risks for future missions, emphasizing the need for comprehensive planning and risk management. Despite meticulous preparations, the loss of communication upon landing led to uncertainty and disappointment among the team, underscoring the importance of effective communication and support structures in space exploration endeavors.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Embracing Failure: Key to Scientific Success

  • Failure is seen as an essential part of achieving success in science.
  • People who experience failure appreciate success more than those who don't.
  • The fear of personal anguish and reputation damage hinders boldness in endeavors.
  • Describing processes in terms of winners and losers is detrimental.
  • Success and failure outcomes are very close, emphasizing the thin line between them.
  • Learning from failures and trying again is crucial for progress.
  • Success at the lab is based on credibility and visibility.
  • NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory was on the brink of a new era in space exploration in the late 1990s.
  • The new frontier emphasized smaller, less expensive, but more numerous missions.
  • The plan involved reducing staff, partnering with aerospace companies, and prioritizing cost-effective missions.

16:11

Mars Global Surveyor: Budget Success, Orbit Challenges

  • Mars Global Surveyor met its launch schedule and budget, returning $6 million to NASA.
  • The spacecraft successfully launched from Earth, heading towards Mars.
  • Mars Global Surveyor was the first of nine US-based crafts planned for Mars exploration over the next decade.
  • A solar array panel malfunctioned at launch, posing potential mission-threatening issues.
  • Engineers identified a secondary failure in the solar array, causing a 20-degree kink that needed reinforcement.
  • Delays in fixing the solar array disrupted orbit plots, requiring a new sunlit orbit plan to be created.
  • The spacecraft underwent aerobraking for a year and a half instead of the planned four months, impacting budgets and schedules.
  • Despite challenges, the spacecraft successfully entered Mars' orbit, leading to scientific discoveries.
  • Scientists aim to understand Mars' past warm, wet climate and the disappearance of its atmosphere.
  • The Mars Climate Orbiter and Mars Polar Lander missions were launched in 1998, aiming to explore Mars at a reduced cost due to innovative spacecraft design and construction methods.

34:03

"Challenges in Mars spacecraft production and launch"

  • Production line spacecraft for Mars missions are challenging due to the tight schedule.
  • John McNamee, an aerospace engineer, managed two missions simultaneously, emphasizing quick decision-making.
  • McNamee aimed for a lean team structure, deviating from JPL's usual oversight approach.
  • Cultural differences between JPL and contractors like Lockheed Martin caused tension.
  • John Casani, experienced in flagship missions, supported adapting to faster, better, cheaper methods.
  • Deep Space Two, a Mars mission experiment, faced challenges in surviving crash landings.
  • McNamee faced resistance in adding extra payloads to the spacecraft, impacting the mission's complexity.
  • Issues arose during the launch preparations, including last-minute software loading.
  • Despite challenges, the JPL-Lockheed team successfully launched two spacecraft on time and within budget.
  • Post-launch, problems emerged with the Mars missions, requiring adjustments due to design flaws.

49:16

Mars spacecraft failures in 1999 orbit.

  • Mars Polar Lander faced issues post-launch, intensifying in the spring and summer of 1999.
  • Mars Climate Orbiter encountered rotation due to solar radiation pressure.
  • Reaction wheels were used to counteract motion but spun too fast, necessitating thrusters to de-spin them.
  • Thrusters had to be fired every 17 hours, adding pressure on a skeleton crew.
  • Navigation data was unusable initially due to a software error.
  • Navigation discrepancies were noted but not formally reported or resolved.
  • Navigation complexities arose due to lack of GPS and reliance on deep space network antennas.
  • Solar panel issues arose two months before Mars arrival, requiring urgent fixes.
  • Despite navigation worries, a decision was made not to conduct an emergency maneuver.
  • The spacecraft ultimately failed to enter Mars' orbit due to a miscalculation in altitude.

01:04:11

Mars Orbiter Lost: Lessons in Failure and Recovery

  • The Mars Climate Orbiter mission faced a critical issue when the signal was lost upon reacquisition.
  • Communication lines went silent, prompting confusion and concern among the team.
  • Efforts were made to reestablish contact with the spacecraft, but no signal was received.
  • Richard Cook, the Mars Surveyor Operations Project Manager, was urgently brought in to provide updates to the public.
  • The spacecraft was believed to be undergoing autonomous recovery processes due to a fault.
  • Navigational data revealed a significant error in the spacecraft's position, causing worry about its survivability.
  • The navigation error was traced back to a discrepancy between English and metric units, leading to the spacecraft's demise.
  • The failure was attributed to poor communication, lack of staffing, and design flaws within the navigation team.
  • NASA acknowledged the serious error and emphasized the importance of learning from failures to improve future missions.
  • The focus shifted towards fixing the problem rather than assigning blame, highlighting the need for collective learning and improvement in space exploration endeavors.

01:18:37

Mission to Mars: A Risky Endeavor

  • The team faced the challenge of saving the Polar Lander after losing the Climate Orbiter.
  • Scrutiny was intense on the spacecraft design, with a thorough examination of potential flaws.
  • The entry, descent, and landing process required precise mechanical activities, including parachute and heat shield separations.
  • Communication during the mission was sacrificed for cost-saving measures, posing a risk for future missions.
  • David Paige, the Science Principal Investigator, had a deep passion for Mars, influenced by his father's Antarctic expeditions.
  • The mission aimed to search for water beneath Mars' surface, with uncertainties about its depth and abundance.
  • The Science team worked tirelessly, adapting plans after the Climate Orbiter loss, facing immense stress.
  • Detailed images from Mars Global Surveyor altered landing plans, revealing hazards in the landing area.
  • The spacecraft approached Mars for landing, with a tense atmosphere and cautious confidence among the team.
  • Despite meticulous preparations, communication was lost upon landing, leading to uncertainty and disappointment among the team.

01:34:15

"Lessons from Mars: Failure, Reinvention, Success"

  • Loss of Mars Polar Lander initially attributed to engine shutdown in final descent, but no crash site found.
  • Emphasis on need for balance in safety measures and team support to avoid devastating failures.
  • Ed Stone addresses lab post-failure, highlighting importance of learning from criticism and moving forward.
  • NASA and JPL criticized for ineffective risk management and organizational issues.
  • Mars program reinvented post-failure, leading to increased support and successful missions.
  • Mars Global Surveyor's successful mission ends in 2001, highlighting importance of stringent flight rules despite human error risks.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.