Jason Riley On “False Black Power?”

Hoover Institution36 minutes read

Jason Riley discusses the importance of human capital over political power in the black community, highlighting the historical shift in family structures and socio-economic outcomes. He emphasizes the need for addressing cultural attitudes, promoting education, and discouraging reliance on government aid to foster true empowerment and progress.

Insights

  • True black power is defined by human capital, such as cultural traits that create economic value, contrasting with false black power centered on political influence.
  • The shift from stable black family structures to single-parent households has led to a decline in cultural values like valuing education, impacting economic outcomes within the black community.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is the main argument in "Please Stop Helping Us"?

    The main argument is about the negative impact of certain well-intentioned policies on the black community.

  • What is the significance of the Moynihan report of 1965?

    The Moynihan report highlighted the rise of single-parent families in inner cities among black families.

  • How did the civil rights strategy shift in the 1960s?

    The civil rights strategy shifted towards acquiring political power.

  • What was the impact of Obama's presidency on racial dynamics?

    Obama's presidency led to racial division despite his symbolic significance.

  • How have cultural attitudes in the black community shifted over time?

    Cultural attitudes have shifted negatively with a decline in valuing education and intelligence.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"False Black Power" explores cultural vs political power.

  • Jason Riley is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a columnist for The Wall Street Journal, and a commentator for Fox News.
  • Riley earned a bachelor's degree in English from the State University of New York at Buffalo.
  • He authored books like "Please Stop Helping Us" and "False Black Power."
  • False black power is political power, while true black power is human capital, referring to cultural traits that produce economic value.
  • The Moynihan report of 1965 highlighted the rise of single-parent families in inner cities among black families.
  • Black scholars like Franklin Frazier had observed the breakdown of the black family structure before Moynihan's report.
  • Herbert Guttman critiqued Moynihan's attribution of the breakdown to slavery, citing historical data showing stable black marriages.
  • Prior to the 1960s, black children were mostly raised in two-parent households with stable marriages.
  • The civil rights strategy shifted towards acquiring political power, leading to increased black political representation.
  • Despite the increase in black political power, socio-economic advancement did not follow, as seen during the Obama administration.

17:29

Racial Politics in America: Obama to Trump

  • Obama's Justice Department investigated police shootings nationwide, leading to racial division.
  • Trump, not a racist, benefited from the decline of white guilt under his presidency.
  • White Americans saw Obama as a symbol of progress, aiming for a post-racial America.
  • Liberals, despite claiming post-racial desires, promote racial division for political gain.
  • Obama oversaw slow economic recovery for blacks, yet received overwhelming support.
  • Trump's economy led to record-low black unemployment, increasing his black support.
  • Historical factors, like the Republican Party's stance on civil rights, influence black voting patterns.
  • Lack of Republican outreach to the black community results in low black voter turnout for Republicans.
  • Trump's missed opportunity to engage with the black community due to his controversial actions.
  • Reparations and affirmative action are debated, with skepticism on their effectiveness for black empowerment.

35:34

Rising out-of-wedlock births and cultural decline

  • In 1965, the out-of-wedlock birth rate was 25%, which has now risen to over 70%, surpassing 30% among white Americans.
  • The Great Society programs have created perverse incentives, leading to generational reliance on the safety net, which should be temporary.
  • The government should not replace a father in the home with financial aid, as it is ineffective at raising children.
  • Cultural attitudes in the black community have shifted negatively over the past 50 years, with a decline in valuing education and intelligence.
  • There is a need for leading thinkers and policymakers to stop making excuses for antisocial behavior in the black community.
  • Nearly a century of African American history, from Emancipation to the Great Society, has been forgotten or suppressed.
  • The mainstream view is changing to acknowledge the importance of discussing black cultural pathology and its impact on inequality.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.