In Gaza now, it’s worse than ethnic cleansing | Centre Stage
Al Jazeera English・21 minutes read
Elan Pape, a historian, challenges the traditional Israeli narrative, advocating for a one-state solution, criticizing Zionist ideology, and highlighting the historical context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Pape argues for de-Zionization, the right of Palestinian refugees to return, and sees a one-state solution as inevitable, with growing support among Palestinians.
Insights
- Elan Pape challenges the Zionist ideology, advocating for a one-state solution in Israel and Palestine, emphasizing the need for de-Zionization and highlighting the historical context of the conflict.
- Pape asserts that the current situation in Gaza constitutes genocide, linking Zionism to settler colonialism, and advocates for the right of Palestinians to return, emphasizing international law and the importance of the BDS movement in addressing injustices.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are Elan Pape's views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?
Elan Pape is known for challenging the traditional Israeli narrative and advocating for a one-state solution in Israel and Palestine. He discusses the dangers of Zionist ideology and emphasizes the need for de-Zionization or decolonization for a viable future.
How did Elan Pape's military service influence his perspectives?
Elan Pape's service in the Israeli military during the 1973 War and witnessing events in the Golan Heights and Lebanon in 1982 influenced his critical views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. These experiences contributed to his pessimistic outlook on the Oslo Accord and the rise of a more right-wing Israeli society.
What does Elan Pape assert about the current situation in Gaza?
Elan Pape asserts that the current situation in Gaza constitutes genocide, surpassing the ethnic cleansing of 1948. He highlights the international indifference enabling the crisis and links Zionism to settler colonialism in the ongoing conflict with Palestinians.
Why does Elan Pape advocate for a one-state solution in Israel and Palestine?
Elan Pape advocates for a one-state solution in Israel and Palestine, emphasizing the need for de-Zionization or decolonization for a viable future. He argues that advocating for the right of Palestinians to return is not anti-Semitic, citing international law and UN resolutions supporting their right to return to their homeland.
What is the significance of the BDS movement in addressing Israeli policies?
The BDS movement is seen as a crucial strategy to force change in Israeli policies and address the injustices inflicted on Palestinians. Support for a one-state solution is growing among Palestinians, especially the younger generation, with the belief that a shift towards this solution is inevitable.
Related videos
TRT World
Palestine Talks | Professor Avi Shlaim says “anti-Semitism was an European, not Arab problem”
Al Jazeera English
Is a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine possible? | Start Here
The Real News Network
The myth of Israel's 'democracy' w/Ilan Pappé | The Chris Hedges Report
Simcha Jacobovici
Expert Explains Palestine Facts YOU Need to Know
SOAS University of London
How I Stopped Being a Jew, Shlomo Sand, SOAS University of London
Summary
00:00
Elan Pape: Challenging Zionist Ideology for Peace
- Elan Pape, an Israeli historian and professor at the University of Exeter, is known for his views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and has authored books challenging the traditional Israeli narrative.
- Pape discusses the dangers of Zionist ideology and his vision for a one-state solution in Israel and Palestine.
- Pape's journey to speaking out in support of Palestinians involved deprogramming from early indoctrination and exposure to historical facts that challenged his beliefs.
- Serving in the Israeli military during the 1973 War and witnessing events in the Golan Heights and Lebanon in 1982 influenced Pape's critical views.
- Pape foresaw the rise of a more right-wing and extreme Israeli society due to the educational system, leading to his pessimistic outlook on the Oslo Accord.
- Understanding the historical context of 1948 is crucial to comprehending the creation of the Gaza Strip and the ongoing conflict in Gaza.
- Pape asserts that the current situation in Gaza constitutes genocide, surpassing the ethnic cleansing of 1948, with international indifference enabling the crisis.
- Pape links Zionism to settler colonialism, highlighting the logic of eliminating natives in the creation of Israel and the ongoing conflict with Palestinians.
- Pape advocates for a one-state solution in Israel and Palestine, emphasizing the need for de-Zionization or decolonization for a viable future.
- Pape argues that advocating for the right of Palestinians to return is not anti-Semitic, citing international law and UN resolutions supporting their right to return to their homeland.
16:31
"Israel's Immigration Policy and Palestinian Rights"
- The immigration of Jews to Israel is not a regular immigration law but an idea that any Jewish baby born anywhere is potentially an Israeli citizen.
- The distinction between the right of Palestinian refugees to return and the future immigration policy of a democratic State in Palestine is crucial.
- The disintegration of Zionism in Israel could lead to many Jews leaving, similar to what happened in South Africa.
- Support for a one-state solution is growing among Palestinians, especially the younger generation, with the belief that a shift towards this solution is inevitable.
- The BDS movement is seen as a crucial strategy to force change in Israeli policies and address the injustices inflicted on Palestinians.
