How We Got the Science of Weight Loss Wrong - with Giles Yeo

The Royal Institution・2 minutes read

The geneticist Jose questions the importance of calorie counting in relation to body weight, pointing out the impact of genes and the environment. He emphasizes the significance of protein and fiber in caloric availability and suggests improving diet quality by focusing on these elements rather than just counting calories.

Insights

  • The distinction between small c calories (heat calories) and big C calories (food calories) is crucial in understanding how the body extracts energy from food, impacting weight management.
  • Emphasizing the importance of protein and fiber in diet composition not only affects caloric availability but also influences satiety levels, making individuals feel fuller and potentially aiding in weight loss by reducing overall calorie intake.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is the significance of calorie counting?

    Calorie counting is a method used to track the energy content of food consumed and burned by the body. It is often associated with weight management and is believed to help individuals maintain a healthy weight or lose weight by creating a caloric deficit.

  • How do genes and the environment affect body weight?

    Genes and the environment play significant roles in determining body weight. Genetic factors can influence metabolism, fat storage, and hunger levels, impacting how the body processes and stores calories. Environmental factors such as diet, physical activity, and lifestyle choices also contribute to weight management.

  • What are Atwater factors and their relevance?

    Atwater factors are values used to calculate the caloric content of fats, carbohydrates, and proteins in food. These factors were developed by Wilbur Atwater in the late 1800s and are still utilized today to estimate the energy content of different macronutrients in food products.

  • How do high protein diets aid in weight loss?

    High protein diets are characterized by a higher percentage of total calories coming from protein. These diets are believed to promote weight loss by increasing satiety, reducing overall calorie intake, and potentially boosting metabolism through the thermic effect of food associated with protein digestion.

  • Why are ultra-processed foods considered unhealthy?

    Ultra-processed foods are typically low in protein and fiber while being high in sugar, salt, and fat. These foods are calorically dense and lack essential nutrients, contributing to poor diet quality and potential health issues. Their convenience, affordability, and long shelf life make them prevalent in diets, especially among those facing food insecurity.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Calories: Genes, Environment, and Digestive Process"

  • The speaker, a geneticist named Jose, questions the significance of calorie counting in relation to body weight.
  • Jose introduces his book, "Why Calories Don't Count," and discusses the impact of genes and the environment on body weight.
  • He explains the different units used to measure calories, distinguishing between small c calories (heat calories) and big C calories (food calories).
  • Jose delves into the concept of caloric availability, highlighting how the body extracts calories from different foods.
  • The process of measuring calories using a bomb calorimeter is detailed, emphasizing the precision of this method.
  • Despite the accuracy of measuring calories, the speaker points out that not all calories are equally absorbed by the body due to the digestive process.
  • Wilbur Atwater's research in the late 1800s led to the development of Atwater factors, which determine the caloric content of fats, carbohydrates, and proteins.
  • The Atwater factors, established over a century ago, are still used today to calculate the calorie content of food products.
  • Jose explains the significance of protein and fiber in caloric availability, noting that protein makes individuals feel fuller than fat or carbohydrates.
  • The speaker uses a knitted model of the human gastrointestinal tract to illustrate the digestive process and its impact on calorie absorption.

14:37

"Digestive System, Energy Metabolism, and Weight Loss"

  • The digestive system consists of the pancreas, gallbladder, liver, stomach, small intestine, appendix, and large intestine.
  • Protein and fiber take longer to digest, making you feel fuller due to the release of gut hormones.
  • Gut hormones signal to the brain, making you eat less and feel fuller.
  • Boiling a liter of water requires 100 calories, equivalent to the calories in an egg.
  • Energy from food is stored in ATP, which is recycled daily in the body.
  • Intermediary metabolism extracts energy from amino acids, glucose, and fatty acids to make ATP.
  • Protein requires more energy to handle due to its nitrogen content, leading to less absorbed calories.
  • Protein must be converted into fat for storage, as the body lacks a protein store.
  • Fats and carbs are more energy-dense and efficient than protein, leading to less heat production.
  • To lose weight, creating a caloric deficit by absorbing fewer calories than burned is essential, achieved through caloric restriction, high protein, or high fiber diets.

28:21

"High Protein Diets: Benefits and Varieties"

  • High protein diets are defined as having more than 16% of total calories from protein.
  • Popular high protein diets like Atkins, Dukan, and Keto are actually low carb high fat diets.
  • These diets vary in the severity of carbohydrate restriction and the belief that carbs are harmful.
  • Removing carbohydrates from the diet leads to increased protein consumption for satiety and weight loss.
  • Gluten-free diets, often merged with grain-free diets, are popular but not always necessary.
  • Paleo diet, based on eating like cavemen, is high in protein due to the removal of grains and starchy vegetables.
  • Protein metabolism involves diet-induced thermogenesis, affecting net metabolizable energy.
  • High fiber diets, like vegan or plant-based diets, reduce caloric availability due to fiber content.
  • Plant-based diets, including alkaline and Sirtfood diets, are effective for weight loss due to their high fiber content.
  • Ultra-processed foods strip away protein and fiber, affecting the quality of the diet and overall health.

42:15

Nutrition and Health Implications of Ultra-Processed Foods

  • Ultra-processed foods are typically low in protein and fiber, requiring the addition of sugar, salt, and fat for flavor.
  • These foods are calorically dense due to their low protein and fiber content, while being high in sugar, salt, and fat.
  • Ultra-processed foods are cheap to produce and have long shelf lives, contributing to their prevalence in diets, especially among lower socioeconomic classes.
  • The issue of food insecurity is highlighted, with many relying on ultra-processed foods due to time constraints and financial limitations.
  • The focus shifts to improving diet quality by emphasizing protein, fiber, and limiting added sugars, rather than solely counting calories.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.