Facing Death (full documentary) | FRONTLINE

FRONTLINE PBS | Official34 minutes read

Families and doctors face complex decisions about end-of-life care in the ICU, with the escalating costs of care raising concerns and pressure to reduce unnecessary expenditures. Patients like Robert, Diana, Martha, and Albert navigate difficult treatment choices and face uncertain prognoses, ultimately highlighting the challenges and emotional toll of navigating end-of-life decisions in modern medicine.

Insights

  • End-of-life care decisions in modern medicine are complex and often involve family members and healthcare proxies making difficult choices regarding life support and treatment options for critically ill patients.
  • The high costs associated with caring for chronically critically ill patients, such as those on ventilators or requiring extensive medical interventions, raise concerns about escalating healthcare expenditures and the need to balance quality of life with medical interventions.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How do families and doctors navigate end-of-life care decisions in modern medicine?

    In modern medicine, patients, families, and doctors often face challenging decisions regarding end-of-life care. The ICU at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York City serves as a poignant example, where families must grapple with the choice of whether to remove a loved one from life support. While medical technology can prolong life, the decisions surrounding end-of-life care have become increasingly complex. Factors such as escalating costs of care in the U.S. and the pressure to reduce unnecessary expenditures add further layers of difficulty to these decisions. Communication challenges in the ICU can lead to healthcare proxies making decisions on behalf of patients, highlighting the importance of clear and open dialogue in navigating these sensitive situations.

  • What factors contribute to the rising costs of end-of-life care in the United States?

    The escalating costs of end-of-life care in the United States are influenced by various factors. Modern medicine's ability to prolong life through advanced technology plays a significant role in driving up healthcare expenses. The complexity of decisions surrounding end-of-life care, such as the use of life support and ventilators, can lead to prolonged hospital stays and intensive treatments, further adding to the financial burden. Additionally, the pressure to reduce unnecessary expenditures in healthcare has become a growing concern, prompting families, doctors, and policymakers to grapple with the delicate balance between providing quality care and managing costs effectively.

  • How do families cope with the difficult decisions surrounding life support for loved ones?

    Families facing decisions about life support for their loved ones often experience emotional turmoil and conflicting perspectives. In cases like that of Diana Reed, a 31-year-old with Scleroderma, families may find themselves divided on whether to remove life support, adding an additional layer of complexity to an already challenging situation. Communication breakdowns in the ICU can further complicate matters, leading to healthcare proxies making decisions on behalf of patients. The Lauraville family's discussions about removing a ventilator for Martha, an 86-year-old with dementia, highlight the emotional toll and difficult choices families must navigate when grappling with end-of-life care decisions.

  • What are the key considerations for patients facing complex medical decisions after serious illnesses?

    Patients like Robert Bernardini, who faces decisions about life support after a massive stroke and pneumonia, must navigate a myriad of complex medical decisions. In cases where patients face complications after treatments like bone marrow transplants, such as Albert Alberti, uncertainty about treatment options and survival chances can weigh heavily on their minds. Strong physical condition is often crucial for successful treatments like chemotherapy, and patients may need to explore all available options with their doctors. Despite low survival chances, patients like Albert Alberti may exhibit a strong determination to keep fighting, underscoring the resilience and courage required to navigate the challenges of serious illnesses and hospitalizations.

  • How do medical teams and families handle changing treatment preferences and deteriorating conditions in patients?

    Medical teams and families often grapple with changing treatment preferences and deteriorating conditions in patients facing serious illnesses. Patients like Norman and John may reach a point where decisions about life-sustaining measures or transitioning to comfort care become necessary. The uncertainty and challenges of medical decisions can create emotional strain for both families and healthcare providers, as they navigate the evolving needs and preferences of patients. In cases where patients like Martha require long-term ventilator support, the high cost of caring for chronically critically ill patients can further complicate the decision-making process. Ultimately, open communication, empathy, and collaboration between medical teams and families are essential in providing compassionate care and support during these difficult times.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

End-of-life decisions in modern medicine

  • Patients, families, and doctors face difficult decisions in modern medicine regarding end-of-life care.
  • The ICU at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York City is highlighted, where a family must decide to take a patient off life support.
  • Modern medicine can prolong life through technology, but decisions at the end of life have become more complex.
  • Concerns arise over the escalating costs of end-of-life care in the U.S., with pressure to reduce unnecessary expenditures.
  • Robert Bernardini, 47, faces decisions about life support after a massive stroke and pneumonia.
  • Communication challenges in the ICU lead to decisions being made by healthcare proxies for patients.
  • Diana Reed, 31, with Scleroderma, is on a ventilator, with her family divided on whether to remove life support.
  • Martha Lauraville, 86, with dementia, prompts her family to decide on removing her from a ventilator.
  • The Lauraville family discusses the possibility of removing the ventilator and the potential need for a tracheotomy.
  • Albert Alberti, 53, faces complications after two bone marrow transplants for leukemia, with ongoing uncertainty about his treatment.

20:54

"Patient's Fight for Survival and Hope"

  • Stronger physical condition is crucial for successful chemo treatment
  • Patient hopes for another transplant to return to normal life
  • Doctor emphasizes exploring all treatment options
  • Patient's determination to keep fighting despite low survival chances
  • Patient's struggle with illness and hospitalization for months
  • Patient's weight loss and debilitation due to treatments
  • Agreement to continue mild chemotherapy at home
  • Discussion on the uncertainty and challenges of medical decisions
  • Patient's changing preferences regarding treatment
  • Family and medical team grappling with patient's deteriorating condition and prognosis

41:49

End-of-life decisions in critical care situations.

  • Norman's family decided to sign a DNR after meeting with doctors in the ICU and focused solely on Comfort Care.
  • John stopped chemotherapy and began bleeding internally, needing to decide on life-sustaining measures or signing a DNR.
  • John agreed to go to hospice but never signed a DNR, eventually dying a day later.
  • Albert had a massive stroke and died one week after being readmitted to the hospital.
  • Martha, after surprising everyone by breathing on her own, had a tracheotomy and has been living on a ventilator for over a year, highlighting the high cost of caring for chronically critically ill patients.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.