Dr Lise Eliot - The story of pink and blue
RootsofEmpathy・25 minutes read
The speaker critiques the brain sex movement for perpetuating stereotypes and distorting science, emphasizing the minimal impact of adult hormone fluctuations on behavior compared to prenatal testosterone and the influence of upbringing on gender identity. They highlight the importance of understanding plasticity in brain development, noting that psychological differences between male and female brains are not as dramatic as commonly believed, and that gender learning and cultural experiences significantly shape brain function.
Insights
- Criticism of the brain sex movement infiltrating classrooms and promoting stereotypes, with authors like Leonard Sax and Michael Gurian peddling stereotypes under the guise of science.
- Gender identity is influenced more by upbringing and activities than prenatal hormone exposure, emphasizing the importance of understanding brain plasticity and cultural learning in shaping gender differences.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What is the Roots of Empathy program?
A program promoting empathy in schools.
What is the brain sex concept?
A theory popularized by a book.
How do hormones influence behavior?
Hormones have minimal impact on behavior.
What are the main criticisms of brain sex studies?
Exaggeration of sex differences and lack of evidence.
How can parents help break gender stereotypes?
By encouraging cross-training and diverse experiences.
Related videos
Radboud Reflects
Testosterone | Lecture by sociomedical scientist Rebecca Jordan-Young
The SCEA
Transgender Neurobiology with Dr. Robert Sapolsky
TEDx Talks
After watching this, your brain will not be the same | Lara Boyd | TEDxVancouver
TED
The way we think about biological sex is wrong | Emily Quinn
Big Think
You have no free will at all | Stanford professor Robert Sapolsky
Summary
00:00
"Debunking Brain Sex Myths in Education"
- The speaker expresses admiration for the Roots of Empathy program and its research conference.
- They highlight the distortion of science regarding sex differences in popular literature.
- Mention of the brain sex concept, popularized by the book "Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus."
- Criticism of the brain sex movement infiltrating classrooms and promoting stereotypes.
- Examples of authors peddling stereotypes under the guise of science, like Leonard Sax and Michael Gurian.
- Discussion on the exaggeration of sex differences in the brain and the lack of significant evidence.
- Emphasis on the small statistical differences in brain sex studies and the misinterpretation of results.
- Explanation of the minimal impact of adult hormone fluctuations on behavior compared to prenatal testosterone.
- Clarification that gender identity is influenced more by upbringing and activities rather than prenatal hormone exposure.
- The importance of understanding plasticity in brain development and the role of cultural learning in shaping gender differences.
16:27
Gender Brain Differences: Fact or Fiction?
- Psychological differences between male and female brains are not as dramatic as commonly believed.
- In animals, brain differences are mainly found in the hypothalamus, driven by testosterone receptors.
- Girls have smaller brains that finish growing earlier than boys, with a 10-12% size difference.
- Brain structure differences in memory and emotion recognition areas show no variance between males and females.
- Both men and women are left hemisphere dominant, with no significant differences in resting connectivity across genders.
- Gender learning and cultural experiences significantly shape brain function, impacting moral reasoning and other cognitive processes.
- Parents often unknowingly reinforce gender stereotypes through toy choices, expectations, and biases.
- Encouraging cross-training and breaking gender stereotypes early can help children overcome societal norms and biases.
