LoginGet started

Dr. Allan Schore: How Relationships Shape Your Brain

Andrew Huberman・103 minutes read

Andrew Huberman's podcast features Dr. Alan Shaw discussing the critical role of early attachment patterns in childhood development, emphasizing that interactions with primary caretakers significantly shape emotional regulation and attachment styles. The conversation highlights the lasting impact of these early experiences on adult relationships, underscoring the importance of understanding attachment dynamics for healthier interpersonal connections.

Insights

  • Andrew Huberman, a professor at Stanford School of Medicine, hosts the Huberman Lab podcast where he discusses with Dr. Alan Shaw the critical role of early childhood attachment patterns, particularly in the first two years of life, in shaping emotional development and adult relationships.
  • Dr. Shaw highlights that the right brain is essential for developing emotional connections with caregivers, influencing attachment styles that can lead to secure, anxious, or avoidant relationships later in life, with significant brain development occurring during this early period.
  • Research indicates that a vast majority of our motivations and behaviors are driven by unconscious processes, with the right hemisphere processing emotional information without conscious awareness, emphasizing the importance of early attachment experiences on emotional regulation.
  • The podcast discusses how effective caregiving involves non-verbal communication, where mothers help regulate their infants' emotional states through facial expressions and tone of voice, establishing lifelong strategies for managing emotions.
  • Dr. Shaw explains that the dynamics of attachment not only affect early childhood but also continue to influence adult relationships, suggesting that understanding these patterns can enhance interpersonal connections and self-awareness.
  • The conversation addresses the therapeutic relationship, emphasizing that effective therapy relies on emotional synchronization between therapist and patient, which facilitates deeper emotional processing and healing, particularly in those with complex attachment issues.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is emotional regulation?

    Emotional regulation refers to the processes by which individuals influence their emotional experience, expression, and physiological responses. It involves managing both positive and negative emotions to achieve a balanced emotional state. Effective emotional regulation is crucial for maintaining mental health and well-being, as it allows individuals to respond appropriately to various situations. This can include strategies such as cognitive reappraisal, where one reframes a situation to alter its emotional impact, or mindfulness practices that promote awareness and acceptance of emotions. In relationships, emotional regulation plays a significant role, as it helps individuals navigate interpersonal dynamics and maintain healthy connections with others.

  • How does attachment affect adult relationships?

    Attachment styles developed in early childhood significantly influence adult relationships. These styles, formed through interactions with primary caregivers, shape how individuals connect with others, manage emotions, and respond to intimacy. Secure attachment fosters healthy, trusting relationships, allowing individuals to communicate effectively and regulate their emotions. In contrast, insecure attachment styles, such as anxious or avoidant, can lead to difficulties in relationships, including fear of closeness or excessive dependence on partners for emotional support. Understanding one's attachment style can provide insights into relationship patterns and help individuals work towards healthier connections, ultimately enhancing their interpersonal dynamics and emotional well-being.

  • What is the role of the right brain in emotions?

    The right brain plays a crucial role in emotional processing and regulation. It is primarily responsible for understanding non-verbal cues, such as facial expressions and tone of voice, which are essential for emotional communication. During early childhood, the right brain undergoes significant development, influencing attachment styles and emotional responses. It processes emotional information unconsciously, guiding behaviors and motivations without conscious awareness. This implicit processing is vital for forming secure attachments and managing emotional states throughout life. In therapeutic settings, engaging the right brain can enhance emotional connections between therapist and patient, facilitating deeper understanding and healing.

  • What is psychobiological attunement?

    Psychobiological attunement refers to the synchronization between a caregiver and a child, where the caregiver responds to the child's emotional and physiological needs. This attunement is essential for developing secure attachments, as it involves the caregiver's ability to regulate the child's emotional states through non-verbal communication, such as tone of voice and facial expressions. Effective attunement fosters emotional regulation in the child, allowing them to develop healthy coping mechanisms and self-regulation skills. When misattunement occurs, it can lead to insecure attachment styles, impacting the child's emotional development and future relationships. Thus, psychobiological attunement is a foundational aspect of healthy emotional growth.

  • How does early childhood development impact later life?

    Early childhood development has a profound impact on an individual's later life, particularly in areas such as emotional regulation, social skills, and overall well-being. The first few years of life are critical for brain development, especially in the right hemisphere, which is responsible for emotional processing and attachment. Experiences during this period shape attachment styles, influencing how individuals relate to others and manage their emotions throughout life. Research indicates that strong emotional and social skills developed in early childhood are better predictors of adult life satisfaction than cognitive abilities alone. Therefore, prioritizing nurturing environments and supportive relationships during early development is essential for fostering healthy emotional growth and future success.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Impact of Early Attachment on Adult Relationships

  • Andrew Huberman, a professor at Stanford School of Medicine, hosts the Huberman Lab podcast, featuring Dr. Alan Shaw, a clinician and psychoanalyst specializing in childhood attachment patterns and their impact on adult relationships.
  • Dr. Shaw emphasizes the significance of the first 24 months of life, during which the brain develops based on interactions with primary caretakers, primarily the mother, influencing emotional development and attachment styles.
  • The right brain is crucial for developing emotional resonance with caretakers, transitioning between calm and excited states, which is essential for forming secure, anxious, or avoidant attachment styles later in life.
  • Dr. Shaw explains that attachment styles are shaped during the right brain's growth spurt from the last trimester of pregnancy through the first two to three years of life, with the right hemisphere dominating this period.
  • Research indicates that the right hemisphere processes emotional information unconsciously, with 90-95% of our motivations and behaviors governed by unconscious processes rather than conscious thought.
  • The attachment relationship involves non-verbal communication through facial expressions, voice, and gestures, where the mother regulates the infant's emotional state, establishing lifelong strategies for affect regulation.
  • The development of the left hemisphere begins after the second year of life, marking a shift in brain dynamics, but the foundational attachment mechanisms are rooted in right brain interactions during early childhood.
  • Dr. Shaw references the "strange situation" experiment, which assesses attachment styles by observing children's reactions to their mothers' absence and return, categorizing them into secure, insecure, anxious, or avoidant attachments.
  • The podcast discusses the ongoing influence of early attachment experiences on adult relationships, suggesting that understanding these patterns can help improve interpersonal connections and self-relationship.
  • Huberman promotes products like David protein bars, which contain 28 grams of protein and 150 calories, and Eight Sleep mattress covers, which regulate temperature for optimal sleep, highlighting their benefits for health and well-being.

15:15

Mother-Infant Attachment and Emotional Regulation

  • The regulation of stress in infants is significantly influenced by the mother's ability to manage the baby's emotional states during a critical period, particularly in the first two years of life when the right brain is developing rapidly.
  • Attachment models evolve from behavior to cognition to emotion, highlighting the importance of emotional development, which gained scientific attention in the mid-1990s due to advancements in neural imaging.
  • Attachment is described as psychobiological, integrating psychological and physiological aspects, particularly the stress response involving the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems, which the mother regulates through her interactions with the baby.
  • Mothers track and synchronize with their baby's emotional states, using non-verbal cues such as tone of voice and facial expressions to either upregulate or downregulate the baby's emotional arousal.
  • The right brain is primarily responsible for regulating attachment and emotional arousal, operating implicitly and beneath conscious awareness, especially in the absence of verbal communication in infants.
  • Secure attachment fosters the development of the child's ability to self-regulate emotions, while insecure attachments lead to reliance on others for emotional regulation, with avoidant children tending to auto-regulate and anxious children seeking external support.
  • Psychobiological attunement is crucial for secure attachment, where mothers not only respond to their child's psychological needs but also their physiological needs, allowing for effective emotional regulation.
  • Misattunement can occur, but effective caregiving involves the mother returning to reconnect and resynchronize with the baby, which is essential for developing secure attachment.
  • The attachment system's functioning is linked to later adult relationships, with the same neural circuitry used in infant-mother attachment being repurposed for adult romantic relationships, emphasizing the continuity of attachment dynamics throughout life.
  • Therapeutic relationships in therapy mirror attachment dynamics, where the therapist's ability to form a secure, trusting relationship with the patient is critical for effective treatment, particularly for those with complex attachment issues like borderline personality disorder.

33:36

Therapist Techniques for Emotional Connection and Regulation

  • The therapist must switch from left-brain to right-brain listening to effectively track a patient's emotional state, which involves a process called "surrender," where the therapist lets go of conscious control to connect intuitively with the patient’s feelings.
  • AG1 is an all-in-one nutritional supplement that includes vitamins, minerals, probiotics, and adaptogens, which supports overall health, digestion, and immune function; it is recommended to take AG1 daily for optimal benefits.
  • A special offer for AG1 includes a free month supply of omega-3 fatty acids, five free travel packs, and a year supply of vitamin D3 K2 for orders placed in November 2024, available at drinkag1.com/huberman.
  • The therapist's goal is to synchronize with the patient's emotional state, whether they are experiencing hypoarousal (depression) or hyperarousal (anxiety), by matching their physiological responses to create a therapeutic alliance.
  • Effective therapy involves the therapist tracking the patient's emotional arousal through non-verbal cues, such as voice tone and facial expressions, to help the patient regulate their emotions and achieve a state of calm.
  • The concept of interpersonal synchrony, where two individuals feel the same emotional state simultaneously, is crucial for building a strong therapeutic relationship and facilitating emotional regulation.
  • Emotional empathy, which occurs in the right brain, allows the therapist to feel what the patient is experiencing without conscious thought, while cognitive empathy, associated with the left brain, involves understanding the patient’s feelings intellectually.
  • Changes in a patient's emotional regulation are facilitated by the therapist's ability to create new neural connections in the right brain, particularly through the orbital frontal cortex, which helps in managing emotions like rage, loss, and shame.
  • The primary attachment figure for a child, typically the mother, plays a crucial role in providing emotional regulation during the first two years of life, while the father often contributes to the child's development of autonomy and risk-taking behaviors through more stimulating interactions.
  • In cases where there is only one primary caregiver, that individual can fulfill both the right-brain and left-brain roles, providing emotional support and cognitive guidance, which is increasingly common in modern family structures.

50:27

Balancing Brain Functions in Therapy and Relationships

  • The discussion highlights the importance of both left and right brain functions in therapy, emphasizing that while the left brain handles more autonomous tasks, the right brain is crucial for emotional and relational dynamics between therapist and patient.
  • Modern exploration of compounds like MDMA in psychotherapy is mentioned, noting that while these substances are not FDA-approved, clinical studies suggest they may enhance right brain synchrony between therapist and patient, potentially accelerating therapeutic processes.
  • Ethical concerns arise regarding the use of empathogenic compounds, as both the therapist and patient would need to take the substance, raising questions about the integrity of the therapeutic relationship.
  • The text emphasizes the significance of subcortical brain areas, particularly the right amygdala, in emotional regulation and attachment, suggesting that current therapeutic practices may be overly focused on cortical areas.
  • In utero development is discussed, indicating that the right brain undergoes significant growth during the last trimester, with evidence showing that early memories are stored in the right amygdala, highlighting the need for attention to prenatal influences on emotional development.
  • The impact of maternal stress during pregnancy is addressed, noting that high cortisol levels can adversely affect the developing amygdala, potentially leading to long-term emotional and developmental issues in the child.
  • The importance of emotional regulation in relationships is underscored, with a focus on the balance between downregulating negative states and upregulating positive states, which is essential for secure attachments and healthy emotional development.
  • The concept of "quiet love" and "excited love" is introduced, differentiating between calming emotional states and more passionate interactions, both of which are necessary for healthy relationships and emotional integration.
  • The text discusses the phenomenon of splitting in borderline personality disorder, where individuals may oscillate between idealizing and devaluing others, indicating a lack of integration between positive and negative self-perceptions.
  • Finally, it is suggested that the way individuals with borderline personality disorder perceive relationships may extend beyond therapy to other life domains, reflecting a broader emotional worldview shaped by right brain dynamics.

01:06:22

Emotional Dynamics in Therapy and Relationships

  • In cases of narcissistic personality disorder, the primary caregiver perceives the infant positively, but when the infant shows signs of depression, the caregiver's emotional engagement ceases, leading to unconscious dynamics in their relationship.
  • Misattunement occurs in dismissive attachment styles, where individuals emotionally disengage when they feel too close, reflecting early attachment dynamics and resulting in a cycle of coming closer and moving apart in relationships.
  • Anxious individuals tend to seek closeness and become more demanding during stress, while avoidant individuals may withdraw, leading to a flat tone of voice that lacks emotional expression, indicating their emotional distance.
  • Effective therapy focuses on implicit emotional changes rather than conscious awareness, emphasizing the need for right-brain engagement to facilitate personality changes and emotional health.
  • Interpersonal neurobiology highlights the importance of interactive regulation over auto-regulation, suggesting that forming close, vulnerable relationships can enhance right-brain communication and emotional health.
  • Individuals can repair their right-brain circuitry by engaging with supportive people, allowing for emotional nourishment and the development of healthy attachment patterns, even outside of therapy.
  • Heightened affective moments in therapy, lasting around 50-60 seconds, occur when both therapist and patient synchronize emotionally, allowing for deeper emotional processing and connection.
  • The right brain is dominant for wide-ranging attention, which allows for a broader emotional context in interactions, contrasting with the left brain's narrow focus on specific details.
  • Neuroimaging studies show that during emotional interactions, the right brains of two individuals can synchronize, particularly in the right temporal parietal junction, facilitating empathic communication.
  • Effective psychotherapy relies on the synchronization of emotional states between therapist and patient, where both parties engage in right-brain communication, enhancing understanding and emotional healing.

01:24:23

Evolving Perspectives on Emotional Connections in Therapy

  • The understanding of psychotherapy has evolved to emphasize the relational unconscious, highlighting the importance of emotional connections between individuals rather than solely cognitive insights.
  • The therapeutic relationship is now recognized as the primary mechanism for change in psychotherapy, contrasting with traditional psychoanalysis, which focused on interpretation from a distance.
  • Face-to-face contact in therapy is crucial, as newer imaging tools reveal the significance of synchrony in emotional communication between therapist and client.
  • Music is identified as a powerful tool for emotional regulation, with individual preferences varying widely; for example, some may find classical music soothing while others resonate with lyrical songs.
  • The emotional impact of music is often felt beyond the literal meaning of lyrics, as the delivery, tone, and context contribute to a deeper emotional truth that resonates with listeners.
  • Dogs and other domestic animals are suggested to facilitate emotional regulation through tactile communication, vocal tone, and even the ability to read human facial expressions, enhancing the bond between humans and pets.
  • The right brain is more connected to bodily states than the left brain, playing a significant role in emotional regulation and unconscious will, as discussed by Ian McGilchrist.
  • Spontaneous behaviors during emotional communication are essential for building trust and synchrony between individuals, allowing for a more genuine connection.
  • Text messaging is criticized for lacking the emotional depth and turn-taking dynamics present in face-to-face or voice communication, potentially hindering interpersonal skills, especially in younger generations.
  • The dominance of the left hemisphere in contemporary communication is viewed as problematic, with a call for more direct, personal interactions to foster better emotional connections and healing.

01:40:26

The Power of Handwritten Letters and Creativity

  • Handwritten letters hold significant emotional value, serving as tangible proof of connections between individuals, unlike more impersonal forms of communication like texting or typewritten letters.
  • The act of writing letters fosters self-reflection, as it requires individuals to articulate their feelings and experiences to others, enhancing personal connections.
  • The text discusses the dominance of the right brain in various human experiences, emphasizing that intuition, creativity, and emotional processing are primarily right-brain functions.
  • Key activities that stimulate right-brain activity include spending time in nature, engaging in creative pursuits like music and art, and practicing wide-range attention, which contrasts with the narrow focus of left-brain activities.
  • The author suggests that therapy should prioritize right-brain processes over techniques, as right-brain engagement leads to more effective long-term changes in patients compared to cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT).
  • New experiences, such as traveling and meeting new people, are essential for stimulating curiosity and right-brain activity, which can lead to personal growth and new relationships.
  • Regular exercise is highlighted as a fundamental component of both physical and mental healing, with references to research on the role of mitochondria in energy and recovery.
  • The text emphasizes the importance of emotional awareness, noting that both positive and negative emotions have adaptive value and should be acknowledged rather than suppressed.
  • The author shares personal experiences of returning to piano playing as a means to engage the right brain, illustrating the value of creative exploration in personal development.
  • A unique learning approach is described, where the author avoids memorization in favor of understanding concepts deeply, leading to a more effective and intuitive grasp of knowledge.

01:58:38

Emotional Development and Parenting Insights

  • The note-taking process for preparing a solo EP involves a specific introspective learning method that spans 6 to 10 weeks, focusing on how to deeply absorb information rather than just memorizing it, emphasizing the importance of emotional experiences in forming lasting memories.
  • Critical early childhood development is highlighted, with a focus on the importance of time spent with infants, particularly in the first 6 to 8 weeks, when the autonomic nervous system and amygdala are in a critical developmental period, which is essential for forming attachments.
  • In Scandinavian countries, parental leave policies are significantly more supportive, with maternal leave lasting 6 months or more and paternal leave at 3 months, contrasting sharply with the U.S. standard of only 6 weeks, which is deemed insufficient for fostering healthy emotional development in children.
  • A study from the London School of Economics identifies the best predictors of adult life satisfaction as emotional regulation, conduct, and IQ, in that order, suggesting that current educational focuses on executive functions may overlook foundational emotional and social skills developed in early childhood.
  • The discussion emphasizes the need for a shift in parenting and educational approaches, advocating for prioritizing emotional and moral development over rote memorization, as critical emotional transfer is essential for a child's overall well-being and future success.
  • The speaker, Dr. Andrew Huberman, announces the upcoming release of his book titled "Protocols: An Operating Manual for the Human Body," which compiles over 30 years of research into practical protocols for various aspects of health, including sleep, exercise, and stress management, available for pre-sale at protocolsbook.com.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.