Asteroid Expert Rates Nine Asteroid Disasters In Movies and TV | How Real Is It? | Insider

Insider13 minutes read

Professor Gretchen Benedix, a meteorite and asteroid expert, debunks unrealistic portrayals of asteroids in movies, clarifying that they do not emit much gas, lack debris clouds, and do not resemble spiky metallic rocks. Despite the possibility of large asteroids going unnoticed before Earth impact, the chances of collision are incredibly slim due to improved tracking capabilities and the decreased frequency of asteroid collisions over time.

Insights

  • Professor Gretchen Benedix debunks common asteroid misconceptions perpetuated by movies, highlighting the unrealistic depictions of smoke, gas, and spiky appearances.
  • The decreased likelihood of asteroid collisions with Earth over time is attributed to the evolution of the solar system and improved space tracking technologies, reducing the probability of impact despite some objects being classified as potentially hazardous.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How do asteroids differ from comets?

    Asteroids are rocky metallic bodies, while comets are composed of ice and dust.

  • How are asteroids depicted inaccurately in movies?

    Asteroids in movies are often shown with excessive smoke and gas, unlike their actual appearance.

  • Can large asteroids go unnoticed before reaching Earth?

    It is unlikely for a large asteroid to go unnoticed before reaching Earth.

  • What is the composition of metallic asteroids?

    Metallic asteroids do not have the spiky appearance shown in movies.

  • How do sound waves travel in space?

    Sound waves in space do not travel the same way as on Earth.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Asteroids: Real vs. Movie Depictions

  • Professor Gretchen Benedix has studied meteorites and asteroids for 20 years.
  • Asteroids in movies are often depicted unrealistically with excessive smoke and gas.
  • Metallic asteroids do not have the spiky appearance shown in movies.
  • Asteroids do not have a debris cloud around them and do not emit much gas.
  • It is unlikely for a large asteroid to go unnoticed before reaching Earth.
  • Destroying a large asteroid would require an immense amount of explosive power.
  • Sound waves in space do not travel the same way as on Earth.
  • The asteroid belt is not a doughnut of rocks but can have asteroid families.
  • Collisions between asteroids have decreased over time, making Earth impacts less likely.
  • Comets are composed of ice and dust, while asteroids are rocky metallic bodies.

15:16

"Near-Earth Objects: Low Risk, High Tracking"

  • Objects with an ephemeris lower than 0.05 AU from Earth are considered potentially hazardous, but the probability of a collision is extremely small due to the solar system's evolution and the current tracking capabilities in space.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.