AQA GCSE History - Elizabethan England (1568-1603) - The Elizabethan Religious Settlement
Pete Jackson・2 minutes read
Elizabeth I established a religious settlement in 1559 to balance Catholicism and Protestantism while facing significant opposition from both groups, leading to a series of harsher laws against Catholics and measures to suppress Puritan dissent. Despite initial stability, growing tensions resulted in the execution of approximately 200 Catholics and the tightening of control over religious practices as Elizabeth struggled to maintain her authority and the settlement's integrity.
Insights
- Elizabeth I's establishment of the Elizabethan religious settlement in 1559 aimed to balance Catholic and Protestant beliefs in England, introducing key laws like the Act of Supremacy and the Act of Uniformity to create a unified Church of England. However, this settlement faced significant challenges, particularly from Catholic opposition led by figures such as Mary Queen of Scots, prompting Elizabeth to enact increasingly severe anti-Catholic laws and measures to suppress dissent.
- The tensions between Elizabeth I's religious policies and the growing Puritan movement highlighted the ongoing struggle within the Church of England, as figures like Thomas Cartwright called for the abolition of bishops and faced repression, including the house arrest of Archbishop Edmund Grindel. This internal conflict, alongside the crackdown on Catholicism, led to a period of heightened persecution, with approximately 200 Catholics executed and the government responding with strict laws against dissenters, reflecting the complexities of maintaining religious stability during her reign.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What is the Elizabethan religious settlement?
The Elizabethan religious settlement, established by Queen Elizabeth I in 1559, was a significant attempt to create a middle ground between Catholicism and Protestantism in England. This settlement emerged after years of religious conflict, particularly during the reigns of her predecessors, which included the Catholic Mary I and the Protestant Edward VI. The settlement consisted of key legislative acts, notably the Act of Supremacy, which declared Elizabeth as the Supreme Governor of the Church of England, and the Act of Uniformity, which mandated the use of the Book of Common Prayer in English for worship. This approach aimed to appease both Catholics and Protestants, fostering a degree of religious stability in a time of turmoil.
Why did Elizabeth face challenges to her rule?
Elizabeth I faced significant challenges to her rule primarily due to the arrival of Mary Queen of Scots in 1568, who became a symbol of Catholic opposition against Elizabeth. This situation escalated with the Northern Rebellion of 1569, where rebels sought to place Mary on the throne, reflecting the deep-seated divisions within England regarding religion. In response to these threats, Elizabeth enacted stricter anti-Catholic laws, including the Treason Act of 1570, which made it punishable by death to deny her supremacy or promote Catholicism. The political and religious tensions of the time, exacerbated by plots against her life, necessitated a firm response from Elizabeth, further complicating her efforts to maintain stability.
What were the consequences for Catholics under Elizabeth?
Under Elizabeth I, Catholics faced severe consequences as the government implemented increasingly harsh laws to suppress Catholicism. The Act of Persuasions in 1581 significantly raised fines for Catholics who did not attend Anglican services, making it financially burdensome to practice their faith. Additionally, the Act Against Priests in 1585 declared it treasonable to be a Catholic priest, leading to the execution of those who remained in England and the death penalty for anyone aiding them. These measures reflected Elizabeth's determination to eliminate Catholic influence and maintain her religious settlement, resulting in the execution of approximately 200 Catholics during her reign, including notable figures like Margaret Clitherow.
How did Puritans react to Elizabeth's religious policies?
The Puritans, who opposed the hierarchical structure of the Church of England and the authority of bishops, reacted strongly against Elizabeth's religious policies. Significant figures like Thomas Cartwright called for the abolition of bishops and rejected Elizabeth's role as the supreme governor of the Church. This dissent led to increased tensions, as Elizabeth viewed her religious settlement as final and sought to suppress Puritan ideas. The house arrest of Archbishop Edmund Grindel, who held Puritan-inspired prayer meetings, exemplified her efforts to control religious practices. Following Grindel's death, John Whitgift enforced stricter adherence to traditional Protestantism, resulting in the suspension of numerous ministers and further escalating the conflict between the crown and Puritan factions.
What impact did Elizabeth's reign have on religion in England?
Elizabeth I's reign had a profound and lasting impact on the religious landscape of England. The Elizabethan religious settlement established a framework that sought to balance the competing interests of Catholics and Protestants, but it also led to increased persecution of dissenters. The government’s response to both Catholic and Puritan opposition included harsh laws and executions, which shaped the religious climate of the time. The settlement initially succeeded in maintaining stability, with a small percentage of priests refusing loyalty oaths. However, the growing tensions and the eventual crackdown on both Catholic and Puritan dissenters highlighted the challenges Elizabeth faced in her quest for a unified religious identity in England, setting the stage for future conflicts in the centuries to come.
Related videos
Pete Jackson
AQA GCSE History - Elizabethan England (1568-1603) - The background and court of Elizabeth I
Real Royalty
The Forgotten Tudor Queen: Bloody Mary | Mary I | Real Royalty
Pete Jackson
AQA GCSE History Revision - Elizabethan England (1568-1603)- How Elizabeth I controlled her people
The Daily Bellringer
The Pilgrims History
Kings and Generals
How England and Spain Failed to Destroy Each Other - Early Modern History
Summary
00:00
Elizabethan Settlement and Catholic Opposition
- Elizabeth I established the Elizabethan religious settlement in 1559 to create a middle ground between Catholicism and Protestantism, following years of religious turmoil in England, including the reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI, and Mary I, the latter known for her persecution of Protestants.
- The settlement included the Act of Supremacy, which declared Elizabeth as the Supreme Governor of the Church of England, and the Act of Uniformity, mandating that all worship follow the Book of Common Prayer in English, with priests wearing specific vestments to appease both Catholics and Protestants.
- Elizabeth's initial success in maintaining the settlement faced challenges after the arrival of Mary Queen of Scots in 1568, who became a rallying figure for Catholic opposition, leading to the Northern Rebellion of 1569, where rebels aimed to place Mary on the throne.
- In response to the Northern Rebellion, Elizabeth enacted harsher anti-Catholic laws, including the Treason Act of 1570, which made it punishable by death to deny her supremacy or promote Catholicism, following the Pope's excommunication of Elizabeth that year.
- Key plots against Elizabeth included the Rodolfi Plot (1571), Throckmorton Plot (1583), and Babington Plot (1586), which further intensified the threat from Catholics and prompted Elizabeth to implement stricter measures against Catholic conspiracies.
- The government passed the Act of Persuasions in 1581, increasing fines for not attending church services to £20 per month, a significant rise from the previous fine of 12 pence in 1559, making it financially burdensome for Catholics.
- The Act Against Priests in 1585 declared it treasonable to be a Catholic priest, giving them 40 days to leave England, and anyone aiding a priest faced the death penalty, reflecting the severity of Elizabeth's crackdown on Catholicism.
- Jesuit priests, such as Robert Parsons and Edmund Campion, began arriving in England around 1574, aiming to convert Protestants back to Catholicism; however, their efforts largely failed, with only about 40,000 Catholics remaining in England by 1683.
- Edmund Campion, who entered England in June 1580, was captured in July 1581 after distributing pamphlets and was executed for treason, highlighting the risks faced by Catholic missionaries during Elizabeth's reign.
- The Elizabethan religious settlement marked a significant moment in England's religious history, as Elizabeth navigated opposition from both Catholics and Puritans, leading to a long-lasting impact on the religious landscape of the country.
14:11
Religious Persecution in Elizabethan England
- During Elizabeth I's reign, approximately 200 Catholics were executed, with Margaret Clitherow, a butcher's wife, being a notable martyr; she was pressed to death under a door with heavy weights for refusing to plead in court after being accused of sheltering priests.
- The Puritans opposed the hierarchical structure of the Church of England and the bishops, with significant figures like Thomas Cartwright calling for the abolition of bishops in 1570 and refusing to acknowledge Elizabeth as supreme governor, leading to increased tensions as Elizabeth viewed her religious settlement as final.
- Elizabeth's concern over the spread of Puritan ideas led to the house arrest of Archbishop Edmund Grindel from 1576 until his death in 1583, as he held Puritan-inspired prayer meetings known as "prophesying," which she sought to suppress; after his death, John Whitgift enforced stricter adherence to traditional Protestantism, resulting in the suspension of 300 ministers.
- The government responded to Puritan dissent with the Act Against Seditious Secretaries in 1593, allowing for the execution of anyone accused of being a separatist, while the Elizabethan religious settlement initially succeeded in maintaining stability, with only 3% of priests refusing loyalty oaths, though opposition from Catholics and Puritans increased after 1568, leading to further persecution and executions.
