An astrophysicist reacts to Carl Sagan's Contact
Dr. Becky・20 minutes read
The film "Contact" follows Jodie Foster's character detecting a radio signal from space believed to be from intelligent life, critiqued for inaccuracies in radio astronomy and scientific processes, emphasizing the significance of technology in contacting extraterrestrial life and addressing themes of science versus religion. Ellie's journey and experiences with wormholes and time dilation resonate with viewers, inspiring reactions to sci-fi content despite the lack of closure in the film.
Insights
- The film "Contact" portrays the significance of technology in potential contact with extraterrestrial life, showcasing the Very Large Array in New Mexico and highlighting the process of obtaining telescope time with expert astronomers.
- Through personal anecdotes, the film emphasizes the childhood inspirations that lead to careers in astronomy, while also addressing themes of science versus religion and the importance of respecting both perspectives in the scientific community.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What is the film "Contact" about?
The film follows Jodie Foster's character, who works for SETI and detects a radio signal from space believed to be from intelligent life.
What is the Arecibo Observatory?
The Arecibo Observatory is a massive radio telescope in Puerto Rico that recently collapsed in 2020, impacting the scientific community.
What is the significance of the Very Large Array?
The film showcases the Very Large Array in New Mexico, emphasizing its importance in technology acquisition for potential contact with extraterrestrial life.
What is the portrayal of radio astronomy in the film critiqued for?
The film is critiqued for inaccuracies, such as mistaking radio waves for sound waves, which are actually light waves.
What themes are addressed in the film "Contact"?
The film addresses themes of science versus religion, highlighting the importance of respecting both perspectives in the scientific community.
Related videos
Joe Scott
The Arecibo Message And METI | Answers With Joe
Extreme Mysteries
ALIEN CONTACT (Episode 1) - ALIEN AND UFO ENCOUNTERS FROM ANOTHER DIMENSION
BeerBiceps
Aliens, Time Travel & Parallel Universes ft. Abhijit Chavda | The Ranveer Show 112
StarTalk Plus
Neil deGrasse Tyson’s Sci-Fi Movie Tier List
US National Archives
Who's Out There - 1975
Summary
00:00
"Contact" film critiques radio astronomy inaccuracies
- The film "Contact" is based on Carl Sagan's book and follows Jodie Foster's character, who works for SETI, detecting a radio signal from space believed to be from intelligent life.
- The film features the Arecibo Observatory, a massive radio telescope in Puerto Rico, which recently collapsed in 2020, impacting the scientific community.
- The portrayal of radio astronomy in the film is critiqued for inaccuracies, such as mistaking radio waves for sound waves, which are actually light waves.
- Personal anecdotes from the narrator and Jodie Foster's character in the film highlight childhood inspirations leading to careers in astronomy.
- The film emphasizes the significance of technology acquisition for potential contact with extraterrestrial life, showcasing the Very Large Array in New Mexico.
- The scientific process of obtaining telescope time is depicted, highlighting the oversubscription and rigorous review process by expert astronomers.
- The film includes technical jargon related to radio signals, such as the hydrogen 21 centimeter emission line and frequency calculations.
- The star Vega is prominently featured in the film, known for its brightness and visibility in the northern hemisphere.
- The rapid public announcement of a potential extraterrestrial signal in the film is criticized for its unrealistic portrayal of scientific discovery and verification processes.
- The film addresses themes of science versus religion, with the narrator expressing the importance of respecting both perspectives in the scientific community.
14:54
Ellie's Journey Through Space and Time
- Ellie is determined to represent her nation, planet, and God on a significant journey, despite her frustrations with Drumlin, who hindered the project and took credit for the original discovery.
- Ellie finds herself on the Russian space station Mir, which operated in the late 80s and early 90s, highlighting collaborations with European astronauts like Helen Sharman.
- Wormholes, connecting two points in spacetime, are distinct from black holes, offering a gentle curvature for travel without a point of no return, unlike black holes.
- Time dilation and relativity play a role in Ellie's experience of spending 18 hours in a wormhole while others detect only a fraction of a second passing.
- Despite the lack of closure in the film "Arrival," Ellie's passion for astrophysics and the wonder of the night sky resonates with viewers, inspiring a series of reactions to classic and new sci-fi content.
