Ace Attorney Cases RANKED Worst To Best (Part 1: #40-21 - The Bottom Half)

Kaempfdog・2 minutes read

Kempdog and his brother rank all Ace Attorney cases from worst to best in a detailed video discussion based on personal opinions and replay value, covering various trilogies and games. They critique each case's storytelling, characters, and mechanics, highlighting strengths and weaknesses to create a comprehensive ranking that considers the overall impact and entertainment value of each case.

Insights

  • The ranking of Ace Attorney cases by Kempdog and his brother is based on personal opinions and replay value, covering original and second trilogies, Apollo Justice, Dual Destinies, Spirit of Justice, and the Investigations games, excluding DGS, The Great Ace Attorney, and Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright.
  • Case 3-4 Turnabout Beginnings is criticized for being boring overall but praised for its impactful ending, showcasing Apollo's development naturally without retconning anything, set in the middle of case four, making it unnecessarily complicated.
  • Turnabout Big Top from Justice for All is defended against its negative reputation, praised for its intentional theme of toxicity and unpleasantness fitting the circus setting, introducing engaging characters like Simon Blackwell and Bobby Fulbright, with Athena's physical prowess and Phoenix's return to form, despite its forgettable nature and linear gameplay.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is the ranking of Ace Attorney cases?

    The ranking covers original and second trilogies, Apollo Justice, Dual Destinies, Spirit of Justice, and the Investigations games.

  • Why is Turnabout Memories praised?

    Turnabout Memories is praised for its foreshadowing and Mia's role.

  • What is the defense for Turnabout Big Top?

    Turnabout Big Top is defended against its negative reputation.

  • What are the criticisms of Turnabout Airlines?

    The case is critiqued for being overstuffed with minor details and featuring a challenging character, Judge Courtney, who nitpicks and withholds crucial evidence.

  • What are the standout elements of "The Stolen Turnabout" case?

    Despite some frustrating moments, "The Stolen Turnabout" case is memorable for its convoluted plot, forgettable victim, and unique characters like Ace Detective Luke Atmey and the introduction of Godot.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Ace Attorney Cases Ranked by Kempdog and Brother

  • Kempdog and his brother rank all Ace Attorney cases from worst to best, aiming for detailed discussions.
  • The video includes back-and-forth discussions between Kempdog and his brother, who voice Phoenix and Edgeworth, respectively.
  • Ground rules are set, emphasizing that the video is based on personal opinions and replay value.
  • The ranking covers original and second trilogies, Apollo Justice, Dual Destinies, Spirit of Justice, and the Investigations games.
  • Exclusions are noted for DGS, The Great Ace Attorney, and Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright.
  • Spoiler warning is given for all cases discussed.
  • The ranking is based on cases that make the duo want to replay them.
  • The first case, 1-1 The First Turnabout, is ranked at the bottom due to lack of interest and replay value.
  • The tutorial cases, like 1-2 The Lost Turnabout and 1-3 The Kidnapped Turnabout, are ranked low for being repetitive.
  • Case 3-4 Turnabout Beginnings is criticized for being boring, except for its impactful ending.

13:22

"Phoenix's Development and Foreshadowing in Cases"

  • The case takes place in the middle of case four, not needing to be so complicated.
  • It doesn't retcon anything, showing Apollo's development more naturally.
  • The "dark age" theme is a direct reference to Phoenix's past.
  • Phoenix aims to bring an end to the dark times and get back on track.
  • The handling of his badge loss could have been less heavy-handed.
  • The case is considered a tutorial one, ranking low among others.
  • The best part is the foreshadowing for future events in Trials and Tribulations.
  • Playing as Mia adds to the case's appeal.
  • Marvin Grossberg's complaints and Phoenix's teenage portrayal are noted.
  • The intro cases lack depth compared to longer ones in the series.
  • Turnabout Memories is praised for its foreshadowing and Mia's role.
  • The case's ranking is affected by Grossberg's complaints and Phoenix's portrayal.
  • The case's length and impact are discussed in comparison to others in the series.
  • The case's ending is critiqued for its deus ex machina nature.
  • The reveal of the killer early on diminishes suspense.
  • Redd White's character is acknowledged for his vocabulary and quirks.
  • The case's short length is noted, making it easy to replay.
  • Despite its importance, the case falls short compared to later ones in the series.
  • Turnabout Serenade from Apollo Justice is defended against criticism.
  • The guitar serenade and investigation locations are critiqued.
  • Clavier Gavin's character is highlighted as a positive aspect.
  • The case's judge moments and Apollo's development are noted.
  • The case's hate is acknowledged, but it is appreciated for its positive elements.
  • The case's replay value is discussed in comparison to other cases in the series.
  • Turnabout Big Top from Justice for All is defended against its negative reputation.
  • The case's music, characters, and unpleasant vibe are discussed.
  • Character arcs and themes of toxicity and unpleasantness are highlighted.
  • The case's depressing nature is seen as intentional and fitting with the circus theme.
  • The case's overhated status is acknowledged, with its unique aspects appreciated.
  • The case's theme of shiny exterior with a dark interior is praised for its execution.

26:39

"Engaging personalities, lackluster case: A review"

  • Introduction to Simon Blackwell and Bobby Fulbright, known for their engaging personalities and interactions in court.
  • Athena's presence, showcasing her physical prowess by suplexing a cop, and Phoenix's gradual return to his old self.
  • Critique of the case's complexity, highlighting the challenge of remembering key details but acknowledging the guidance provided.
  • Criticism of the game's linearity and lack of investigative freedom, with automatic transitions between locations.
  • Disappointment in the forgettable nature of the case, with uninteresting characters like Jinxy Tenma and Phineas Filch.
  • Florent L'Belle's entertaining shamelessness but obvious role as the killer, leading to a lack of suspense.
  • Damien Tenma's standout presence as a defendant, blending intimidating and caring traits, along with his demon possession act.
  • Overall assessment of the case as messy and subpar, despite some enjoyable elements, falling short of the series' top-tier standards.
  • Positive review of Turnabout Airlines as a solid case with interesting characters like Rhoda Taniro and Kimmy Meal.
  • Mention of Franziska's return, visually appealing settings, and the case's overall forgettable nature but ease of replay.

40:05

"Phoenix Wright: Mixed Bag of Fan Service"

  • The protagonist is confident in her abilities but still enjoys teasing Phoenix and has not fundamentally changed from her old personality.
  • The protagonist is once again the defendant, but her presence elevates the case despite some major issues that cannot be ignored.
  • The side characters are generally cared about, but the localized names used in the case are poorly executed and lack effort.
  • The main prosecutor, Nayuta Sanmahi, is criticized for tedious dialogue, repetitive insults, and lack of character progression.
  • The assistant, Rafa, is perceived as annoying and uncreative, fitting into typical anime archetypes, but some find depth in her character development.
  • The Divination Seance mechanic is highlighted as a fun and creative aspect of the case, despite potential pitfalls leading to game overs.
  • The case's momentum is noted to falter in its final moments, with a sense of dissatisfaction in the resolution and testimonies.
  • The case is described as a mixed bag, with engaging investigation sequences but less appealing trial segments, ranking it lower in the series.
  • The case is critiqued for being overstuffed with minor details and featuring a challenging character, Judge Courtney, who nitpicks and withholds crucial evidence.
  • The case is acknowledged for its fan service elements, bringing back beloved characters like Phoenix, Maya, and Edgeworth, but is criticized for its lackluster ending and unsatisfying resolution.

53:17

Character development and humor in legal drama.

  • Edward's character development is highlighted, starting as an evil prosecutor but gradually realizing his errors, culminating in a pivotal moment where he turns on his own witness to help win the case.
  • Side characters like Wendy Oldbag, Will Powers, Cody Hackins, and Penny Nichols add depth and humor to the story, with Maya shining as a standout character who brings excitement and curiosity to the case.
  • Despite some frustrating moments, "The Stolen Turnabout" case is memorable for its convoluted plot, forgettable victim, and unique characters like Ace Detective Luke Atmey and the introduction of Godot, known for his coffee addiction and sarcastic demeanor.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.