a deep dive into everything wrong with the new avatar show
A Clockwork Reader・77 minutes read
The speaker expresses deep disappointment with the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender," criticizing various aspects like casting, script, CGI, and character development. They emphasize the lack of passion and effort in the adaptation, advising against watching it and encouraging revisiting the original show instead.
Insights
- The speaker expresses deep disappointment with the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender," criticizing various aspects like casting, script, CGI, and production design, highlighting the lack of depth and character development compared to the original show.
- The adaptation is further criticized for diminishing female characters' agency, altering character dynamics, removing significant scenes and character development moments, and failing to capture the emotional depth, authenticity, and impact of the original series, urging viewers to revisit the original show instead and demand higher standards in television content.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are the criticisms of the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender"?
The speaker expresses disappointment with the adaptation's poor quality, criticizing aspects like casting, script, CGI, and production design. They highlight the lack of depth and character development compared to the original show, praising only the original soundtrack. The removal of humor, lack of passion, and effort in production, as well as the failure to capture the essence of the characters and story, are emphasized. The adaptation's writing, costuming, and overall quality are criticized, with dissatisfaction towards the lack of emotional depth and character development. The adaptation is advised against, with encouragement to revisit the original show instead.
How does the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender" differ from the original series?
The adaptation is criticized for lacking depth and meaningful character development, reducing female characters to props and removing essential conflicts. Changes in character dynamics, altered character arcs, and omitted character development are highlighted. The show's dialogue and acting feel modern and scripted, lacking authenticity and depth. Key scenes, character interactions, and lore are altered, detracting from the emotional impact and depth of the original series. The adaptation combines plots from different seasons, resulting in a rushed and confusing narrative, with continuity errors in the spirit world.
What are the major flaws in the character portrayals in the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender"?
The adaptation diminishes character depth and meaningful development, particularly with female characters reduced to props. Changes in character dynamics, altered character arcs, and omitted character development are noted. The portrayal of key scenes, like Zuko's agni kai, falls short of the original's impact. Characters lack emotional depth and strong convictions, deviating from their original complexity. The show relies heavily on telling rather than showing character development, with abrupt backstories and unconvincing portrayals.
How does the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender" handle bending abilities and character progression?
The adaptation fails to explore bending abilities and character progression effectively, with characters not receiving proper training or mastering their elements. Key moments like Aang learning firebending and overcoming fear are entirely cut out, impacting character development. Characters like Qara are declared masters without earning the title, lacking emotional outbursts or strong convictions. The adaptation deviates from the original series in handling bending abilities and character progression, leading to a lack of depth and authenticity.
What are the consequences of combining plots from different seasons in the live-action adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender"?
The adaptation's combination of plots from different seasons results in a rushed and confusing narrative, with continuity errors in the spirit world. Changes to lore and character interactions detract from the emotional impact and depth of the original series. Unexpected appearances and interactions in the spirit world disrupt coherence and depth. The adaptation alters character dynamics, removes essential conflicts, and omits significant character development, leading to a lack of depth and meaningful storytelling.
Related videos
Summary
00:00
Disappointing Netflix adaptation of Avatar: The Last Airbender
- The speaker expresses a deep love for "Avatar: The Last Airbender" and hopes for a good adaptation.
- They discuss their disappointment with the live-action adaptation of the show on Netflix.
- The speaker shares their thoughts on the poor quality of the adaptation, criticizing various aspects like casting, script, CGI, and production design.
- They highlight the lack of depth and character development in the adaptation compared to the original show.
- The speaker praises the original soundtrack but criticizes almost every other aspect of the adaptation.
- They mention the removal of humor from the adaptation, which was a key element in the original show.
- The speaker expresses their disappointment with the adaptation's writing, costuming, and overall quality.
- They emphasize the show's failure to capture the essence and complexity of the original characters and story.
- The speaker concludes by advising against watching the adaptation and encourages revisiting the original show instead.
- They express a wish that the adaptation had not been made and criticize the lack of passion and effort put into the production.
13:23
Critique of Avatar: The Last Airbender
- The title card of the show is criticized for its font and animation.
- The reviewer expresses dissatisfaction with the initial scenes and introduction of the show.
- The portrayal of Aang flying is deemed corny and poorly animated.
- Aang's discovery of being the Avatar and subsequent decision to run away is analyzed.
- The lack of emotional depth and character development in the adaptation is highlighted.
- The removal of significant scenes, like Katara breaking Aang out of the iceberg, is criticized.
- The acting performances of the cast are deemed subpar and unconvincing.
- The absence of the Aang-Katara romance and iconic moments like "yip yip" is noted.
- The portrayal of the air Nomads' genocide is considered unnecessary and lacking impact.
- The emotional payoff of Aang finding Monk Gyatso's body is deemed lacking compared to the original series.
25:42
"Rebooted show fails female characters"
- The show aimed to be less sexist than the original but ended up being more sexist and misogynistic.
- Female characters lost agency and well-written parts in the new version.
- Episode two focuses on changes in character dynamics, particularly with Saka and Suki.
- Saka's motivation for visiting Kyoshi Island is altered, now centered around stealing Zuko's diary.
- The original lines and dynamics between Saka and Suki are removed, leading to a shallow relationship.
- Suki's character is diminished, with her role reduced to being interested in Saka's appearance.
- Suki teaches Saka to fight without him wearing the Kyoshi warrior costume or makeup.
- The original lesson of humility and respect is lost, with Suki thanking Saka instead of him learning from her.
- The new version lacks depth and meaningful character development, with female characters reduced to props.
- The show's dialogue and acting feel modern and scripted, lacking authenticity and depth.
38:13
"Episode 3: Missing Character Development and Depth"
- Episode 3 omitted crucial character development for Zuko and Xiao, cutting out significant fight scenes from the original show.
- The episode also removed philosophical commentary and emotional depth by excluding Teo and his father's storyline.
- Ang's pivotal moment of learning firebending and overcoming his fear was entirely cut out, impacting his character development.
- The introduction of Jet and the Freedom Fighters lacked depth and purpose, altering character dynamics and removing essential conflicts.
- The episode failed to explore Ang's grief over the destruction of the air temple and the displacement of refugees by the Fire Nation.
- Qara's character arc was altered, with Jet inexplicably helping her overcome her bending block through a guided meditation.
- The episode lacked coherence and depth, with significant plot points and character development being omitted or altered.
- The appearance and characterization of Boomie were criticized for being poorly executed and lacking authenticity.
- The episode combined multiple plots from different seasons, resulting in a rushed and confusing narrative.
- Changes to lore and character interactions, like Iro's uncharacteristic behavior, detracted from the original show's emotional impact and depth.
51:05
"Avatar: Book One Adaptation Disappoints Fans"
- The show introduces elements from book two into book one, causing confusion.
- Boomi lectures Aang on responsibility despite Aang not goofing off.
- The episode "Spirited Away" delves into Zuko, Ozai, and Azula's dynamics.
- The characters enter the spirit world and encounter Co, a menacing entity.
- Aang seeks help from Roku in the Fire Nation temple to free his friends.
- Continuity errors occur in the spirit world, with unexpected appearances and interactions.
- The show relies heavily on telling rather than showing character development.
- Katara's backstory is abruptly revealed, lacking the buildup seen in the original series.
- Zuko's backstory is explored, but the character's portrayal feels lacking.
- The show's adaptation of key scenes, like Zuko's agni kai, falls short of the original's impact.
01:03:48
"Avatar: Spirit UA, Qara's Waterbending Journey"
- UA is revealed to be part spirit in addition to having the moon spirit within her, allowing her to transform into other spirits and access the spirit world.
- Qara does not learn waterbending from Master Paku, as neither she nor Ang ever receive waterbending training throughout the season.
- Qara convinces Master Paku to let her fight in the battle against the Fire Nation by rallying the women from the healing Hut to join the fight.
- Qara is declared a waterbending master without earning the title, having only practiced with a single scroll she took from the Southern Water Tribe.
- Ang never waterbends in the entire season, despite the expectation for him to learn waterbending being a central theme.
- Qara lacks any emotional outbursts or strong convictions, deviating from her original character who stood up for her beliefs.
- The live-action adaptation on Netflix is criticized for its poor writing, lack of character development, and deviation from the original series, urging viewers to demand higher standards in television content.
