7. Behavioral Genetics II

Stanford・2 minutes read

Genetic variations impact behavior, but environmental factors play a significant role in determining traits accurately, with gene-environment interactions crucial for understanding behavior. Gender differences in cognitive skills vary across countries based on societal treatment of genders, with environmental factors often underestimated in studies on genetic influences.

Insights

  • Breeding Siberian foxes for tameness can result in physical traits similar to puppies after 30 generations, showcasing the rapid evolution of behavior and appearance.
  • Behavior genetics focuses on genetic patterns influencing behavior, with studies on twins and genetic markers for diseases aiding in research, highlighting the impact of genetics on health outcomes.
  • Heritability measures the variability, not the average level, of traits influenced by genes and environment, emphasizing the importance of gene-environment interactions in determining behavior and health outcomes.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How can genetic differences impact behavior?

    Genetic differences can influence behavior through variations in specific genes like the vasopressin receptor and BDNF. For example, differences in the vasopressin receptor gene can affect social behavior and relationships in humans, while variants of the BDNF gene can impact anxiety levels and stress responses. These genetic variations can lead to differences in behavior and health outcomes, showcasing the significant role genes play in shaping individual traits and responses.

  • What is the role of heritability in trait variability?

    Heritability measures the degree of variability around the average level of a trait, not the average level itself. It does not indicate how much genes determine the average trait, but rather how much they determine the variability in traits. Heritability is a way to understand the less deterministic nature of genes in various cases. By studying heritability through gene variants, like in the example of plant IQ with different gene versions, researchers can assess the impact of genes on trait variability accurately.

  • How do genes interact with the environment in determining traits?

    Genes interact with the environment to influence traits, showcasing the importance of gene-environment interactions. Understanding these interactions is crucial in interpreting the influence of genes on traits accurately. The variability in traits is often more explained by environmental factors than genetic differences, impacting the heritability of traits. By considering gene-environment interactions, researchers can fully comprehend how genes and the environment work together to shape individual traits and behaviors.

  • What factors influence cognitive abilities?

    Cognitive abilities can be influenced by genetic differences and environmental factors. Different versions of genes can affect cognitive skills like math performance, with societal gender equality playing a role in shaping these abilities. Gender differences in cognitive skills vary across countries based on their gender equality index, showcasing how societal treatment of genders can impact cognitive abilities. Factors like upbringing, societal norms, and genetic predispositions all play a role in determining cognitive skills in individuals.

  • How do gender differences in cognitive skills vary globally?

    Gender differences in cognitive skills vary across countries based on societal treatment of genders and gender equality. In Iceland, girls perform slightly better in math than boys, showcasing a minimal gender difference. The level of gender differentiation in societies correlates with math performance discrepancies, with Scandinavian countries showing zero gender gap in math scores due to less differentiation. Environmental factors and societal norms play a crucial role in determining gender differences in cognitive skills, highlighting the impact of upbringing and societal treatment on individual abilities.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Rapid Evolution and Genetic Markers in Behavior

  • Siberian foxes can be bred for tameness, resulting in physical traits resembling puppies after 30 generations.
  • Evolution can occur rapidly, leading to changes in behavior and physical appearance.
  • Metro dogs in Moscow's subway system have evolved over 30 generations to exhibit wolf-like traits due to their feral lifestyle.
  • Behavior genetics focuses on patterns of behavior related to genetics rather than constructing evolutionary stories.
  • Studies involving monozygotic twins, adopted individuals, and separated identical twins help eliminate environmental influences in behavior genetics research.
  • Prenatal environment can have lifelong consequences, leading to the field of fetal origins of adult disease and epigenetics.
  • Genetic differences can be identified by observing external manifestations, protein variants, or differences in protein size and function.
  • Genetic markers for diseases are identified by analyzing DNA from families with the disease to locate a stretch of DNA containing the candidate gene.
  • RFLP technique, focusing on restriction fragment length polymorphisms, helps identify genetic markers for diseases but requires meticulous analysis and statistical validation.
  • Genetic markers play a crucial role in advising individuals on genetic testing and potential pregnancy decisions based on genetic information.

14:17

Genetics, Disease, and Ethics: Clinical Challenges and Advances

  • The field of genetics and disease presents challenges in terms of clinical application and bioethics.
  • Testing for genetic markers of diseases raises ethical dilemmas, especially for diseases with no cure.
  • Advancements in molecular biology have improved the ability to identify specific genes and mutations.
  • Diseases like psychiatric disorders and diabetes involve multiple genes, not just one.
  • Techniques like gene microarrays and QTLs help identify multiple genes influencing complex traits.
  • Gene sequencing and analysis have led to significant progress in understanding genetic variations.
  • Studies on genes like vasopressin receptor and BDNF show how genetic variants can impact behavior and health.
  • Genetic differences in vasopressin receptor gene can affect social behavior and relationships in humans.
  • Variants of the BDNF gene can influence anxiety levels and stress responses in individuals.
  • Research in genetics aims to understand how specific genes and variants impact human behavior and health outcomes.

27:56

Genetic variations impact behavior and traits.

  • Metabolic activity in the amygdala shows similar findings to other areas.
  • The neurotransmitter dopamine and its receptors, particularly D4, are linked to various traits in rodents and humans.
  • Dopamine is associated with pleasure, anticipation, and reward-seeking behavior.
  • Different versions of the dopamine type four receptor gene in humans map onto risk-taking, sensation seeking, and novelty craving behaviors.
  • The gene NPY and its variants are linked to anxiety levels and metabolic rates in the amygdala.
  • Genetic differences explain small percentages of variability in behavior.
  • Genetic links to behavior are significant but not deterministic.
  • The field explores genetic variations and their impact on behavior, emphasizing nature, nurture, and chance.
  • Mitochondria within cells can have different genetic makeups due to random events during cell division.
  • Heritability measures the degree of variability around the average level of a trait, not the average level itself.

42:23

Genes, Environment, and Trait Variability Explained

  • Heritability does not indicate how much genes determine the average trait, but rather how much they determine the variability in traits.
  • Heritability is a way to understand the less deterministic nature of genes in various cases.
  • Heritability is often studied through variants of genes, such as in the example of a plant with three different gene versions affecting a trait like IQ.
  • The predictive power of genes in determining traits can vary significantly based on the environment in which the study is conducted.
  • Scientists often design experiments that eliminate environmental influences, leading to an overemphasis on genetic factors in trait variability.
  • Controlling for environment is crucial in accurately assessing the impact of genes on traits.
  • The heritability of a trait can be low if environmental factors play a significant role in trait variability.
  • Understanding gene-environment interactions is essential in interpreting the influence of genes on traits accurately.
  • The variability in traits is often more explained by environmental factors than genetic differences, impacting the heritability of traits.
  • It is crucial to consider gene-environment interactions to fully comprehend the role of genes in determining traits accurately.

56:33

Genes and Environment Influence Trait Variability

  • The number of fingers a person has has 0% heritability, with variability being entirely environmental due to industrial accidents.
  • In 1952 America, earring-wearing behavior had 100% heritability, with males and females showing distinct patterns.
  • A study involving plant IQ in different environments and gene variations showed that gene type entirely explained variability, indicating 100% heritability.
  • Another study on plant IQ in various environments revealed no difference based on gene type, indicating 0% heritability.
  • The PKU disease, affected by a gene mutation, showed 100% heritability until environmental interventions reduced it to 0%.
  • A study on a gene related to depression in different environments showed that the risk of depression depended on childhood stressors, indicating a gene-environment interaction.
  • The same study revealed that the bad version of the gene was slightly protective in certain environments, showcasing a radical gene-environment interaction.
  • Heritability numbers indicate variability, not average levels of traits, leading to counter-intuitive findings like earrings being heritable while the number of fingers is not.
  • Scientists often eliminate environmental variability in experiments, artificially inflating the heritability of traits.
  • Studying traits in diverse environments can reveal the true impact of genes and the environment on variability.

01:10:32

Genes' role in traits influenced by environment.

  • The more environments a genetically influenced trait is studied in, the less significant genes appear to be in determining the trait.
  • Genes' importance in determining traits diminishes as more environments are studied.
  • The interaction between genes and environment is crucial in understanding genetic influence on traits.
  • The significance of genes in determining traits varies based on the environment studied.
  • The impact of genes on behavior is influenced by childhood stress levels.
  • The interaction between genes and stress hormones affects behavior.
  • Genetic variations can predispose individuals to certain behaviors based on environmental factors.
  • Different versions of genes can affect cognitive abilities depending on environmental factors.
  • Genetic differences can impact cognitive skills, such as math performance, based on societal gender equality.
  • Gender differences in cognitive skills can be influenced by societal treatment of genders.

01:25:00

Gender, Environment, and Math Performance in Society

  • In Iceland, girls perform slightly better in math than boys, showcasing a minimal gender difference.
  • The level of gender differentiation in societies correlates with math performance discrepancies, with the least differentiation in Scandinavian countries resulting in zero gender gap in math scores.
  • Environment plays a crucial role in determining math capabilities, with upbringing in a specific society being more indicative of math skills than gender.
  • Gender differences in cognitive skills, such as verbal performance, vary across countries based on their gender equality index.
  • The influence of genes on behavior is significant, but environmental factors are often underestimated in studies, impacting the understanding of genetic influences.
  • Human genes primarily code for freedom from genetic constraints, emphasizing the role of environment in shaping behavior.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.