tier ranking every book i've ever rated five stars ⭐️

lexi aka newlynova・2 minutes read

Lexi, an avid reader, plans to tier rank her five-star books based on their lasting impact and quality, discussing each book in detail without spoilers. Despite evolving reading tastes and fewer five-star ratings over time, Lexi reflects on various books, including standouts like "A Man Called Ove," "Educated," and "Legendborn," sharing her evolving thoughts and preferences.

Insights

Lexi categorizes her five-star books into different tiers based on their lasting impact and quality, with tiers like "I will never shut up about this" for exceptional favorites and "Simple to understand holds up" for books that haven't stood the test of time well.
Lexi reflects on her evolving reading tastes, noting a higher standard over time leading to fewer five-star ratings, showcasing personal growth and discernment in book selection.
Various books are discussed with detailed insights, including standouts like "Legendborn" for rekindling interest in YA fantasy, "My Dark Vanessa" for its emotional impact, and "The Night Circus" for its unmatched sense of wonder and enchantment.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

What is the top tier of Lexi's five-star book ranking system?
"I will never shut up about this."
What is the next tier after "I will never shut up about this" in Lexi's ranking system?
"Perfect book no notes."
What is the tier for books that Lexi may not have given a five-star rating upon reflection?
"I was being nice."
What is the tier for books that Lexi has no memory of reading?
"She doesn't even go here."
What is the tier for books that Lexi is slightly ashamed to have given five stars?
"Sweet summer child."

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Lexi's Tiered Five-Star Book Rankings

The speaker, Lexi, is an avid reader with nearly 300 books logged on Goodreads, having rated 53 books five stars in the past three years.
Lexi plans to tier rank her five-star books, categorizing them into different tiers based on their lasting impact and quality.
The top tier, "I will never shut up about this," includes books that are considered life-altering and exceptional favorites.
The next tier, "Perfect book no notes," consists of five-star books with an extra special quality that stands out.
The "Simple to understand holds up" tier features valid five-star books that haven't stood the test of time as well as others.
The "I was being nice" tier includes books that, upon reflection, may not have deserved a five-star rating.
The "She doesn't even go here" tier comprises books that Lexi has no memory of reading, indicating they may not have left a lasting impression.
The "Sweet summer child" tier is for books that Lexi is slightly ashamed to have given five stars, suggesting they may not hold up to her current standards.
Lexi plans to discuss each book in detail, without spoilers, and will be honest about her current feelings towards them.
Lexi reflects on her evolving reading tastes, noting that her standards have become higher over time, leading to fewer five-star ratings.
Lexi begins discussing specific books she has rated five stars, sharing her thoughts on each one, including "A Man Called Ove," "Act Your Age, Eve Brown," "Babble," "Bad Blood," "Betty," "Beach Read," "Displacement," "Educated," "Firekeeper's Daughter," "The Hating Game," and "Heartstopper."

10:38

Top-rated books offer diverse, impactful stories.

Carmen Maria Machado is the author of "Her Body and Other Parties," a short story collection that received a rating of 4.5 due to some stories being weaker than others.
The collection includes standout stories like "The Husband Stitch" and a Law and Order SVU-inspired tale that divided opinions.
"Homegoing" by Yaa Gyasi was initially considered for a 4.5 rating but was ultimately given 5 stars for its impressive family saga structure.
"I'll Be Gone in the Dark" by Michelle McNamara focuses on the Golden State Killer case, with the author passing away before his capture.
"I Hate Everyone But You" by Gaby Dunn and Allison Raskin resonated with the reader due to its exploration of Hollywood's treatment of children.
"In the Dream House" by Carmen Maria Machado is praised for its innovative storytelling about an abusive relationship.
"Into Thin Air" by Jon Krakauer recounts a disastrous Everest expedition, making it read like a thriller with memorable characters.
"Know My Name" by Chanel Miller is highly recommended for its impactful memoir on gendered violence and injustice.
"Legendborn" by Tracy Deonn is lauded as a top-tier YA fantasy that rekindles interest in the genre.
"My Dark Vanessa" by Kate Elizabeth Russell is emotionally impactful, becoming a favorite for its profound impact on the reader.

22:08

Romance, Fantasy, and Found Family Favorites

The text discusses the experience of reading various books and rating them, starting with a romance novel with a plus-sized lead, read during a reality TV hyperfixation phase.
The reader designed a fantasy Bachelor league during this time but did not win, and the book was not a five-star read despite enjoying the representation of plus-sized characters.
Another book, "Seven Days in June," is the reader's favorite romance novel, featuring historical tension and a second chance romance that stood out for its depth and tension.
"Six of Crows" and "Crooked Kingdom" are praised for their found family dynamics, characterization, and heist plot, earning a perfect book rating.
"The Wicked King" from the Cruel Prince Trilogy is lauded for its protagonist, Jude, and her complex, evil romance with Cardan, sparking a love for reading.
"The Obelisk Gate" and "The Stone Sky" from the Fifth Season Trilogy are commended for their world-building, emotional impact, and dark fantasy elements, earning a perfect book rating.
"The Hard Principle," a contemporary fiction and romance novel, initially made the reader emotional but upon reflection, the rushed ending and dual focus on romance and family dynamics may not warrant a five-star rating.
"The Last Olympian" from the Percy Jackson series is viewed fondly but critiqued for the handling of characters Luke and Annabeth, preventing a five-star rating.
"The Midnight Library" is acknowledged for its emotional impact during a low point in the reader's life, likely to receive a five-star rating upon a reread.
"The Night Circus" is highlighted for its immersive experience, unique storytelling, and unmatched impact compared to other books, making it a standout read.

33:37

Books with Strong Characters and Emotional Depth

The book "The Night Circus" evokes a unique sense of wonder and enchantment, making it stand out despite weak plot and character development.
"The Office of Historical Corrections" is highly praised for its emotional depth and range of feelings it evokes, with each short story being exceptional.
The "Poppy War Trilogy" is recommended for its strong characters, particularly the protagonist Ren, and the compelling narrative throughout the entire series.
"The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo" is a compulsively readable book with a strong, sarcastic voice in the character of Evelyn Hugo, although there are debates about its representation.
"The Song of Achilles" is unexpectedly popular on BookTok despite its slow pace and descriptive nature, offering a beautiful and emotional retelling of the Iliad.
"Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" is a deeply impactful book that resonates with the reader through its storytelling and exploration of relationships, making it a favorite.
"The Story Life of AJ Fikry" is compared to "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" but falls short in leaving a lasting impression, despite being enjoyable.
"This is Water" by David Foster Wallace is a significant piece that constantly resonates with the reader, emphasizing the importance of kindness in interactions.
"Verity" by Colleen Hoover is a thrilling read with intense emotions and shocking plot twists, although the author's other works have complicated the reader's perception of the book.
"We Should All Be Feminists" is a short but impactful book that loses its appeal due to the author's problematic views, leading to a reevaluation of its significance.
"Yellow Face" by RF Kuang, while thought-provoking and insightful about the publishing industry's injustices, could have been more concise in delivering its message, making it slightly weaker compared to the author's other works.

44:59

Embracing Love for Books, Humorous Video

The speaker expresses relief that their love for certain books remains integral to their personality, deciding not to rank or order them at the moment. Despite a strained voice, they end the video by encouraging likes, comments on favorite books, and subscribing, while humorously warning against criticism of a particular book. They plan to rest and take medication for their throat.

Try it yourself — It’s free.