The TRUTH About Social Media & Your Children | Jonathan Haidt X Rich Roll Podcast

Rich Roll・2 minutes read

American kids spend a significant amount of time on social media, affecting their mental health negatively as discussed by Jonathan Haidt, who explores how social media impacts childhood development and perception. Recommendations include delaying smartphone use, avoiding social media until 16, and implementing phone-free schools to reduce screen time and combat rising rates of depression and suicide.

Insights

  • American kids spend a significant amount of time on social media, impacting their mental health negatively, especially post-2012.
  • Parents give children phones early due to fear of missing out, affecting their playtime and social interactions negatively.
  • The shift to smartphones by 2015 increased online time for kids, impacting their development and social skills.
  • Social media has worsened mental health issues in children, especially girls, leading to addictive behaviors and emotional vulnerability.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How does social media impact children's mental health?

    Social media negatively affects children's mental health by increasing screen time, leading to issues like loneliness, depression, and self-harm. The constant exposure to social media platforms can exploit emotional vulnerabilities, especially in teenagers, affecting their growth and perception. The addictive nature of social media, coupled with the pressure to maintain online presence, can worsen mental health post-2012, particularly for Gen Z. The shift to smartphones by 2015 increased online time, impacting children's development and social skills. Overall, social media's influence on children's mental health has raised concerns about addiction, compulsive use, and the need for parental control.

  • What are the recommendations to mitigate the negative effects of social media on children?

    To reduce the adverse impact of social media on children, recommendations include delaying smartphone use until high school, avoiding social media until 16, and implementing phone-free schools. By limiting screen time and increasing real-world experiences, children can combat rising rates of depression and suicide. Giving kids more independence, free play, and responsibilities in the physical world can help balance the effects of excessive screen time. These reforms aim to address the challenges posed by social media on children's mental health and overall development.

  • How do social media platforms target teenagers emotionally?

    Social media platforms target teenagers emotionally by exploiting their intense emotions and lack of self-control. The algorithms on these platforms are designed to engage users by tapping into their vulnerabilities, especially affecting girls who are more prone to emotional contagion. Features like heat maps and streaks on platforms like Snapchat can exacerbate feelings of exclusion and pressure to maintain constant engagement. By understanding and manipulating teenagers' emotional vulnerabilities, social media platforms can influence their behaviors and mental well-being significantly.

  • What are the potential consequences of excessive social media use on children?

    Excessive social media use by children can lead to various negative consequences, including loneliness, depression, self-harm, and addiction. The constant exposure to social media platforms can impact children's mental health, social skills, and overall development. The addictive nature of social media, coupled with the pressure to maintain online presence, can worsen mental health post-2012, particularly for Gen Z. By understanding the potential consequences of excessive social media use, parents and educators can take steps to mitigate these effects and promote healthier screen time habits for children.

  • How can parents manage their children's device usage effectively?

    Parents can manage their children's device usage effectively by creating collective rules with other parents, setting boundaries, and limiting smartphone use at home. By fostering healthier relationships with technology and encouraging phone-free environments, parents can help children develop a balanced approach to screen time. Schools going phone-free can also improve social interactions and inclusivity among children. It is essential for parents to be aware of the harmful effects of excessive phone use and take proactive steps to regulate and monitor their children's device usage for their overall well-being.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Social media's impact on children's development

  • American kids spend 5 hours a day on social media, impacting their mental health negatively.
  • Jonathan Haidt, a social psychologist, discusses the interplay between technology and childhood.
  • Parents give kids phones early due to fear of missing out, affecting childhood play and interaction.
  • In "The Anxious Generation," Haidt explores how social media alters children's growth and perception.
  • Children's data is sold by companies, raising concerns about parental control.
  • Social media's impact on children's mental health worsened post-2012, especially for Gen Z.
  • The shift to smartphones by 2015 led to increased online time for kids, affecting their development.
  • Puberty is crucial for brain development, with play shaping social skills and identity.
  • Early puberty (ages 10-14) is vulnerable to smartphone influence, impacting social and neurological development.
  • Loss of childhood independence and trust in children led to increased supervision, affecting kids' development negatively.

14:07

Digital dangers: Impact of screens on children

  • The digital space is more dangerous than the physical world, with techno optimism in the 90s and 2000s leading to the belief that technology would benefit children.
  • Tech companies pushed for children to have devices without data on the impact, leading to devices taking over childhood.
  • The pandemic highlighted the negative effects of excessive screen time on mental health and child development.
  • The initial excitement of the internet promised connectivity and access to information for a better world, but hyperconnectivity now leads to loneliness, depression, and self-harm.
  • Four foundational harms affecting children and adults are social deprivation, sleep deprivation, cognitive fragmentation, and addiction.
  • American kids spend 5 hours daily on social media and 3-5 hours on other screen-based activities, impacting hobbies, reading, and outdoor play.
  • Social deprivation data shows a significant decrease in time spent with friends, especially among teenagers, with a steep decline post-2010.
  • Attention fragmentation due to multitasking and notifications on smartphones affects focus and productivity, particularly in teenagers with developing brains.
  • Social media targets the emotional vulnerability of teenagers, especially girls, exploiting their intense emotions and lack of self-control.
  • Raising the age limit for social media accounts to 16 or 18 is recommended to mitigate the negative effects of addiction and compulsive use on children's mental health.

27:17

"Video games vs social media addiction"

  • Video games are generally not harmful for boys on average, while social media is harmful for girls on average.
  • Between 2 and 15% of individuals may experience addiction or problematic use of video games or social media.
  • Even if most kids are not addicted, a significant percentage being addicted is concerning.
  • Certain individuals may be more prone to addiction due to brain traits, but everyone can be trained through reward systems.
  • Dopamine plays a crucial role in motivation and can lead to addictive behaviors.
  • Boys and girls show different patterns in mental health issues, with boys having higher suicide rates but girls experiencing a sharper increase in mental health issues in recent years.
  • Girls' mental health deterioration is linked to the rise of social media, especially after 2012-2013 when platforms like Instagram became popular.
  • Girls are more vulnerable to emotional contagion through social media due to their tendency to share emotions and the stronger impact of negative emotions.
  • Snapchat features like heat maps and streaks can exacerbate feelings of exclusion and pressure to maintain constant engagement.
  • The author's views on Snapchat have become more negative due to features like heat maps and streaks that can negatively impact users' mental health and social dynamics.

40:28

Snapchat's Solar System Feature: Harmful for Kids

  • Snapchat's feature that shows users their social universe like a solar system is criticized as harmful, especially for kids.
  • Paying subscribers can access this feature for $4 a month, revealing who is closest to them based on communication patterns.
  • The feature can lead to revelations about friendships, potentially causing distress and confusion.
  • A study by the University of Chicago revealed the value people place on social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram.
  • The study showed that individuals would pay to get off these platforms if everyone else did too, highlighting the addictive nature of these apps.
  • College students expressed a desire to get off TikTok if others did, indicating a collective action problem.
  • The author suggests solutions like delaying smartphone use until high school, avoiding social media until 16, and implementing phone-free schools.
  • The author emphasizes the importance of giving kids more independence, free play, and responsibilities in the real world.
  • These reforms aim to reduce screen time, increase real-world experiences, and combat rising rates of depression and suicide.
  • Counterarguments include the correlation versus causation debate and the consideration of other societal factors like economic disparities and the opioid crisis.

52:44

Social Media's Impact on Teen Mental Health

  • Correlation does not imply causation, but there are numerous experiments that show causation, such as studies where kids were assigned to go off social media for a month, resulting in a positive effect.
  • There is a significant amount of experimental evidence contradicting the claim that all evidence is correlational, with longitudinal studies and experiments supporting causation.
  • Skeptics demanding proof beyond a reasonable doubt are using an inappropriate standard for a public health emergency, where action is necessary even without absolute certainty, especially when the proposed actions are low-cost and harmless.
  • The increase in Teen Mental Health issues is not limited to the United States, as similar trends are observed in English-speaking countries, Northern Europe, and other nations, indicating a global crisis.
  • The stigma around mental health has decreased, but social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram have created communities where mental illness is valorized, potentially leading to over-therapy and misinformation.
  • Social media has contributed to the fragmentation of society, with algorithms promoting extreme content and leading to a lack of shared reality, challenging the cohesion of society and democracy.
  • Social media's viral nature has exacerbated tribalism, leading to a fragmentation of society and a lack of shared understanding, with extreme voices dominating and moderates being silenced.
  • The spiral of silence phenomenon, where moderates are silenced, leading to a shift towards extreme views, is evident in both the Republican and Democratic parties, as well as in left-leaning institutions like universities and media.
  • The current information environment, influenced by social media, has led to a rise in contrarianism and misinformation, creating challenges for societal cohesion and democracy.
  • The impact of social media on Teen Mental Health and society at large is a complex issue that requires further understanding and consideration of the broader implications of online platforms.

01:05:59

Social media's influence on democracy and trust.

  • Social media silences moderates, empowering extremists and hindering common understanding.
  • Public trust in institutions is eroded by social media dynamics.
  • The younger generation faces challenges in forming opinions amidst social media influence.
  • The impact of AI on societal trust and democratic institutions is concerning.
  • The ability to regulate social media for adults is limited due to the First Amendment.
  • Trust in institutions, especially higher education, has declined since 2015 due to political agendas.
  • Despite challenges, there are signs of improvement in higher education with initiatives like Heterodox Academy.
  • Democracies face problems that worsen before ultimately being fixed.
  • The current state of American political life is concerning but could potentially change.
  • Social media's impact on spiritual degradation contrasts with ancient wisdom, promoting judgment and self-focus.

01:19:29

"Rediscovering ancient wisdom for modern spirituality"

  • The speaker, an atheist of Jewish ethnicity, delves into research on morality and religion due to their close connection, leading to the study of ancient insights.
  • Modern society is losing touch with past wisdom, guidance, and spiritual wisdom, emphasizing a battle between ego/self-focus and self-transcendence.
  • The speaker highlights the importance of investing in self-transcendence and being present offline to cultivate empathy, forgiveness, and spiritual growth.
  • Engaging in practices that focus on self-improvement, mental health, and self-transcendence requires conscious commitment and habit changes.
  • The speaker discusses the crisis of meaning and lack of purpose in modern society, emphasizing the importance of moving towards a higher, selfless focus.
  • Drawing from experiences in India, the speaker explores the concept of a vertical dimension in life, highlighting the psychological significance of high vs. low and divinity vs. carnal aspects.
  • The speaker reflects on the loss of the third dimension of divinity in modern society, leading to a sense of dissatisfaction and disorientation.
  • Research on moral psychology has shifted the speaker's perspective towards understanding the importance of communal morality and the limitations of reasoning in moral development.
  • Addressing the cohesion problem in American politics, the speaker suggests emphasizing assimilation, national service, and common experiences to bridge ideological divides.
  • Practical advice for parents on managing children's device usage includes creating collective rules with other parents, setting boundaries, and limiting smartphone use at home to foster healthier relationships with technology.

01:33:03

Limit children's phone use for social health.

  • Encourage limiting children's phone use, suggesting schools go phone-free to improve social interactions and inclusivity.
  • Highlight the challenge of individuals, including tech leaders, to recognize the harmful effects of excessive phone use.
  • Express skepticism towards social media companies' willingness to reform without legislative or legal pressure.
  • Discuss the impact of lawsuits on social media companies and the potential for significant legal actions.
  • Advocate for the Kids Online Safety Act to mitigate the negative effects of social media on children.
  • Praise bipartisan efforts in addressing social media issues and the potential for collective action to combat these challenges.
  • Identify TikTok as the most damaging platform due to its addictive nature and negative impact on mental health.
  • Criticize Instagram and YouTube for promoting social comparison and edited realities, particularly harmful to young girls.
  • Emphasize the importance of delaying children's exposure to social media until later in adolescence.
  • Call for stricter enforcement of age restrictions on social media platforms and pressure on Congress to regulate the industry effectively.

01:46:07

Empowering Art Project Engages Youth Through Emotion

  • The art project involves a photo of a girl in front of the capital, initially displayed on the National Mall in Washington, then moved to New York City, and later to San Francisco.
  • The project aims to raise funds to bring the art to Los Angeles and potentially other cities, with a focus on engaging young people through social media like Instagram.
  • The project's goal is to evoke gut feelings through art and dramatic images, aligning with the academic research on moral foundations Theory.
  • The art project includes provocative images like a girl in a space suit with the phrase "send me to Mars," aiming to tap into people's emotions and prompt deeper reflection.
  • The project also involves creating billboards and posters with impactful messages, such as "supervision is love," to illustrate metaphors and evoke strong reactions.
  • Anxiousgeneration.com serves as a platform for the art project, offering resources for parents, teachers, and schools to encourage phone-free environments and facilitate collective action.
  • The project's ultimate aim is to empower parents to organize local collective action, starting with small groups to address the societal issue of excessive phone use among children and teenagers.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.