Dr. Jonathan Haidt: How Smartphones & Social Media Impact Mental Health & the Realistic Solutions

Andrew Huberman・2 minutes read

The Huberman Lab podcast, featuring Dr. Jonathan Haidt, delves into the mental health crisis in youth caused by smartphone use, offering solutions to guide them back to a healthy mental trajectory, emphasizing the need to understand neurobiology, psychology, social psychology, and technology to support the youth population. The discussion highlights the detrimental impact of smartphones on youth mental health, especially in girls, leading to increased rates of depression and anxiety, urging for limits on smartphone and social media use to foster healthy development.

Insights

  • Smartphone use, especially among youth, has led to a mental health crisis, with specific impacts on girls' and boys' depression rates and overall well-being.
  • The transition from a play-based childhood to a phone-based childhood post-2010 has negatively affected healthy human development, particularly in social skills and community trust.
  • Prominent figures like Dr. Jonathan Haidt emphasize the need to understand and address the addictive nature of smartphone and social media use, which can lead to mental health challenges, especially in youth.
  • Recommendations include delaying smartphone exposure until late puberty to prevent negative effects on neuroplasticity and impulse control, advocating for flip phones as an alternative.
  • Social media plays a significant role in shaping children's behaviors, with a focus on perfectionism, image presentation, and heightened social interactions leading to anxiety and depression, particularly among girls.
  • Collective action, such as implementing phone-free policies in schools and advocating for age limits on social media access, is crucial to protect children from the negative impacts of excessive screen time and technology use.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How does smartphone use impact mental health?

    Smartphone use, especially among youth, has been linked to a rise in depression and anxiety rates, particularly in girls starting around 2012. Factors like screen time, content viewed, and social dynamics play a role in this decline in mental health. The addictive nature of smartphones and social media can create an obsessive-compulsive loop that hinders focus and attention, leading to significant mental health challenges. Understanding the impact of technology on neurobiology, psychology, and social dynamics is crucial to address these mental health issues and guide young individuals back to a healthy mental trajectory.

  • What are the effects of social media on children?

    Social media platforms have been associated with increased anxiety, depression, and self-critique among children, especially girls who spend significant time on platforms like TikTok and YouTube. The pressure to present a perfect image online, fear of missing out, and heightened social interactions contribute to these negative effects. Boys, on the other hand, often engage in humor and quick jokes online, but both genders experience similar insecurities and fears. The lack of low stakes mistakes online, where errors can lead to public shaming, can have long-term consequences on children's mental health and well-being.

  • How can parents help children navigate technology?

    Parents can play a crucial role in helping children navigate technology by limiting access to smartphones and social media, especially before high school. Implementing rules like no smartphones before high school and restricting internet exposure can prevent excessive dopamine-driven neuroplasticity and negative impacts on behavior and identity formation. Collaborating with other parents to advocate for phone-free schools, promoting exploration and independence, and modeling positive habits can create a healthier relationship between children and technology.

  • What are the benefits of a play-based childhood?

    A play-based childhood, characterized by activities like team sports, music, and free play, offers numerous benefits for children's mental health and development. Engaging in activities that promote social interaction, cooperation, and creativity can enhance neuroplasticity, social connections, and self-transcendent moments. Encouraging children to experience boredom, explore personal preferences, and engage in real-world responsibilities can foster a fulfilling childhood beyond virtual adventures. Restoring a play-based childhood can counteract the negative effects of excessive social media use and promote overall well-being.

  • Why is it important to limit children's exposure to harmful content?

    Limiting children's exposure to harmful content, especially on social media, is crucial to protect their mental health and well-being. Trauma from adverse events or extreme content can permanently alter brain responses, affecting effectiveness in life and leading to negative consequences. Strategies like reducing the quantity of information consumed, avoiding disturbing content, and promoting real-world experiences can help children navigate the challenges of technology and maintain a healthy relationship with screens. By implementing phone-free policies in schools, encouraging independence, and advocating for norm changes, parents can create a safer environment for children to grow and develop.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Youth Mental Health Crisis: Smartphone Solutions

  • The Huberman Lab podcast discusses science and science-based tools for everyday life, hosted by Andrew Huberman, a professor at Stanford School of Medicine.
  • Dr. Jonathan Haidt, a social psychologist and author, is a guest on the podcast, focusing on his book "The Anxious Generation" and solutions to the mental health crisis caused by smartphone use, especially in youth.
  • The discussion covers critical periods for social development, understanding competition, violence, and sex, and the differing impacts of smartphone use on boys and girls.
  • Dr. Haidt offers specific solutions to address mental health challenges caused by smartphone use, aiming to guide youth and young adults back to a healthy mental trajectory.
  • The podcast emphasizes the importance of understanding neurobiology, psychology, social psychology, and technology to support the youth population.
  • Helix Sleep sponsors the podcast, offering customized mattresses and pillows based on individual sleep needs, with a 20% discount and two free pillows for listeners.
  • AeroPress, a coffee maker, is highlighted for its ability to brew a perfect cup of coffee quickly, with a 20% discount for listeners.
  • Juve sponsors the podcast, providing medical-grade red light therapy devices that offer various health benefits, with up to $400 off select products for listeners.
  • The conversation between Dr. Haidt and Andrew Huberman delves into the impact of smartphones on mental health, highlighting the significant changes in technology from 2010 to 2015.
  • The discussion addresses the addictive nature of smartphone and social media use, likening it to an obsessive-compulsive loop that hinders focus and attention, leading to mental health challenges, especially in youth.

13:50

Rising Depression Rates Among Young Girls

  • Until 2010-2011, there was no significant increase in depression rates among girls, with around 12-15% qualifying as majorly depressed.
  • In 2012, there was a sudden and sharp increase in depression rates among girls, resembling a hockey stick graph.
  • Internationally, similar trends were observed with girls experiencing a significant rise in depression and anxiety rates.
  • Boys also showed an increase in depression and anxiety rates, starting around 2009-2010 and gradually rising.
  • The rise in depression rates for girls was not just self-reported but also evident in hospital admissions and emergency department visits.
  • Smartphone use among young girls in 2012 correlated with a decline in mental health, with various factors like screen time, content viewed, and social dynamics playing a role.
  • Girls in America now spend about 5 hours a day on social media, with platforms like TikTok and YouTube being major time sinks.
  • Overall, young people in America spend 7-10 hours a day on smartphones, not including school screen time.
  • The shift from a play-based childhood to a phone-based childhood since 2010-2012 is seen as detrimental to healthy human development.
  • The loss of community trust and the fear of child abduction led to the decline of a play-based childhood, with kids spending more time indoors on computers and the internet.

27:24

"AG1: Essential Nutrition for Health and Well-being"

  • The individual discussed was an icon known for counterculture and design interests, particularly in computers.
  • He introduced aesthetically pleasing fonts to computer design, attracting more girls and women to the field.
  • Social media played a significant role in balancing boys' and girls' interest in computers and the internet.
  • The arrival of phone-based childhood between 2010 and 2015 marked a significant shift in society.
  • The speaker has been taking AG1 for over 10 years, emphasizing its importance for nutrition and well-being.
  • AG1 provides essential vitamins, minerals, probiotics, and adaptogens to support physical and mental health.
  • AG1 is a foundational nutritional supplement meant to complement a healthy diet, enhancing overall well-being.
  • AG1 users report improvements in energy levels, digestion, sleep, and other vital aspects of health.
  • The decline in community and trust led to the removal of play-based childhood, impacting children's development.
  • Boys tend to gravitate towards activities like war, violence, and remote control, while girls focus more on social dynamics and relationships, showing distinct interests and behaviors.

40:51

Technology's impact on nature and relationships.

  • Our species evolved in nature with relationships with animals, seeking out and forming bonds with them.
  • The speaker expresses concern about how a technology-focused childhood can disconnect individuals from nature and animal relationships.
  • The discussion shifts to the speaker's fascination with Aquaria, particularly freshwater tanks and aquascaping.
  • Aquaria interest delves into understanding fish compatibility, plant density, and ecosystem maintenance to prevent system crashes.
  • The focus on Aquaria is more on the system dynamics rather than the relationships between the fish themselves.
  • The conversation transitions to exploring potential sex differences in interest towards Aquaria, pondering if it's more appealing to boys due to its complex systems.
  • The discussion moves towards the impact of pornography on sexual development during puberty, particularly concerning dopamine reinforcement.
  • Dopamine is highlighted as a motivator, creating a state of focus and craving, with rapid dopamine rises leading to addiction or extreme habit formation.
  • The ready availability of pornography triggers significant dopamine releases, leading to addiction and diminishing real-world learning experiences related to courtship and pursuit.
  • The use of pornography, especially in excess, can hinder the development of real-world relationship skills, leading to issues like erectile dysfunction and anxiety.

54:45

"Gen Z lacks social skills due to screens"

  • Gen Z employees in the corporate world lack initiative, confidence, and problem-solving skills, needing constant direction.
  • Boys and girls are exposed to hyper-stereotypical experiences through video games and social media, missing essential social interaction and conflict resolution skills.
  • Natural play, like sports or games, teaches crucial social skills such as rule-making, conflict resolution, and cooperation.
  • Online conflicts escalate quickly due to fear of public humiliation, leading to severe consequences like cyberbullying and suicide ideation.
  • Social media lacks the concept of "low stakes mistakes," where errors can lead to severe public shaming and long-term consequences.
  • Children need stable small groups for healthy social development, but social media exposes them to large, unpredictable audiences lacking empathy.
  • Childhood experiences have shifted drastically post-2010, with more time spent alone on screens rather than in human interactions.
  • Element electrolyte drink is recommended for proper hydration and electrolyte balance, crucial for cognitive and physical performance.
  • Dynamic subordination in male groups, like Navy SEAL teams, allows for skill-based leadership shifts and relentless cooperation.
  • Followership is essential in group dynamics, with trust in leaders crucial for effective teamwork and overcoming obstacles.

01:08:31

Boys and girls navigate online dynamics

  • Boys benefit from practicing both leadership and follower roles in group dynamics, enhancing employability in the future.
  • Boys and men often excel in different skill sets within groups, allowing for a harmonious meshing of abilities.
  • Social dynamics among boys and men involve understanding individual strengths and roles without attempting to be what they are not.
  • Online interactions, especially for girls, focus on perfectionism in image presentation, contrasting with boys' more casual approach.
  • Boys and girls experience similar insecurities online, with fear of missing out affecting both genders.
  • Online life for girls involves heightened social interactions, leading to increased anxiety, depression, and self-critique.
  • Boys' online interactions often revolve around humor and cleverness, with a focus on quick, one-hit jokes.
  • Boys have a higher suicide rate than girls, often using more violent means like guns, while girls tend to attempt suicide more frequently but with less lethal methods.
  • Social media use can impact brain development, with critical periods for learning and plasticity shaping neural circuits until around age 25.
  • Exposure to intense, high-potency stimuli like violent porn or processed food can wire neural circuits in a potentially harmful way, necessitating active unwiring or shifting for adaptation.

01:22:15

"Puberty's Impact on Identity and Development"

  • A Japanese study observed Japanese businessmen in California in the 70s, finding that children who arrived before age 9 or after age 15 remained distinctly Japanese, while those between 9 and 15 felt American upon returning to Japan.
  • Puberty is highlighted as a sensitive period for cultural learning and identity formation, crucial for understanding one's place in society.
  • The brain undergoes significant changes during puberty, with testosterone and estrogen playing key roles in organizing and activating brain areas, particularly the hypothalamus and forebrain.
  • Puberty marks a critical period for impulse control development, with the prefrontal cortex learning to suppress impulses driven by the hypothalamus, impacting behaviors and decision-making.
  • Hormonal effects during puberty, such as thickening of vocal cords, influence physical changes like voice deepening, affecting social interactions and self-concept.
  • Neuroplasticity during puberty is highly responsive to rewards, with dopamine reinforcement accelerating learning and behavior changes based on rewarding experiences.
  • Delaying exposure to smartphones until late puberty is recommended to avoid negative impacts on neuroplasticity and impulse control development, with flip phones suggested as an alternative for children.
  • Limiting access to the internet and social media for children, especially before high school, is crucial to prevent excessive dopamine-driven neuroplasticity and potential negative impacts on behavior and identity formation.
  • Collective action traps, where every child feels the need for a smartphone due to peer pressure, can be broken by implementing norms like delaying smartphone access and limiting internet exposure.
  • Implementing rules like no smartphones before high school and restricting internet access can help children navigate the challenges of neuroplasticity during puberty, fostering healthier development and identity formation.

01:35:53

Protecting Children: Social Media Age Restrictions Needed

  • Social media is deemed unsafe for children under 16 due to the pressure to gain prestige through likes and followers, leading to exposure to disturbing content.
  • A challenge called "running the gauntlet" involves watching 20 videos, including graphic violence, which young people may regret seeing.
  • Trauma from adverse events can permanently alter brain responses, affecting effectiveness in life, emphasizing the importance of avoiding such content.
  • Puberty is a sensitive period for identity and relationship skills development, necessitating caution in what children are exposed to between ages 9 to 15.
  • Children's exposure to extreme content on social media from random individuals selected for their behavior's extremity can be harmful during sensitive developmental periods.
  • Proposed laws to raise the age limit for social media to 16 or 18 aim to protect minors from the negative impact of social media, outweighing any potential benefits.
  • Implementing phone-free policies in schools is crucial to prevent distractions and reinforce learning, as excessive phone use can hinder attention and learning abilities.
  • Encouraging more independence, free play, and real-world responsibilities for children aims to restore a fulfilling childhood experience beyond virtual adventures.
  • Advocating for norm changes before laws, such as keeping smartphones away from children, can lead to more effective societal shifts in technology use.
  • Age verification and raising the minimum age for social media access to 16 are proposed as necessary legal measures to protect children from the negative effects of social media.

01:48:27

Promoting Playful Childhood: Strategies for Parents

  • An 8-year-old is reported missing, leading to police involvement and potential Child Protective Services intervention.
  • Eight states have taken steps to discourage helicopter parenting and promote safe play spaces for children.
  • Suggestions in a book include recommendations for governments, tech companies, schools, and parents to restore a play-based childhood.
  • Summer camps are recommended for detoxing children from phone addiction, with evidence showing positive effects.
  • Team sports and religion are highlighted as protective factors for children's mental health.
  • Playing musical instruments cooperatively in bands or choirs can enhance neuroplasticity in children.
  • Synchrony experiences, like singing in a choir or playing in a band, can provide self-transcendent moments and enhance social connections.
  • The importance of experiencing boredom to better understand personal preferences and feelings is discussed.
  • Excessive social media use among children is linked to loneliness and anxiety, driven by a need to keep up with peers and constant stimulation.
  • Strategies to regain control of attention, such as limiting notifications and social media access, are recommended, along with mindful walks for processing emotions.

02:01:57

"Unplugged Walks Transform Student Experiences in Park"

  • Encourages students to walk without distractions, leading to transformative experiences in Washington Square Park.
  • Highlights the beauty and impact of walking through the park without music or phone distractions.
  • Emphasizes the need for young people to reduce the quantity of information they consume.
  • Discusses the negative impact of social media platforms on children's development and well-being.
  • Criticizes the influence of social media companies on children's lives, comparing it to a harmful environment like a casino.
  • Points out the addictive nature of social media and the lack of regulation due to legal protections.
  • Stresses the importance of limiting children's exposure to harmful content on social media.
  • Compares the addictive nature of social media to television, highlighting the behaviorist aspect of social media.
  • Discusses the impact of parental behavior on children's use of technology and the importance of modeling positive habits.
  • Suggests promoting an adventurous childhood to counteract the negative effects of excessive social media use.

02:15:08

Parent-led movement for phone-free schools.

  • Collaborate with other parents to implement changes in phone policies for kids in elementary and middle school.
  • Introduce "Free Play Friday" where kids can engage in activities without restrictions every Friday.
  • Emphasize trust in kids to navigate and stay safe in their experiences, supported by statistics.
  • Merge concepts from previous books with the current book, "The Anxious Generation," to address concerns about children's well-being.
  • Express high optimism (10 out of 10) about the potential for significant changes in children's screen time habits.
  • Highlight the global shift towards addressing excessive screen time in family life.
  • Encourage collective action among parents to advocate for phone-free schools and promote exploration and independence for children.
  • Propose practical steps like discussing the book with friends, supporting related projects, and contacting legislators to drive change.
  • Acknowledge the importance of collective action in breaking the cycle of excessive screen time for children.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.