Obi-Wan Kenobi Ruined the Empire (But Andor Fixed It)
Master Samwise・15 minutes read
The portrayal of the Empire in "Andor" as a formidable force with meticulous planning and execution stands in stark contrast to the bumbling and illogical depiction in "Obi-Wan Kenobi," showcasing the importance of portraying adversaries as intelligent and capable, highlighted by the different strategic approaches and responses to threats in each series. The Star Destroyer that Vader diverted to chase after Obi-Wan inexplicably disappears, showcasing a lack of logic and continuity in the storytelling of the Obi-Wan Kenobi show, leading to disappointment for the creator who plans to make a comparison video but also gratitude for the growth of their channel.
Insights
- The portrayal of the Galactic Empire in "Andor" emphasizes meticulous planning and execution, contrasting sharply with the bumbling and illogical depiction in "Obi-Wan Kenobi," showcasing the importance of portraying adversaries as intelligent and capable within the Star Wars Universe.
- The contrast between the Empire's swift and strategic response to a heist in "Andor" and its incompetence and lack of preparedness in "Obi-Wan Kenobi" highlights the significance of operational systems and the impact they have on the overall effectiveness of villains within the narrative.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
How does "Andor" integrate the imperial system?
Seamlessly
What is the Empire's response to heists in "Andor"?
Swift
How are Stormtroopers portrayed in "Obi-Wan Kenobi"?
Inept
What does the disappearance of the Star Destroyer in "Obi-Wan Kenobi" showcase?
Lack of logic
Related videos
Summary
00:00
Empire's Competence Contrasted in Star Wars
- The Galactic Empire, led by a Sith Lord, aims to dominate systems, with a ruthless commander overseeing its forces and an Intelligence Division of dedicated officers.
- Villains in the Star Wars Universe are typically part of larger organizations, obligating creators to depict both heroes and villains within their operational systems.
- "Andor" exemplifies this concept well, seamlessly integrating the imperial system with the original trilogy's Empire while introducing new ideas and characters.
- In contrast, Obi-Wan Kenobi's Empire lacks competence and logic, focusing solely on main characters without considering the overall system.
- A comparison between scenes from "Andor" and "Obi-Wan Kenobi" reveals the former's strategic planning and the latter's lack thereof, showcasing the Empire's vulnerabilities.
- The Empire's failure to anticipate a heist in "Andor" highlights its lack of preparedness, allowing rebels to exploit a weakness due to a rare event.
- The Imperial Security Bureau's swift and heavy response to the heist underscores the Empire's commitment to projecting strength and quashing rebellious acts.
- In "Obi-Wan Kenobi," the Empire's incompetence is evident in security breaches and illogical decisions, such as leaving bases defenseless and lacking strategic planning.
- Stormtroopers in "Obi-Wan Kenobi" are portrayed as inept and ineffective, contrasting with their more menacing depiction in "Andor," where they are used sparingly but effectively.
- The portrayal of the Empire in "Andor" as a formidable force with meticulous planning and execution stands in stark contrast to the bumbling and illogical depiction in "Obi-Wan Kenobi," showcasing the importance of portraying adversaries as intelligent and capable.
14:17
Star Destroyer Disappears, Disappointing Creator, Grateful Growth
- The Star Destroyer that Vader diverted to chase after Obi-Wan inexplicably disappears, showcasing a lack of logic and continuity in the storytelling of the Obi-Wan Kenobi show, leading to disappointment for the creator who plans to make a comparison video but also gratitude for the growth of their channel.
