How Much More Star Wars Do We Need?
Drew Gooden・34 minutes read
The original Star Wars movies remain popular for their iconic elements, with new series relying heavily on familiar characters but requiring effort to keep viewers engaged. While the "Obi-Wan Kenobi" show was disappointing due to production issues and lack of depth, "Andor" is praised for its character development and realistic portrayal, advocating for fresh perspectives in future Star Wars content.
Insights
- Star Wars media heavily relies on iconic characters like Skywalker, Obi-Wan, Yoda, and Darth Vader, often centering new series around them, showcasing the role of nostalgia in attracting viewers and the need for continuous effort to sustain interest.
- The show "Andor" stands out for its exceptional execution, emphasizing consequences and meaningful actions in storytelling, with deep character development and smart writing, contrasting with other Star Wars series, ultimately highlighting the importance of fresh protagonists and new perspectives in future content.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
Why are the original Star Wars movies still popular?
The original Star Wars movies remain popular due to their thrilling content, exceptional performances, iconic music, and minimal incestuous themes, captivating audiences with a timeless story of good versus evil.
What are the main criticisms of the "Obi-Wan Kenobi" show?
The "Obi-Wan Kenobi" show faced criticism for its lackluster appearance, absence of a compelling narrative, and uninteresting characters, highlighting production issues like inconsistent writing, incompetent antagonists, and illogical plot developments.
How does "Ahsoka" differ from "Kenobi" in terms of character development?
"Ahsoka" surpasses "Kenobi" slightly but lacks stakes as main characters consistently survive dangerous situations unharmed, with a plot centered on retrieving a map from villains without fully exploring moral dilemmas or character dynamics.
What sets "Andor" apart from other Star Wars shows?
"Andor" distinguishes itself by portraying its main character realistically and with depth, emphasizing consequences and meaningful actions in storytelling, showcasing character development and smart writing while avoiding gratuitous cameos for a fresh perspective in the Star Wars universe.
What transformative event occurs in the Narkina 1 prison in "Andor"?
The Narkina 1 prison incident serves as a pivotal moment for Cassian, altering his perspective and motivating him to join the rebellion, highlighting themes of sacrifice, selflessness, and working towards a greater cause within the oppressive prison environment.
Related videos
Summary
00:00
Star Wars Series: Nostalgia, Characters, and Disappointments
- The original three Star Wars movies are still popular due to their exciting content, great performances, iconic soundtrack, and minimal incestuous themes.
- Star Wars media heavily relies on characters like Skywalker, Obi-Wan, Yoda, and Darth Vader, with new series often revolving around them.
- Nostalgia plays a significant role in attracting viewers to Star Wars content, but effort is necessary to maintain interest.
- The "Obi-Wan Kenobi" show was disappointing due to its cheap appearance, lack of a compelling story, and uninteresting characters.
- The show's production issues are evident in its inconsistent writing, incompetent antagonists, and illogical plot developments.
- The series seems to have been created around a recognizable character without a well-thought-out plot, relying on familiar formulas.
- "Ahsoka" is marginally better than "Kenobi" but suffers from a lack of stakes, as main characters consistently survive dangerous situations unscathed.
- The show's plot revolves around retrieving a map from the bad guys to prevent a greater threat, leading to a moral dilemma that is not fully explored.
- The potential for interesting character dynamics, such as master-apprentice relationships, is not fully realized in the series.
- Character development is lacking, with Sabine being the only one showing slight growth, albeit without a clear progression in her abilities.
11:59
Timing, Death Reactions, Character Context, Ahsoka Comparison, "Andor" Superior, SoFi Sponsorship, Realistic "Andor", Storytelling Consequences, "Andor" Character Development
- Events occur due to timing, not causality; reactions to death seem lacking in understanding.
- Question arises about a child's presence on a ship during war.
- Criticism of actors in a show is questioned, suggesting issues lie in character context.
- Ahsoka's portrayal as a wise Jedi in different shows is compared, highlighting discrepancies.
- Ahsoka's calm demeanor in her show is criticized for its lack of emotional depth.
- Comparison is drawn to a Star Wars show "Andor" being superior in execution and depth.
- Sponsorship by SoFi is mentioned, offering financial insights and a $10,000 giveaway.
- "Andor" subverts expectations by portraying its main character in a realistic, gritty manner.
- The importance of consequences and meaningful actions in storytelling is emphasized.
- Character development in "Andor" is praised for its depth and smart writing, contrasting with other shows.
23:00
"Andor" Season Finale: Prison Transformation and Rebellion
- The season finale of the show "Andor" on Aldhani was completed in three episodes, contrary to the expectation of a longer arc.
- The Narkina 1 prison sequence is highlighted as the best part of the show, showcasing the harsh conditions and control mechanisms within the prison.
- The prison utilizes electric floors to maintain order, with minimal guards and a system of prisoner supervision.
- Cassian, the main character, attempts to gather information about the prison from a fellow prisoner named Kino Loy.
- Rumors of prisoners being re-incarcerated and harsh treatment shed light on the oppressive nature of the prison.
- The prison incident serves as a transformative event for Cassian, altering his perspective and motivating him to join the rebellion.
- Sacrifice and working towards a greater goal are central themes, with characters like Luthen embodying the idea of selflessness for a cause.
- The rebellion members are shown to be sacrificing personal desires for the greater good, leading to a sense of unity and purpose.
- The show "Andor" is praised for its writing quality and avoidance of gratuitous cameos, focusing on new perspectives within the Star Wars universe.
- The importance of character evolution in storytelling is emphasized, with a call for fresh protagonists and alternate perspectives in future Star Wars content.
34:43
Reevaluating Necessity of New Star Wars Stories
- Questioning the need for more Star Wars stories due to potential repetition and repackaging of old ones.
