How one tweet can ruin your life | Jon Ronson
TED・2 minutes read
Social media platforms like Twitter initially provided a space for radical de-shaming but later evolved into a powerful tool for holding individuals and powerful entities accountable through online shaming, as seen in cases like Jonah Lehrer and Justine Sacco. The incidents highlighted the dark side of online shaming, with trolls, public condemnation, and financial gains at the expense of individuals' mental health, emphasizing the need to address unfair shaming and provide support in such situations.
Insights
- Online shaming on platforms like Twitter started as a way for people to reveal shameful secrets and find support, but it quickly evolved into a powerful tool for holding individuals and institutions accountable for their actions, showcasing the potential for both positive and negative impacts on individuals' lives and reputations.
- The shift in social media from empowering marginalized voices to creating a surveillance society has led to instances like the public shaming of Justine Sacco and Jonah Lehrer, highlighting the dangers of online mob mentality, the impact on mental health and well-being, and the importance of speaking out against unjust shaming practices to prevent further harm and trauma.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What is the impact of online shaming?
Online shaming can have severe consequences on individuals' mental health and well-being, as seen in cases like Justine Sacco and Jonah Lehrer. The power of social media to amplify shame and hold individuals accountable has led to public condemnation, job loss, and even financial gain for search engines. The incident with Sacco highlighted the dangers of online shaming, showcasing the dark side of the internet and the potential for trolls to escalate situations with vile comments. Overall, online shaming can lead to significant personal and professional repercussions, emphasizing the need to address the trauma caused by lack of support in such situations.
How did Twitter evolve as a platform?
Twitter initially served as a platform for radical de-shaming, where people shared shameful secrets and found solidarity. Over time, it transformed into a space where individuals could hold newspapers and powerful figures accountable for their actions through social media shaming. The evolution of Twitter showcases the shift from giving voice to the voiceless to creating a surveillance society, emphasizing the importance of speaking up against unfair shaming and abuses of power within society.
Who faced public shaming on Twitter?
Individuals like Jonah Lehrer and Justine Sacco faced public shaming on Twitter for their actions. Lehrer was caught plagiarizing and faking quotes, leading to harsh criticisms and insults displayed on live Twitter feeds during his public apology. Sacco, a PR woman, received severe backlash after posting a controversial joke about AIDS and race, resulting in her life being dismantled online as thousands called for her to be fired. These cases highlight the power of social media to shame individuals and the potential consequences of online actions.
What was the response to online shaming?
The response to online shaming varied, with some individuals facing severe backlash and others using the situation for profit. In the case of Justine Sacco, her employers joined in the public condemnation, adding to the excitement of her impending downfall. Trolls on Twitter escalated the situation with vile comments, showcasing the dark side of online shaming and the impact it can have on individuals' lives. Overall, the response to online shaming can lead to significant personal and professional repercussions, emphasizing the need to address the trauma caused by lack of support in such situations.
How did social media impact public perception?
Social media, as seen in the case of Justine Sacco, can significantly impact public perception and the hunt for people's shameful secrets. Sacco, daughter of a South African mining billionaire, was wrongly assumed to be wealthy until she clarified that her father sells carpets. This incident highlights the power of social media to shape public perception and the consequences of online actions. The impact of social media on public perception emphasizes the need to be mindful of the content shared online and the potential repercussions it may have on one's personal and professional life.
Related videos
TED
The price of shame | Monica Lewinsky | TED
TEDx Talks
Is Social Media Hurting Your Mental Health? | Bailey Parnell | TEDxRyersonU
Channel 4 News
Jaron Lanier interview on how social media ruins your life
The Royal Institution
Q&A: There is No Algorithm for Truth - with Tom Scott
Aperture
The Courage To Be Disliked
Summary
00:00
Twitter's Role in Public Shaming Incidents
- Twitter initially served as a platform for radical de-shaming, where people shared shameful secrets and found solidarity.
- The power of social media shaming was realized when individuals could hold newspapers and powerful figures accountable for their actions.
- A pop science writer, Jonah Lehrer, faced public shaming after being caught plagiarizing and faking quotes.
- During a public apology, Lehrer was confronted with live Twitter feeds displaying harsh criticisms and insults.
- Justine Sacco, a PR woman, faced severe backlash on Twitter after posting a controversial joke about AIDS and race.
- Sacco's life was dismantled online as thousands called for her to be fired and companies capitalized on the situation for profit.
- The online shaming of Sacco led to a significant increase in Google searches about her, benefiting the search engine financially.
- Trolls on Twitter escalated the situation with vile comments, showcasing the dark side of online shaming.
- Sacco's employers joined in the public condemnation, adding to the excitement of her impending downfall.
- The incident with Sacco highlighted the dangers of online shaming, leading to severe consequences for individuals' mental health and well-being.
12:50
"Social Media Shaming: Impact and Advocacy"
- Justine Sacco, daughter of a South African mining billionaire, was wrongly assumed to be wealthy until she clarified that her father sells carpets, highlighting the impact of social media on public perception and the hunt for people's shameful secrets.
- The speaker discusses the shift in social media from giving voice to the voiceless to creating a surveillance society, emphasizing the importance of speaking up against unfair shaming and the trauma caused by lack of support in such situations.
- Jon Ronson, author of a book on shamers, advocates for standing up against unfair shaming and shares his personal experience of facing insults and accusations online, illustrating the challenges of addressing abuses of power within society.
