You have no free will at all | Stanford professor Robert Sapolsky

Big Think・2 minutes read

The frontal cortex is shaped by environment and experience even 25 years after birth, as discussed by Dr. Robert Sapolsky, emphasizing the absence of free will in human behavior and the influence of biological and environmental factors on decisions. Understanding how environment and biology impact decisions can lead to a reevaluation of blame and punishment, with a focus on root causes and prevention rather than blame or praise.

Insights

  • The frontal cortex, which matures slowly until age 25, is heavily shaped by environmental factors and experiences rather than genetics, influencing societal norms and values.
  • Despite the absence of free will in human behavior, understanding the biological and environmental influences on decision-making can lead to a reevaluation of blame and punishment, emphasizing prevention and quarantine models for societal protection.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is the role of the frontal cortex in decision-making?

    The frontal cortex is the least genetically influenced part of the brain, shaped by environment and experience even 25 years after birth. It plays a crucial role in self-control, influencing behaviors and decision-making processes. Factors like stress, fear, and past experiences can impact the frontal cortex, leading to faster, less thoughtful decisions. Understanding the frontal cortex's function can help individuals make intentional changes in behavior and improve decision-making skills.

  • How do cultural differences impact brain development?

    Cultural differences in child-rearing practices influence brain development and societal values. Collectivist cultures prioritize cooperation, while individualist cultures emphasize independence. Ancestors' environments also impact cultural traits, such as monotheism in desert dwellers and polytheism in rainforest dwellers. Child-rearing practices aim to instill cultural values in the next generation's brains, shaping behavior and decision-making processes.

  • What is the significance of emergent properties in complex systems?

    Emergent properties, like consciousness and free will, cannot be solely attributed to complex systems without affecting their basic components. Emergence involves simple rules and interactions leading to complex outcomes, such as ants building colonies. Properties like conformity only arise in interactions with others, not in isolation. Understanding emergent properties in complex systems can provide insights into decision-making processes and societal behaviors.

  • How can individuals improve decision-making skills?

    To enhance decision-making skills, individuals should reflect on past experiences and circumstances, ensuring thoughtful consideration before making choices. Education and societal conditioning play a crucial role in training individuals to stop and reflect before decisions. Ensuring sufficient energy levels by eating before important actions can also improve cognitive function and lead to more thoughtful decisions in critical moments.

  • What factors influence judges' parole decisions?

    Judges' parole decisions are influenced by various factors, including the time since their last meal. Low blood glucose levels can affect brain function, particularly the frontal cortex, leading to faster, less thoughtful decisions. Parole board judges are more likely to grant parole right after a meal, with a 60% chance, compared to later when the chance drops to 0%. Understanding how physiological factors impact decision-making can shed light on the complexities of human behavior and judgment.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Free Will: Biology vs. Environment"

  • The frontal cortex is the least genetically influenced part of the brain, sculpted by environment and experience even 25 years after birth.
  • Dr. Robert Sapolsky, a renowned professor at Stanford University, discusses free will and its implications for humanity on "Big Think."
  • Sapolsky, a MacArthur Genius Fellow, draws from his expertise in biology and neurology, with bestselling books like "Why Zebras Don't Get Ulcers" and "Determined."
  • Sapolsky wrote "Determined" as a follow-up to "Behave," aiming to emphasize the absence of free will in human behavior.
  • Free will is often misunderstood as conscious choice, overlooking the biological and environmental factors shaping intentions.
  • Language used to describe human actions often implies free will, but causality and choice are distinct concepts.
  • Distributed causality refers to the multitude of factors influencing human behavior, from recent stimuli to ancestral culture.
  • Phineas Gage's case exemplifies concentrated causality, where a brain injury drastically altered his behavior, highlighting the role of the frontal cortex in self-control.
  • Various systems, like hormonal levels and past trauma, can influence split-second decisions, such as identifying a threat or making a snap judgment.
  • Factors like stress, fear, and past experiences can impact decision-making in critical moments, from hormone levels to childhood trauma.

14:46

"Meal timing impacts parole decisions significantly"

  • Judges' parole decisions are influenced by the time since their last meal, with a significant impact on granting parole.
  • Parole board judges are more likely to grant parole right after a meal, with a 60% chance, compared to later when the chance drops to 0%.
  • Low blood glucose levels affect brain function, particularly the frontal cortex, leading to faster, less thoughtful decisions.
  • To improve decision-making, individuals should ensure they have sufficient energy by eating before important actions.
  • Reflecting on past experiences and circumstances can aid in making more thoughtful decisions.
  • Education and societal conditioning play a crucial role in training individuals to stop and reflect before making decisions.
  • Change in behavior is influenced by circumstances and experiences, shaping individuals' decision-making processes.
  • Understanding the mechanisms behind decision-making can help individuals make intentional changes in behavior.
  • The emergence of complex systems, like AI, may lead to the misconception that free will is an emergent property.
  • Emergent properties, like consciousness and free will, cannot be solely attributed to complex systems without affecting their basic components.

29:25

Emergence, Brain Development, and Cultural Values

  • Emergence involves simple rules and interactions leading to complex outcomes, such as ants building colonies.
  • Emergent properties, like conformity, only arise in interactions with others, not in isolation.
  • The frontal cortex's delayed maturation until age 25 allows for learning societal norms and values.
  • The frontal cortex evolves to be less genetically determined, influenced more by environment and experience.
  • Cultural differences in child-rearing impact brain development and societal values.
  • Collectivist cultures prioritize cooperation, while individualist cultures emphasize independence.
  • Ancestors' environments influence cultural traits, like monotheism in desert dwellers and polytheism in rainforest dwellers.
  • Child-rearing practices aim to instill cultural values in the next generation's brains.
  • Cultural differences in behavior, like walking around or moving chairs in Starbucks, reflect upbringing.
  • Society's evolutionary role is to pass on cultural values and ensure survival into the next generation.

44:27

Ancestral influences shape brain, decisions, and society.

  • Beliefs, loves, hates, and values are passed down from ancestors and shape brain construction.
  • Despite the absence of free will, individuals can still make decisions and have some control over their actions.
  • Understanding how one's environment and biology influence decisions can lead to a reevaluation of blame and punishment.
  • In cases of harmful behavior, individuals should be quarantined for society's protection, focusing on root causes and prevention.
  • Quarantine models, like those used for drowsy airline pilots, can be applied to dangerous individuals without invoking blame.
  • Protecting society from incompetence or danger requires skill, motivation, and a focus on prevention rather than blame or praise.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.