Witcher 3 - The Choices GERALT Would Make [Hearts of Stone]

Neon Knight・2 minutes read

Geralt of Rivia faces moral dilemmas in Hearts of Stone as he navigates complex choices that impact the fates of others, especially dealing with the manipulative Gaunter O'Dimm and the tragic story of Olgierd von Everec. The storyline showcases the depth of character writing, highlighting themes of deception, manipulation, sacrifice, and the consequences of choices in a morally grey world.

Insights

Geralt's choices in Hearts of Stone involve complex moral dilemmas that impact the fates of others, highlighting the depth of decision-making in the game.
Gaunter O'Dimm emerges as a malevolent entity, orchestrating events to manipulate Geralt and others, showcasing a sinister and deceptive nature that drives the story's darker themes.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

Who is Geralt of Rivia?
A skilled character with rich history and traits.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Geralt faces moral dilemmas in Hearts of Stone.

Geralt of Rivia is a well-established character with a rich history and set personality traits.
The Witcher games allow players to make choices for Geralt, often involving moral dilemmas.
Hearts of Stone presents life or death scenarios where Geralt's decisions impact others' fates.
Gaunter O'Dimm plays a significant role in orchestrating events in Hearts of Stone.
Geralt's debt to Gaunter is part of a larger plan involving Olgierd von Everec's soul.
Gaunter manipulates events to lead Geralt to Olgierd, setting up complex choices for Geralt.
Geralt's tasks for Olgierd reveal layers of deception and manipulation surrounding the von Everec family.
Geralt's final task involves confronting the consequences of Olgierd's deal with Gaunter.
Geralt must choose the fate of Iris von Everec, based on her memories and the truth about Olgierd.
Understanding the true nature of Olgierd's past is crucial in making informed decisions in Hearts of Stone.

11:47

Complex Villain Olgierd's Tragic Pact with Gaunter

Olgierd is portrayed as more complex than a simple villain, with a love for art and reading, and a code of conduct during raids.
Geralt witnesses Olgierd's adherence to his code when he saves a man from execution for breaking it.
Olgierd's group, the Wild Ones, is not his original crew, but a more reckless bunch he picked up after leaving Iris.
Olgierd's retention of his raiding code despite losing his heart showcases the depth of character writing in Hearts of Stone.
Olgierd's gradual loss of humanity is highlighted by his actions towards Iris and her father, leading to a tragic outcome.
Iris's immortality, a result of Olgierd's wish, comes with a significant drawback, trapping her in a world of torment.
Geralt's choice to help Iris move on from her purgatory showcases a rare act of kindness in the story.
Olgierd's desperate attempts to end his pact with Gaunter reveal his true intentions and the sacrifices he was willing to make.
Gaunter is revealed as a malevolent entity who thrives on causing suffering and playing with his victims' lives.
Gaunter's manipulative nature is exposed through his interactions with Geralt, showcasing his deceptive and self-serving behavior.

25:07

Gaunter's Sinister Deception in Hearts of Stone

Gaunter revels in the slow reveal of his true nature to Geralt in Hearts of Stone, showcasing his sinister side gradually.
Gaunter's enjoyment of torment is evident in his actions, from procuring von Everec blood to torturing Vlodimir's ghost.
The evil nature of Gaunter is highlighted through his murder of an old man with a wooden spoon, showcasing his twisted sense of fun.
Gaunter's manipulation of words and actions to deceive others is evident in his treatment of the professor, where he psychologically tortures him.
Gaunter's cruelty extends to sending vivid visions of a non-existent daughter to the professor, leading to psychological torment.
Gaunter's deceptive nature is further emphasized through his actions in Blood & Wine, where he curses Marlene to a monstrous existence.
The rapid downfall of Olgierd's life is detailed, from his love for Iris to the events leading to her forced marriage to a prince.
The ruthless actions of Horst Borsodi and Iris's parents in seizing Olgierd's possessions and promising Iris to the prince are highlighted.
The choice between siding with Horst or Ewald during the heist in Hearts of Stone is discussed, emphasizing the risks and consequences.
Olgierd's curses, both on the prince and the one cast on him by Gaunter, are detailed, showcasing the power of words and emotions in the Witcher universe.

36:48

"Deal with the Devil: Geralt's Dilemma"

Olgierd met Gaunter O'Dimm through a wandering witch who mentioned Gaunter's ability to grant any wish.
After losing everything, Olgierd encountered the witch who suggested Gaunter could solve his problems.
Olgierd, after losing his family heirlooms, called upon Gaunter for help, leading to a deal that restored his fortune at the cost of his brother's life.
To defeat Gaunter and save Olgierd's soul, Geralt must challenge him to a duel of wits, risking his own soul in the process.
Geralt arrives first at the meeting point with Olgierd, having learned more about Olgierd's past and complexities.
Gaunter tricks Geralt into helping collect Olgierd's soul, leading to a confrontation where Geralt must decide whether to intervene.
In the cannibal quest, Geralt investigates the disappearance of a halfling apprentice, leading him to an elderly couple with suspicious behavior.
The elderly couple's story about the halfling's death by wolves is contradicted by evidence found in their meat cellar, including human remains.
Geralt must choose between killing the elderly couple or making them promise to stop eating human flesh, both imperfect outcomes.
Geralt's decision in the cannibal quest reflects his moral code and the evidence he uncovers, potentially putting future innocents at risk.

48:59

"Geralt Confronts Cannibal Couple and Witcher"

Geralt encounters a couple who are revealed to be serial killer cannibals during a battle.
By being patient and not immediately killing them, Geralt learns more about their actions.
The monsters are eventually justifiably put down after revealing their atrocities.
If Geralt takes the couple's cabin key, he can enter their well-stocked home.
Gaetan, another Witcher, is involved in a contract where a village massacre occurred.
Geralt discovers Gaetan's involvement in the massacre and confronts him.
Gaetan explains that he was betrayed by the villagers and retaliated by killing innocents.
Geralt faces a moral dilemma in deciding Gaetan's fate, drawing parallels to past encounters with violent Witchers.
The sparing Gaetan option is criticized for its handling and lack of alignment with Geralt's character.

Try it yourself — It’s free.