Why Star Wars is Falling Apart | Video Essay
Movie Overload・30 minutes read
The author is disappointed with the current state of Star Wars, finding recent content lacking despite high hopes for Disney's involvement. Criticisms include the nostalgia-driven plots of recent movies, a decline in quality, and concerns about the franchise's future direction.
Insights
- The author expresses disappointment with the current state of Star Wars, feeling detached from the brand due to a decline in quality content and a lack of coherent planning, especially evident in "The Rise of Skywalker."
- Concerns about the uncertain future of Star Wars are raised, with a call for potential leadership changes, such as Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau taking over, to address the franchise's stagnation and explore new timelines like the Old Republic for revitalization.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are the author's feelings towards the current state of Star Wars?
The author expresses disappointment and detachment from the current Star Wars content, finding it lacking compared to previous iterations.
How did Disney's acquisition of Lucasfilm impact the Star Wars franchise?
Disney's acquisition led to a resurgence in Star Wars content, with new movies and shows being produced under their ownership.
What was the author's reaction to Disney's handling of Star Wars characters like Kylo Ren and Rey?
The author initially had high hopes for Disney's Star Wars, especially with the introduction of characters like Kylo Ren and Rey, finding them intriguing and engaging.
What criticisms does the author have towards the show "The Book of Boba Fett"?
The author criticizes "The Book of Boba Fett" for trying too hard to emulate "The Mandalorian" and not allowing Boba Fett to shine in his own right, leading to a lackluster portrayal of the character.
Who are suggested as potential replacements for Kathleen Kennedy in overseeing Star Wars?
Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau are suggested as potential replacements for Kathleen Kennedy to take over Star Wars, similar to Kevin Feige's role in Marvel, to address the current stagnation in the franchise.
Related videos
Summary
00:00
Disillusionment with Star Wars under Disney
- The author expresses disappointment with the current state of Star Wars, feeling increasingly detached from the brand.
- Despite liking the original trilogy and prequels, the author finds the current Star Wars content lacking.
- Disney's acquisition of Lucasfilm in 2012 marked a significant shift for the franchise, leading to a resurgence in Star Wars content.
- The author initially had high hopes for Disney's Star Wars, especially with the success of "Star Wars Rebels" and "The Force Awakens."
- "The Force Awakens" was praised for reintroducing familiar elements with new characters, reinvigorating the franchise.
- The sequel trilogy introduced characters like Kylo Ren, Rey, and Finn, with Kylo Ren standing out as a favorite for the author.
- "Rogue One" was well-received, but "The Last Jedi" marked a turning point where the author felt Star Wars began to decline.
- "The Rise of Skywalker" is heavily criticized by the author for its nostalgia-driven plot and lack of a coherent plan for the trilogy.
- The author highlights the impact of these sequels on the Star Wars fandom, leading to division and toxicity.
- Despite some successes like "The Mandalorian," the author feels Star Wars is in a state of confusion, unable to decide between quality content and disappointing releases.
14:53
Star Wars shows face criticism and uncertainty.
- The show "The Book of Boba Fett" is criticized for trying too hard to emulate "The Mandalorian" and not allowing Boba Fett to shine in his own right.
- While some episodes without Boba Fett are praised, the overall show is deemed lacking, especially when compared to "The Mandalorian."
- Boba Fett's character development in the show is criticized for not aligning with his established persona from "The Mandalorian."
- The handling of legacy characters like Boba Fett in Disney's Star Wars is highlighted as a major issue, with characters becoming caricatures of themselves.
- The reliance on cameos in shows like "The Book of Boba Fett" is criticized for detracting from the overall quality of the storytelling.
- The show "Andor" is praised for its well-written story and character development but criticized for being perceived as boring due to the lack of cameos.
- Despite positive reviews from those who have watched it, "Andor" is not performing well, potentially impacting the future of similar shows.
- "Obi-Wan Kenobi" is criticized for not fully utilizing its potential, with production quality concerns and distracting elements like unnecessary characters.
- The show's focus on a new character, Riva, is criticized for taking away from the main characters and the core story.
- The future of Star Wars content is uncertain, with concerns raised about the direction of the franchise and the lack of clarity in upcoming projects.
28:53
"Star Wars' Future: Uncertain but Hopeful"
- Kathleen Kennedy, despite being blamed for some of Star Wars' issues, has been involved in creating successful films in the franchise's history, although she has also overseen failures. Suggestions have been made for Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau to take over Star Wars, akin to Kevin Feige's role in Marvel, as a potential solution to the current stagnation in the franchise.
- The future of Star Wars appears uncertain, with criticisms of recent projects and a lack of clear direction. Calls for exploring new timelines, such as the Old Republic, are made to revitalize the franchise, which is currently facing challenges in regaining its former glory after the divisive reception of the sequel trilogy.
