Why Is Desalination So Difficult?

Practical Engineering・2 minutes read

The Carlsbad Desalination Plant in San Diego produces 10% of the area's water supply, using modern technology to extract water from the ocean and remove salt through reverse osmosis efficiently. Despite the energy-intensive process, advancements in desalination technology indicate a growing role in providing freshwater, especially in regions facing water scarcity.

Insights

  • The Carlsbad Desalination Plant in San Diego provides 10% of the area's water supply by directly extracting ocean water for treatment, showcasing a crucial alternative to traditional water sources.
  • Desalination, particularly through reverse osmosis, aims to remove over 98% of salt from seawater, addressing the World Health Organization's standards for acceptable water quality, but faces challenges like energy consumption, brine disposal, and post-treatment requirements for safe consumption, highlighting the complexity and potential of this technology in addressing water scarcity worldwide.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How does desalination work?

    Desalination involves removing salt from seawater to make it drinkable. Methods like distillation and reverse osmosis are commonly used.

  • What are the environmental impacts of desalination?

    Desalination plants produce a concentrated brine stream that is challenging to dispose of due to its environmental impact. Methods like diffusers or injection into the ground are used for disposal.

  • Why is desalination important?

    Desalination is crucial in areas with severe water scarcity, providing a viable solution to meet freshwater needs. It plays a significant role in regions like the Middle East and parts of the United States.

  • What are the challenges of desalination?

    Desalination faces challenges such as high energy demands, complex processes, and the need for pretreatment to remove contaminants. Disposal of brine is also a significant challenge.

  • How does reverse osmosis differ from distillation in desalination?

    Reverse osmosis uses membranes to separate salt from water under pressure, while distillation involves heating seawater to vaporize and then condense it. Reverse osmosis is more energy-efficient.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Desalination: Extracting Fresh Water from the Ocean"

  • The Carlsbad Desalination Plant outside San Diego produces around 50 million gallons or 23,000 cubic meters of fresh water daily, accounting for 10% of the area's water supply.
  • Unlike traditional treatment plants, the Carlsbad plant directly extracts water from the ocean for desalination.
  • Globally, there are over 18,000 desalination plants, yet they only meet less than 1% of the world's water needs, consuming a quarter of the water industry's energy.
  • Seawater typically contains around 35 grams of dissolved salt per liter, equivalent to 35 parts per thousand or 35 permille.
  • Desalination aims to remove over 98% of salt from seawater, with the World Health Organization suggesting that water with more than 1 part per thousand dissolved solids is usually unacceptable for consumption.
  • Distillation, the oldest desalination method, involves heating seawater to vaporize and then condense it, requiring significant energy and time.
  • Reverse osmosis, a more efficient desalination method, uses membranes to separate salt from water under high pressure, with modern plants employing advanced technology to enhance efficiency.
  • Reverse osmosis systems require significant energy, with a basic setup using around 1200 watts to produce a liter of drinkable water in five minutes.
  • Despite being less efficient on a small scale, modern reverse osmosis plants utilize high-quality membranes and energy recovery systems to reduce energy consumption significantly.
  • Desalination plants must undergo pretreatment to remove contaminants like dirt and organic matter before the salt separation process, adding to the overall energy and cost requirements.

12:50

Challenges and Solutions in Desalination Technology

  • RO or permeate water cannot be sent directly to customers as it is too clean and needs post-treatment to add minerals for taste preference.
  • Desalination plants recover about half of intake flow, resulting in a brine stream twice as concentrated as seawater, which is challenging to dispose of due to environmental impacts.
  • Brine disposal methods include using diffusers, blending with other water streams, or injecting into the ground to dilute it before release.
  • Desalination is compared to nuclear power in terms of complexity and costs, with challenges like high energy demands and coupling water costs with electricity costs.
  • Desalination is a viable solution in areas with severe water scarcity, with the biggest plants located in Middle Eastern countries and regions with variable climates like California, Texas, and Florida.
  • Private sector partnerships in desalination projects help offload financing and operational risks, making the process more cost-effective and stable, with advancements in technology indicating a potential increase in desalination's role in freshwater supply.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.