Which voting system is the best? - Alex Gendler
TED-Ed・2 minutes read
The colonists on Mars held a vote to decide the location of a new space port, with West Base winning despite being far from other bases, sparking concerns about fairness. Alternative voting methods like instant runoff voting and the Condorcet method were considered, revealing challenges in creating a truly fair system due to conflicting criteria and the risk of strategic voting.
Insights
- Plurality voting favored West Base for the new space port, despite its distance from other bases, raising concerns about fairness and representation in decision-making processes.
- Exploring alternative methods like instant runoff voting and the Condorcet method revealed the complexity of achieving fairness in voting systems due to conflicting priorities and the risk of strategic manipulation, emphasizing the need for careful consideration in designing democratic processes.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
How many colonists live on each base on Mars?
42 colonists live on West Base, 26 on North Base, 15 on South Base, and 17 on East Base on Mars.
What voting method resulted in West Base winning for the new space port location?
Plurality voting resulted in West Base winning for the new space port location.
What are some alternative voting methods explored in the decision-making process?
Alternative voting methods like instant runoff voting and the Condorcet method were explored.
What challenges were highlighted in achieving a truly fair voting system?
Challenges in achieving a truly fair voting system were due to conflicting criteria and potential for strategic voting.
Why were questions raised about the fairness of the voting outcome?
Questions about the fairness of the voting outcome arose due to West Base winning easily despite being far from other bases.
Related videos
ambiguousamphibian
Can I Terraform Mars in 200 Days? | Surviving Mars
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
Building a Marsbase is a Horrible Idea: Let’s do it!
ambiguousamphibian
Can I Terraform Mars in 100 Days? | Surviving Mars
Alt Shift X
All Tomorrows: the future of humanity?
Fraser Cain
How A Realistic Mars Mission Will Play Out
Summary
00:00
"Choosing a Space Port on Mars"
- 42 colonists live on West Base, 26 on North Base, 15 on South Base, and 17 on East Base on Mars, and a vote is held to determine the location of a new space port based on proximity to their base.
- Plurality voting, where each person casts a single ballot, results in West Base winning easily, despite being far from other bases, leading to questions about fairness.
- Alternative voting methods like instant runoff voting and the Condorcet method are explored, highlighting challenges in achieving a truly fair voting system due to conflicting criteria and the potential for strategic voting.
