LoginGet started

Tucker Carlson Interviews Putin [Live Reaction]

Meet Kevin・120 minutes read

Putin discussed Russia's historical claims to parts of Western Ukraine, delving into the region's complex history and connections to Russia, while highlighting the need for peace and cooperation through negotiation with the US and NATO. Despite tensions and accusations, Putin emphasizes the importance of building relationships and addressing historical grievances, advocating for a peaceful resolution without military actions in Ukraine.

Insights

  • Russia has historical claims to parts of Western Ukraine dating back to the 8th century, shaping the ongoing conflict.
  • The collapse of the Soviet Union and subsequent NATO expansion eastward strained relations with Russia.
  • Putin emphasizes the need to eradicate neo-Nazi movements in Ukraine and implement the Minsk agreements for peace.
  • Putin criticizes NATO and the US for focusing on Ukraine instead of domestic issues, advocating for cooperation with China and negotiations with Ukraine to resolve conflicts.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What historical events shaped Russia's claim to parts of Ukraine?

    The historical claim to parts of Western Ukraine by Russia dates back to the 8th century, with significant events such as the baptism of Russia in 988 and the Mongol invasion in 1223 leading to the subordination of Orthodox priests to the pope in Russian lands. Truces and agreements with Poland in 1654 and the inclusion of Russian lands into the Moscow Kingdom further solidified Russia's historical ties to Ukraine. Despite these historical connections, the establishment of Soviet Ukraine as an autonomous entity in 1922 under Stalin's leadership and the transfer of lands to the Soviet Republic of Ukraine, including the Black Sea region, shaped Ukraine as an artificial state under Soviet influence.

  • How did the collapse of the Soviet Union impact Russia's relations with the West?

    The collapse of the Soviet Union was initiated by Russian leadership, expecting cooperation with the West based on shared language, culture, and history. However, NATO's expansion eastward strained relations, leading to tensions between Russia and the US. Despite attempts by Putin to restore relations post-Yugoslav conflict, including proposing a joint missile defense system with the US and Europe, the West's negative response and NATO's expansion further exacerbated the strained relations. This historical context sheds light on the complexities of Russia's relationship with the West post-Soviet Union collapse.

  • What concerns did Putin raise regarding US involvement in Ukraine?

    Putin raised concerns about the United States' support for separatism and terrorism in the north Caucasus, providing various forms of support to terrorist groups in the region. The CIA's admission to supporting opposition groups in Russia was deemed ridiculous by Putin, highlighting the tensions between the US and Russia. Additionally, Putin proposed a peaceful resolution to the conflict in Ukraine, emphasizing the need to cease weapon supplies for peace to prevail. These concerns and proposals reflect Putin's stance on US involvement in Ukraine and the broader geopolitical implications of the conflict.

  • How did the conflict in Ukraine impact Russia's relations with NATO?

    The conflict in Ukraine, fueled by US pressure on Ukraine to align with the EU and NATO's expansion eastward, strained relations between Russia and NATO. The refusal of Ukraine's leadership to implement the Minsk agreements further escalated tensions, with Putin expressing readiness to implement the agreements for conflict resolution. Despite efforts to negotiate and resolve the conflict peacefully, challenges arose from US influence and NATO activities in the region, highlighting the complexities of Russia's relations with NATO in the context of the Ukrainian conflict.

  • What were the key points of discussion regarding Russia's global position and relations with China?

    The discussion touched on Russia's evolving global position, with experts noting changes in the country's standing despite facing numerous sanctions. Cooperation with China was emphasized as crucial, with bilateral trade exceeding $230 billion and covering various sectors like high-tech, energy, and scientific research. The development of BRICS countries, including Russia, was highlighted, showcasing their rapid growth and increasing share of the world economy. These points underscore the importance of Russia's relations with China and its position in the global economic landscape.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Putin's Interview: Russia's Historical Claims in Ukraine

  • Tucker Carlson interviewed Vladimir Putin about the war in Ukraine on February 6th, 2024, at the Kremlin.
  • Putin discussed Russia's historical claim to parts of Western Ukraine dating back to the 8th century.
  • The interview delved into the history of Russia's centralized statehood, including the baptism of Russia in 988.
  • The Mongol invasion in 1223 led to the subordination of Orthodox priests to the pope in Russian lands.
  • In 1654, a truce was concluded with Poland, leading to the inclusion of Russian lands into the Moscow Kingdom.
  • The Austrian general staff promoted Ukrainian independence to weaken potential enemies before World War I.
  • After the Bolshevik Revolution in 1917, the Civil War began, including hostilities with Poland in 1921.
  • Poland collaborated with Hitler before World War II, leading to the partitioning of Czechoslovakia.
  • The USSR regained historical lands, including parts of Ukraine, after World War II.
  • The USSR established Soviet Ukraine as an autonomous entity in 1922 under Stalin's leadership.

21:07

Ukraine's Complex History and Russia's Relations

  • Lands were transferred to the newly established Soviet Republic of Ukraine, including the Black Sea region, despite historical connections to Russia and no prior association with Ukraine.
  • Lenin's decision to grant autonomy to Bolsheviks led to the creation of Soviet Ukraine, part of the USSR, with a policy of promoting national languages and cultures.
  • Ukraine received lands from Poland, Hungary, and Romania after World War I, shaping it as an artificial state under Stalin's influence.
  • Hungarians in Ukraine desired to reclaim historical lands, reflecting redrawn borders and historical grievances across nations.
  • The collapse of the Soviet Union was initiated by Russian leadership, expecting cooperation with the West based on shared language, culture, and history.
  • Russia believed the collapse of the Soviet Union would lead to cooperation with the West, but NATO's expansion eastward strained relations.
  • Russia supported Serbia during the Yugoslav conflict, leading to tensions with the US and accusations of violating international law.
  • Putin sought to restore relations with the US post-Yugoslav conflict, even considering joining NATO, but faced rebuffs and hostility from the West.
  • The West's negative response to Russia's attempts at cooperation post-Cold War led to strained relations and lack of common ground.
  • Despite bitterness over past rejections, Putin emphasizes the need to build relations in different ways and work towards common ground, questioning the motives behind the West's hostility.

39:32

US Support for Terrorism in Caucasus: Putin's Concerns

  • The United States supports separatism and terrorism in the north Caucasus despite objections.
  • Various forms of support, including political, informational, financial, and military, are provided to terrorist groups in the Caucasus by the United States and its allies.
  • Putin raised concerns with a U.S. president about this support, providing proof of the assistance.
  • The CIA admitted to supporting opposition groups in Russia, which Putin found ridiculous.
  • Putin proposed a joint missile defense system with the U.S. and Europe, but the U.S. declined, leading to Russia developing hypersonic strike systems.
  • NATO's expansion eastward, contrary to promises made, led to tensions with Russia, especially regarding Ukraine's potential membership.
  • The U.S. pressured Ukraine to align with the EU, leading to a coup and conflict in Crimea and Donbas.
  • European guarantors of an agreement between Yanukovich and the opposition failed to uphold their commitments, leading to the coup in Ukraine.
  • The U.S. involvement in the coup in Ukraine, costing billions, was deemed a political mistake by Putin.
  • Putin questions the necessity of military actions and victims in achieving political goals, suggesting a legal and peaceful approach could have been taken.

58:33

Crimea's involvement and tensions over Minsk.

  • Crimea's involvement was triggered by the developments on Maidan and concerns over NATO expansion.
  • The refusal of Ukraine's leadership to implement the Minsk agreements led to tensions.
  • Germany and France admitted signing the Minsk agreements without intending to implement them.
  • Putin expressed readiness to implement the Minsk agreements.
  • The issue of denazification in Ukraine was a significant concern for Putin.
  • Ukraine's identity was built on false heroes collaborating with Hitler, leading to nationalist sentiments.
  • Putin emphasized the need to eradicate neo-Nazi movements in Ukraine.
  • Negotiations in Istanbul aimed to prohibit neo-Nazism in Ukraine.
  • Ukraine's ban on negotiating with Russia hindered conflict resolution efforts.
  • Putin highlighted the need to cease weapon supplies to Ukraine for peace to prevail.

01:18:52

Russia's Territorial Aims in Ukraine and Global Risks

  • The speaker discusses Russia's territorial aims in Ukraine and the potential risks of global war.
  • Mention of deterrence methods and the fear of Russia using tactical nuclear weapons.
  • The goal of weakening Russia in the Ukrainian conflict is highlighted.
  • Reference to Chuck Schumer's statement on funding the Ukrainian effort to avoid US citizens fighting there.
  • The discussion of a proxy war and the involvement of mercenaries from various countries.
  • The suggestion to negotiate with Russia rather than engage in conflict.
  • Speculation on the industrial terrorism incident involving the Nord Stream pipelines.
  • The challenge of presenting evidence in a propaganda war against the US.
  • Criticism of German leadership's silence on the pipeline incident and their actions in relation to Russia.
  • The speaker's view on the split in the world and the importance of shared security for stability.

01:37:56

"Cooperation with China and Russia in trade"

  • Cooperation with China is crucial, with a goal set to reach $200 billion in mutual trade, already exceeding this level to $230 billion.
  • Bilateral trade with China is well-balanced, covering high-tech, energy, and scientific research and development sectors.
  • The BRICS countries, including Russia, are developing rapidly, with their share of the world economy surpassing that of the G7 nations.
  • Russia remains in the United Nations due to its status as a P5 member, granting veto power within the UN Security Council.
  • The US's approach to global changes involves force, sanctions, and pressure, which are deemed counterproductive.
  • Personal relationships with American leaders, like Bush and Trump, are highlighted, emphasizing the importance of elite mindset over individual personalities.
  • China's economy has surpassed the US in purchasing power parity, with India, Japan, and Russia following in the rankings.
  • Despite facing numerous sanctions, Russia has become Europe's top economy, prompting a need for a change in approach from the ruling elites.
  • The US's evolving position in the world is acknowledged, with experts noting gradual changes in the country's global standing.
  • Efforts to resolve conflicts in Ukraine through peaceful means have been repeatedly proposed, with challenges arising from US influence and NATO activities in the region.

01:56:58

"Putin negotiates weapons, religion, and journalism"

  • Putin mentioned negotiating if the US stops supplying weapons, suggesting a resolution in a few weeks.
  • Refusal to negotiate was denied, with mention of British persuasion leading to continued hostilities.
  • Russia's Orthodox roots were highlighted, emphasizing loyalty to other religions within the country.
  • The discussion shifted to Christianity's nonviolent nature and its compatibility with leadership roles.
  • Putin expressed a pragmatic view of Western culture compared to Russia's focus on eternal values.
  • The conversation touched on the supernatural and the development of the world community.
  • The potential dangers of genetic research and AI were discussed, with a focus on regulation.
  • The possibility of releasing a US journalist held in Russia was mentioned, pending reciprocal steps.
  • Putin defended the journalist's imprisonment, citing espionage due to secret information acquisition.
  • The dialogue with the US government regarding the journalist's release was ongoing, emphasizing a calm and professional approach.

02:17:53

Financial support, weapons influx, and peace negotiations.

  • Financial support of 72 billion US dollars provided, with Germany ranking second in support.
  • Large influx of weapons to Ukraine, urging current Ukrainian leadership to negotiate and rescind a decree.
  • Allegations of former British Prime Minister preventing Ukraine from negotiating peace settlement on behalf of the Biden Administration.
  • Discussion on dealing directly with the Biden Administration for decision-making.
  • Preparation of a document in Istanbul for peace settlement, hindered by Prime Minister Johnson.
  • Mention of promises made in 1991 regarding NATO expansion and US military bases in Ukraine.
  • Putin's perspective on NATO expansion and pressure on Russia, leading to the 2014 conflict in Ukraine.
  • Allegations of US backing separatists in Ukraine and the subsequent conflict.
  • Putin's call for peace and implementation of Minsk agreements, with accusations of Ukraine not complying.
  • Putin's belief in healing wounds and unity between Russian and Ukrainian people, emphasizing the need for denazification in Ukraine.

02:36:12

Putin's Views on Ukraine and Negotiations

  • Ukraine pushed Russia out according to Russia's point of view, which claims they left as part of negotiations.
  • Putin emphasizes the history of Ukraine collaborating with Hitler, mentioning the presence of 56 to 140,000 Jews in Ukraine and ties to Hitler by Ukrainian historical figures.
  • Putin accuses Zelensky of visiting Canada's parliament where a former Nazi gave a speech, leading to a scandal with a standing ovation.
  • Putin states he hasn't spoken with Biden since before the military operation, suggesting negotiations should start by stopping weapon supplies and fighting.
  • Putin criticizes NATO and the US for war-mongering and questions their focus on Ukraine instead of domestic issues like border problems and national debt.
  • Putin suggests the US should cooperate more with China, highlighting their long-standing partnership and the need for compromise.
  • Putin criticizes the United Nations as illegitimate but notes Russia's veto power in the Security Council due to being a P5 member.
  • Putin praises Bush and Trump, highlighting relationships with them and suggesting the goal is more important than the demeanor of politicians.
  • Putin expresses willingness to negotiate with Ukraine but points out past failed attempts due to external interference, urging readiness for negotiation without weapon supplies or fighting.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.