The 2021 Holberg Debate on Identity Politics: J. Butler, C. West, G.Greenwald and S. Critchley.

Holberg Prize・2 minutes read

The Holberg Debate, focusing on identity politics and cultural wars, featured speakers like Judith Butler and Glenn Greenwald discussing the complexities and impact of these issues, highlighting the need for deeper understanding and meaningful conversations to address systemic inequalities and foster social cohesion. The discussion delved into the intersection of racism, neoliberalism, and societal challenges, emphasizing the importance of moral critique, due process, and organized forces for sustained change in navigating complex issues and fostering societal harmony.

Insights

  • The Holberg Debate, organized annually with a significant prize, engages in public discourse on pressing issues, such as identity politics and cultural wars.
  • Judith Butler challenges the dismissal of movements as identity politics, emphasizing their role in addressing issues of justice, freedom, and equality, particularly against white supremacy.
  • Identity politics encompasses more than just cultural issues, delving into systemic violence and power dynamics, aiming for freedom of movement without restrictions.
  • Glenn Greenwald's personal narrative highlights the positive impact of identity politics in addressing discrimination and advocating for equality, showcasing its potential for societal change.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is the Holberg Debate and its purpose?

    The Holberg Debate is an annual event organized by the Holberg Prize at the University of Bergen, Norway, honoring Ludwig Holberg. It aims to engage academics and the public in discussions on pressing issues. This year's topic was identity politics and cultural wars, featuring prominent speakers like Judith Butler and Cornel West.

  • Who were the speakers at the Holberg Debate?

    The Holberg Debate featured speakers like Judith Butler, Cornel West, and Glenn Greenwald, with Simon Critchley moderating. They discussed topics such as identity politics, cultural issues, and systemic violence, emphasizing the importance of understanding and addressing societal challenges.

  • What are the key points discussed in the Holberg Debate?

    The speakers delved into the complexities of identity politics, challenging the moral content of one's identity and its political implications. They highlighted the importance of solidarity, struggles for human dignity, and the need for diverse perspectives in conversations about societal issues.

  • How does identity politics impact societal structures?

    Identity politics can either foster social cohesion or hinder it, depending on its application. It plays a crucial role in addressing issues of discrimination, systemic inequalities, and struggles for justice and equality in society.

  • What is the significance of the Holberg Prize?

    The Holberg Prize, established by the Norwegian government, honors Ludwig Holberg and aims to engage academics and the public in discussions on pressing issues. It provides a platform for in-depth conversations on topics like identity politics, cultural wars, and societal challenges.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Holberg Debate: Challenging Identity Politics and Equality

  • The Holberg Debate is organized by the Holberg Prize at the University of Bergen, Norway, worth 6 million Norwegian kroner or approximately 700,000 US dollars.
  • Established in 2003 by the Norwegian government, the Holberg Prize honors scientist and writer Ludwig Holberg, who lived from 1684 to 1754.
  • The Holberg Debate, held annually in December, aims to engage academics and non-academics in public debate on pressing issues, with this year's topic being identity politics and cultural wars.
  • Due to pandemic restrictions, the debate was live-streamed from New York City, featuring Judith Butler, Cornel West, and Glenn Greenwald, moderated by Simon Critchley.
  • The event structure includes 10 minutes of opening remarks from each speaker, followed by a discussion and closing remarks.
  • Judith Butler questions the framework of identity politics, emphasizing that movements for social justice are often labeled as identity politics, although they aim to challenge exclusionary principles of justice, freedom, and equality.
  • She highlights white supremacy as the most influential and dangerous form of identity politics, defending whiteness as superior and normative, leading to neofascist trends and border violence.
  • Butler argues that labeling movements as identity politics can be a way to dismiss their concerns without truly listening to their demands for justice and equality.
  • She challenges the distinction between cultural issues and systemic violence, pointing out that movements like Black Lives Matter address issues of violence, institutionalization, and state power, not just cultural identity.
  • Butler urges for a deeper understanding of the struggles for justice and equality, beyond simplistic categorizations like identity politics or cultural issues.

23:28

Navigating Identity Politics: Freedom, Integrity, and Change

  • Identity politics in public spaces is about freedom of movement without violence or restrictions, not merely cultural or identity issues.
  • The history of culture wars can be traced back to the late 19th century, with a book by James Davidson Hunter in 1991 highlighting the struggle for America's soul.
  • The conversation delves into the essence of identity politics, challenging the moral content of one's identity and its political consequences.
  • Identity politics is viewed through the lens of moral and spiritual integrity, linked to solidarity and struggles for human dignity against domination.
  • The term "identity politics" was first used by the Combahee River Collective in 1977, emphasizing honesty and acknowledging one's background in political engagement.
  • Identity politics can be positive, as seen through personal experiences like navigating homosexuality during the Reagan era and facing discrimination in same-sex marriage laws.
  • Glenn Greenwald shares his personal journey of facing discrimination in same-sex marriage laws, highlighting the impact on his life and family.
  • The term "identity politics" is complex and elusive, defined by its usage in discourse and politics rather than a fixed definition.
  • Identity politics can be a tool for positive change, as seen through personal narratives of discrimination and struggles for equality.
  • The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding the deployment and impact of identity politics in society and personal lives.

40:27

"Challenging Identity Politics: Uniting Against Division"

  • White children playing with non-white kids face potential police suspicion due to racial profiling.
  • Combatting injustices based on demographic identity and group membership is crucial.
  • Identity politics should aim to end categorical privileges, not fortify them.
  • Interview with Alexander Ocasio-Cortez highlighted concerns about deceptive use of identity politics.
  • Barack Obama's election exemplified how identity politics can be used to maintain the status quo.
  • Institutions like GCHQ and CIA use identity symbols to mask underlying exploitative practices.
  • Identity politics can be cynically weaponized to entrench existing power structures.
  • Concerns arise when discourse on discrimination inadvertently fosters division among groups.
  • Bernie Sanders' campaign success emphasized uniting people based on shared goals, not identity.
  • Exclusion of certain perspectives, like those of women of color, highlights systemic inequalities.

58:41

"Embracing diversity and solidarity for justice"

  • Non-violence is described as a force, including concepts like militant pacifism and aggressive non-violence.
  • Indigenous struggles against oppression, such as those in Brazil, are highlighted, emphasizing a history of suffering and persistence.
  • Political movements emerging from suffering are discussed, with a focus on solidarity with various groups fighting against corporate power and violence.
  • The importance of acknowledging vulnerability, victimization, and suffering in demanding justice and freedom is emphasized.
  • The need for expanding solidarities and listening to new social movements for a successful left movement is stressed.
  • The impact of the lack of women of color in conversations on identity politics is examined, highlighting the importance of diverse perspectives.
  • The complexity of diversity is explored, with a focus on the wide-ranging views different individuals can bring based on their backgrounds and experiences.
  • The necessity of considering class diversity alongside other forms of diversity is discussed, emphasizing the importance of including working-class perspectives.
  • The challenges of identity politics discourse and the need for clear language in addressing issues like white supremacy are addressed.
  • The importance of holding onto clear language while acknowledging the complexity of human identity and the need for truth-telling and humility in intellectual discussions is emphasized.

01:15:33

"Identity, politics, and the rise of extremism"

  • Inclusion of diverse perspectives is crucial for meaningful conversations, not just for representation.
  • Identity can serve as a starting point for understanding history and resisting degradation.
  • Politics should not solely focus on linguistic recognition but on deeper issues of history and existence.
  • White supremacy is not adequately described by identity politics; it involves a possessive sense of ownership over public spaces.
  • Identity politics may not fully capture the complexities of white nationalism and exclusivity in public spaces.
  • The term "tribalism" may oversimplify modern issues and neglect the struggles of actual tribes.
  • Far-right populist movements stem from economic insecurities and a sense of neglect by neoliberal elites.
  • Diversification in newsrooms may not truly represent diversity if individuals share similar privileged backgrounds.
  • The rise of far-right leaders like Trump and Bolsonaro reflects a backlash against neoliberalism and elite neglect.
  • The crisis of legitimacy among neoliberal elites contributes to the rise of neo-fascist possibilities and a sense of impotence among the populace.

01:32:34

"Examining Rittenhouse Case and Societal Challenges"

  • Glenn discusses the importance of due process, law, evidence, and jury division in the Kyle Rittenhouse case.
  • He emphasizes the need for institutions to be scrutinized to prevent abuse of power.
  • Glenn highlights discrepancies between media narratives and trial realities in the Rittenhouse case.
  • Cornell adds a moral dimension to the discussion, noting the importance of moral critique alongside due process.
  • He mentions the impact of neoliberalism on social services, environmental protections, and fear of destruction.
  • The conversation delves into the intersection of racism, anti-immigrant, anti-trans, and anti-feminist movements with neoliberal economic governance.
  • The fear of destruction is seen as a driving force behind various societal issues.
  • The discussion touches on the need for a more nuanced analysis of societal problems and the failure of the left to present a compelling vision.
  • The importance of institutional capacity and organized forces for sustained change is highlighted.
  • The conversation expands to include the spiritual aspect of engaging with classical texts and the closure of Howard University's classics department.

01:49:38

Classics and contemporary issues in academia.

  • Careerism and opportunism lead to a myopic vision and short-term calculation.
  • Right-wing individuals in Charlottesville were listening to Motown music, showcasing contradictions in their behavior.
  • The debate over the right wing's ownership of classical works of civilization is unnecessary.
  • Classics courses can be used to explore fundamental questions like democracy, slavery, and justice.
  • Texts like Antigone are being reappropriated globally to address contemporary issues.
  • Tragedies and classics are resources for broader conversations and revolutionary purposes.
  • Courses like "The Enlightenment" at the University of Essex explored texts through a critical lens.
  • Academia fosters discourse challenging orthodoxies and pieties, encouraging constructive dialogue.
  • Wearing a mask signifies a social bond and obligation to care for others during the pandemic.
  • There is a tension between civic virtue and personal liberty, requiring a balance for public health and individual rights.

02:06:03

Navigating societal challenges through trust and courage.

  • Building an ethos of mutual care and responsibility is crucial for societal harmony.
  • Suspicion towards mandates stems from historical traumas and experiences of oppression.
  • Different political ideologies and historical contexts shape individuals' perspectives on societal structures.
  • The COVID-19 pandemic has significant political and cultural implications, akin to the impact of the 9/11 attacks.
  • Concerns arise regarding the use of extensive state powers during the pandemic and the suppression of dissent.
  • The pandemic has centralized power in large corporations and governments, impacting small businesses and individual freedoms.
  • Balancing personal liberty with societal well-being is a complex ethical dilemma.
  • The importance of trust in institutions and public health systems in fostering vaccine acceptance is highlighted.
  • Restoring faith in institutions through persuasion rather than coercion is essential for societal cohesion.
  • Courage and a redefinition of freedom beyond individualism are crucial for navigating complex societal challenges.

02:22:27

Influences on individuals and society's cohesion.

  • Individuals can be affected by the death drive, but some can evade or disempower it.
  • Historical forces can act through people, shaping their actions and formation.
  • People are influenced by antecedent practices, figures, discourses, stories, and symbols.
  • Glenn Greenwald appreciates the civil and thoughtful discussion on complex issues.
  • Social pathology leads to hostility and division, hindering social cohesion.
  • Identity politics can either foster social cohesion or impede it, depending on its application.
  • Cornell West emphasizes the importance of exemplary movements and practices against negativity.
  • Judith Butler advocates for a more open-minded and listening approach to address societal challenges.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.