Simulating alternate voting systems
Primer・13 minutes read
Plurality voting can lead to the spoiler effect, while instant runoff voting faces issues like the center squeeze phenomenon. Approval voting eliminates the spoiler effect and allows voters to strategically disapprove of their least favorite candidate to increase their preferred candidate's chances of winning.
Insights
- Plurality voting leads to the spoiler effect, where a third candidate can impact the election outcome, highlighting a flaw in this voting system.
- Approval voting allows voters to strategically disapprove of their least favorite candidate to boost the chances of their preferred candidate winning, presenting a unique approach that balances strategy and honesty in voting.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are the different types of voting systems used in elections?
There are three main types of voting systems used in elections: plurality voting, instant runoff voting, and approval voting. Plurality voting involves each voter selecting one candidate, instant runoff voting requires voters to rank candidates from best to worst, and approval voting allows voters to choose as many candidates as they want within a defined approval range.
How does the spoiler effect impact election outcomes?
The spoiler effect occurs in plurality voting when a third candidate affects the outcome by drawing votes away from one of the main candidates, potentially leading to an unintended winner. This phenomenon highlights the limitations of plurality voting and the need for alternative voting systems that can mitigate such effects.
What is the main advantage of approval voting over instant runoff voting?
Approval voting eliminates the spoiler effect seen in plurality voting and some strategic voting issues present in instant runoff voting. By allowing voters to express support for multiple candidates without fear of wasting their vote, approval voting aims to provide a more accurate representation of voter preferences and reduce the impact of strategic voting tactics.
How does strategic voting manifest in approval voting?
In approval voting, strategic voting can manifest in the form of a chicken dilemma, where voters must decide how much to betray their preferences to ensure their preferred candidate wins. This dilemma arises from the flexibility of approval voting, as voters can strategically disapprove of their least favorite candidate to increase the chances of their preferred candidates winning.
Why are approval voting and ranked choice voting preferred over plurality voting?
Approval voting and ranked choice voting are favored over plurality voting because they allow voters to honestly express their preferences without the constraints of a single-choice system. By providing more flexibility and accuracy in representing voter preferences, these alternative voting systems offer a more democratic approach to elections and have the potential to replace the traditional plurality voting method.
Related videos
Summary
00:00
"Voting Systems: Balancing Strategy and Preference"
- In the United States and many other countries, two dominant political parties exist, largely due to the voting system used.
- Plurality voting, also known as first past the post, involves each voter selecting one candidate.
- Instant runoff voting, or ranked choice voting, requires voters to rank candidates from best to worst, eliminating one at a time.
- Approval voting allows voters to choose as many candidates as they want within a defined approval range.
- Plurality voting can lead to the spoiler effect, where a third candidate affects the outcome.
- Instant runoff voting aims to balance honesty and strategy in voting but can still face issues like the center squeeze phenomenon.
- Approval voting eliminates the spoiler effect seen in plurality voting and some strategic voting seen in instant runoff voting.
- In approval voting, voters may strategically disapprove of their least favorite candidate to increase the chances of their preferred candidates winning.
- Strategic voting in approval voting can lead to a chicken dilemma, where voters must decide how much to betray their preferences to ensure their preferred candidate wins.
- Approval voting is a form of score voting, part of range voting systems, but lacks significant real-world examples for definitive conclusions.
13:01
"Ranked and Approval Voting: Better Than Plurality"
- Ranked choice voting is the second most common single winner voting method, potentially having the best chance of replacing plurality voting. Approval voting is also favored as voters can honestly express their first choice, whether being aggressive or compromising with subsequent choices. Both options are preferred over plurality voting, which is deemed unfavorable, although any voting system is better than not voting at all.
