Rosemary oil for hair growth? How to spot bad science

Lab Muffin Beauty Science・2 minutes read

Rosemary oil has been compared to minoxidil as a treatment for hair growth but requires further study to determine its effectiveness due to flawed data in existing research. The lack of substantial clinical trials and varying levels of active ingredients in rosemary oil raise doubts about its reliability and effectiveness compared to approved hair growth drugs like minoxidil.

Insights

  • Rosemary oil has been shown to be as effective as minoxidil in treating hair loss, but its reliability is questioned due to flawed data points in a study, impacting the credibility of its reported benefits.
  • Despite potential positive outcomes in self-assessments, rosemary oil lacks substantial clinical trials and reliable evidence to support its efficacy, making it less practical and trustworthy compared to approved drugs like minoxidil for hair growth.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • Is rosemary oil effective for hair growth?

    Yes

  • What role do peer-reviewed journals play in scientific research?

    Evaluation and publication

  • What are the limitations of abstracts in scientific papers?

    Lack comprehensive understanding

  • Are there inaccuracies in the data of the study comparing rosemary oil and minoxidil?

    Yes

  • How does rosemary oil compare to finasteride in terms of effectiveness?

    Less practical

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Rosemary Oil vs. Minoxidil for Hair Growth

  • Rosemary oil is considered a scientifically backed treatment for hair growth, comparable to minoxidil.
  • Studies from 2015 have shown rosemary oil to be as effective as minoxidil in treating hair loss.
  • Topical application of diluted rosemary oil on the scalp can be beneficial for patients with androgenetic alopecia.
  • Consistent use of rosemary oil for at least 6 months is recommended to determine its effectiveness.
  • Peer-reviewed journals play a crucial role in scientific research by evaluating and publishing articles.
  • The peer review process involves experts in the field assessing the quality and validity of research articles.
  • Peer review has its limitations, including potential biases, lack of recognition for reviewers, and variability in quality.
  • Abstracts in scientific papers serve as summaries but may not provide a comprehensive understanding of the study.
  • The abstract of a study comparing rosemary oil and minoxidil for hair growth highlights significant hair count increases.
  • Critical evaluation of the full scientific paper is essential to understand the methodology, results, and limitations accurately.

12:29

Data Accuracy Concerns in Rosemary Oil Study

  • The graph from the data shows identical baseline and month three numbers, raising concerns about accuracy.
  • Despite typos not necessarily indicating a flawed study, two key data points in this research are incorrect.
  • Only six numbers are crucial in the study, with two being inaccurate, casting doubt on the reliability of the other four.
  • Peer reviewers and authors failed to rectify the errors in the data, questioning the study's credibility.
  • The study's calculations, especially regarding baseline and month three numbers, are under scrutiny for potential inaccuracies.
  • The study's findings, based on these flawed data points, may not be trustworthy, prompting the need for raw data verification.
  • The study's minimal impact on hair count, with an average difference of six or two hairs, is deemed insignificant given the standard deviation.
  • Seasonal variations and other factors could influence hair growth, potentially skewing the study's results.
  • Self-assessments in the study indicate positive outcomes for rosemary oil, but skepticism arises due to inconsistencies with other studies and social media claims.
  • Mechanistic reasoning for rosemary oil's potential benefits is discussed, but the lack of clinical efficacy and reliable evidence raises doubts about its effectiveness compared to approved drugs like minoxidil.

24:45

Rosemary oil less effective than finasteride

  • To achieve 2/3 of the effect of finasteride, you would need 230 times more of a specific compound found in rosemary, but due to the low concentration of this compound in rosemary, you would have to use 2 kg of rosemary leaves daily, making rosemary oil less practical compared to finasteride.
  • Rosemary oil lacks substantial clinical trials to support its effectiveness, relying mainly on mechanistic reasons which are not strong indicators of success. The varying levels of active ingredients in rosemary oil due to factors like growth conditions and extraction methods further diminish its reliability.
  • Rosemary oil contains components like camphor, carnosol, and cineole that can be irritating and allergenic, potentially worsening hair loss. While minoxidil also causes scalp itching, its proven hair growth mechanisms outweigh any irritation, unlike rosemary oil, which lacks clear evidence of its impact on hair loss.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.