Poisoned Waters (full documentary) | FRONTLINE

FRONTLINE PBS | Official・2 minutes read

Puget Sound and Chesapeake Bay are facing severe pollution, impacting wildlife and human health, despite past efforts to regulate and clean up the waters. Urgent action is needed to address pollution in these water bodies within the next two decades to prevent irreversible damage to the environment.

Insights

  • Pollution from agriculture is a significant threat to water bodies like Puget Sound and Chesapeake Bay, causing deformities in wildlife and health risks for humans due to industrial waste contamination.
  • Despite the Clean Water Act being in place for three decades, America has failed to effectively clean up its waterways, leading to dead zones suffocating aquatic life in the Chesapeake Bay and impacting fish and crabs.
  • Efforts to regulate and clean up water pollution face challenges from powerful industries like poultry farming, with resistance to strict regulations hindering progress, despite the success of technologies like Biological Nutrient Removal in improving water quality.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How is pollution impacting Chesapeake Bay?

    Pollution from agriculture and industrial waste is significantly impacting Chesapeake Bay, leading to deformities in wildlife, dead zones suffocating aquatic life, and health risks for humans. The pollution, primarily from nitrogen and phosphorus, occupies up to 40% of the bay, impacting fish and crabs, and causing fish kills. This pollution not only affects wildlife but also leads to beach closures and health advisories for humans. The ecosystem of Chesapeake Bay is being fundamentally altered by human activities, threatening its ability to support recreation and seafood. Despite scientific knowledge on how to save the bay, political will is lacking, hindering efforts to clean up the waters.

  • What technology helped improve water quality in Potomac River?

    Biological Nutrient Removal (BNR) technology, involving bacteria consuming sewage, proved effective in improving water quality in the Potomac River. Excess nutrients like phosphorus and nitrogen from human waste were causing water quality issues in the river. Wastewater treatment plants upgraded to remove phosphorus, but significant improvement was only seen when nitrogen removal was implemented. The Blue Plains modernization, costing a billion dollars, included BNR technology and was successful, leading to over 100 sewage treatment plants adopting it. Strict regulations, penalties, and inspections by the EPA and state governments ensured sewage treatment compliance and progress.

  • What is the impact of poultry farming on Chesapeake Bay?

    Intense poultry farming on the Chesapeake Bay's eastern shore has led to significant pollution issues from chicken manure. Big chicken companies, like Perdue, lobbied against strict regulations on agriculture waste, resisting efforts to regulate nutrient management by farmers to reduce runoff from chicken manure. The excess manure from poultry farming is a major unregulated source of water pollution, causing significant environmental damage in the bay. Efforts to regulate nutrient management faced resistance from the powerful poultry industry, despite claims of implementing more best management practices each year to address pollution concerns.

  • How are emerging contaminants affecting drinking water?

    Emerging contaminants like pharmaceuticals and chemicals in drinking water pose a challenge for regulators and water treatment facilities. The Washington Aqueduct, supplying water to one million people in DC, faces difficulties in filtering out new contaminants due to outdated systems. Studies reveal that a significant portion of emerging contaminants detected in river water make it through the filtering process into tap water. Concerns arise about the combined effects of multiple contaminants, potentially leading to unforeseen health risks like lower sperm count and reproductive issues. The presence of these contaminants highlights the need for improved water treatment and regulatory measures to ensure safe drinking water.

  • What are the challenges in cleaning up the Duwamish River?

    The Duwamish River, a major hotspot for PCB contamination, is a federal Superfund site due to toxic pollution from decades of industrial activity. Legacy pollutants like PCBs have accumulated in the river sediments, contaminating the food web and posing health risks to wildlife and humans. Boeing, a major contributor to PCB contamination, has clashed with the EPA over cleanup efforts, leading to delays and disputes over responsibility. The ongoing battle between Boeing and the city of Seattle has hindered cleanup efforts and led to legal disputes. The cost of cleanup and liability for PCB contamination is a significant concern, with disagreements persisting over achieving cleanup goals to allow safe consumption of fish and shellfish.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Environmental Threats to Puget Sound and Chesapeake"

  • Puget Sound and Chesapeake Bay are facing critical environmental threats, with pollution from agriculture being a significant contributor.
  • Industrial waste is contaminating the waters, leading to deformities in wildlife and posing health risks to humans.
  • Frontline investigates the failure of America to clean up its waterways despite the Clean Water Act being in place for three decades.
  • Dead zones, caused by excessive nitrogen and phosphorus from fertilizers, are suffocating aquatic life in the Chesapeake Bay.
  • Dead zones occupy up to 40% of the main stem of the bay, impacting fish and crabs, leading to fish kills.
  • Pollution is not only affecting wildlife but also causing health issues for humans, leading to beach closures and advisories.
  • The Chesapeake Bay's ecosystem is being fundamentally altered by human activities, threatening its ability to support recreation and seafood.
  • Despite scientific knowledge on how to save the bay, political will is lacking, hindering efforts to clean up the waters.
  • In the past, public outrage and demand for action led to the creation of environmental protection laws like the Clean Water Act.
  • The EPA, under strong leadership, enforced regulations and took action against polluters, leading to significant improvements in water quality, such as in the Potomac River.

18:10

Chesapeake Bay Pollution: Impact and Solutions

  • Potomac River and bay faced water quality issues due to excess nutrients from human waste like phosphorus and nitrogen.
  • Wastewater treatment plants upgraded to remove phosphorus, but river quality didn't improve significantly until nitrogen removal was implemented.
  • Biological Nutrient Removal (BNR) technology, involving bacteria consuming sewage, proved effective in improving water quality.
  • Blue Plains modernization, costing a billion dollars, included BNR technology and was successful, leading to over 100 sewage treatment plants adopting it.
  • EPA and state governments enforced strict regulations, penalties, and inspections to ensure sewage treatment compliance and progress.
  • Reagan administration's deregulatory agenda weakened EPA, shifting to voluntary compliance, impacting environmental protection efforts.
  • Chesapeake Bay Program, a voluntary initiative, missed targets, failing to reduce water pollution as promised by the Clean Water Act.
  • Intense poultry farming on the Chesapeake Bay's eastern shore led to significant pollution issues from chicken manure.
  • Purdue Farms' growth transformed the poultry industry, leading to concentrated factory-style production and massive manure production.
  • Agriculture, particularly poultry farming, is a major unregulated source of water pollution, with excess manure causing significant environmental damage.

36:07

Poultry Industry Pollution Threatens Chesapeake Bay

  • Agriculture, particularly poultry farming, contributes significantly to pollution in the Chesapeake Bay.
  • Efforts to regulate nutrient management by farmers to reduce runoff from chicken manure faced resistance from the powerful poultry industry.
  • Big chicken companies, like Perdue, lobbied extensively against strict regulations on agriculture waste.
  • Purdue initiated a program to recycle excess manure and educate growers on better manure management to avoid more regulations.
  • The poultry industry claims to be implementing more best management practices each year to address pollution concerns.
  • Scientists have discovered intersex in male bass, linked to exposure to endocrine disruptors, posing risks to marine life and potentially human health.
  • The presence of emerging contaminants in drinking water, including pharmaceuticals and chemicals, poses a challenge for regulators and water treatment facilities.
  • The Washington Aqueduct, supplying water to one million people in DC, faces difficulties in filtering out new contaminants due to outdated systems.
  • Studies reveal that a significant portion of emerging contaminants detected in river water make it through the filtering process into tap water.
  • Concerns arise about the combined effects of multiple contaminants, potentially leading to unforeseen health risks, such as lower sperm count and reproductive issues.

54:26

"PCB Pollution Threatens Puget Sound Ecosystem"

  • Puget Sound is facing serious issues, with declining orca populations serving as a key indicator of ecosystem health.
  • Killer whales in Puget Sound are studied closely due to their role as top predators accumulating contaminants, with alarming levels of PCBs found in their blubber.
  • PCBs, cancer-causing chemicals banned by Congress, persist in the environment and bioaccumulate in food webs, posing health risks to humans and marine mammals.
  • The decline in orca populations, with only 86 individuals remaining, is attributed to PCB contamination and other pollutants in the ecosystem.
  • The Duwamish River, a major hotspot for PCB contamination, is a federal Superfund site due to toxic pollution from decades of industrial activity.
  • Legacy pollutants like PCBs, once widely used in industry, have accumulated in the river sediments, contaminating the food web and posing health risks to wildlife and humans.
  • Boeing, a major contributor to PCB contamination in the Duwamish River, has clashed with the EPA over cleanup efforts, leading to delays and disputes over responsibility.
  • The ongoing battle between Boeing and the city of Seattle over PCB contamination in the river has hindered cleanup efforts and led to legal disputes.
  • The cost of cleanup and liability for PCB contamination in the Duwamish River is a significant concern, with millions of dollars needed to address the pollution.
  • The ultimate goal is to clean up the river sufficiently to allow local tribes to safely consume fish and shellfish, but disagreements persist over the feasibility of achieving this goal.

01:11:34

South Park Community Advocacy Leads Cleanup

  • Setting reasonable expectations for cleanup in industrial areas is crucial, focusing on achieving a level where rivers are safe for fishing and consuming fish without health concerns.
  • The community of South Park faced contamination with PCBs, causing fear and concern among residents, particularly those with children, leading to demands for cleanup.
  • Malarkey Asphalt, an industrial site in South Park, was a source of pollution due to past practices like open dumping and waste oil spraying, prompting the community to push for further testing and cleanup.
  • Tests revealed high PCB levels at Malarkey, exceeding federal limits, leading to disagreements over cleanup standards between the community and authorities.
  • South Park residents advocated for a more stringent cleanup standard of one part per million, emphasizing safety for the entire community, which was eventually adopted despite initial resistance.
  • South Park's community activism led to a successful cleanup effort, redefining the concept of cleanliness and prompting the development of riverfront habitat zones.
  • Stormwater runoff, a major threat to waterways, carries pollutants like PCBs into Puget Sound, with the volume of oil entering Puget Sound through stormwater runoff being equivalent to the Exxon Valdez spill every two years.
  • Impervious surfaces like concrete and asphalt exacerbate stormwater pollution, emphasizing the importance of land use in combating pollution.
  • King County's Chief Executive Ron Sims focused on protecting critical areas like forests to safeguard water quality, implementing ordinances to control development and prevent sprawl.
  • Rural landowners, like the Van Lakens, faced property rights challenges due to zoning ordinances, leading to resentment and activism against regulations perceived as onerous, culminating in the formation of the Citizens Alliance for Property Rights.

01:29:13

Challenges and Solutions in Urban Development

  • Ron Sims faced backlash for implementing a county ordinance based on scientific analysis of runoff water flows.
  • Critics argue that the ordinance restricts land use, but Sims maintains that no one has lost the value or use of their land in King County.
  • A lawsuit challenged Sims' Critical Areas Ordinance, with a state appeals court partially striking it down, now pending before the state supreme court.
  • Tysons Corner in Virginia exemplifies unchecked growth leading to environmental issues, with rapid development and loss of forested areas.
  • Tysons Corner's success stemmed from buying cheap farmland, rezoning it for commercial use, and developing infrastructure like roads and sewers.
  • Tysons Corner's reliance on cars has led to severe traffic congestion, with the area now considered as built out as it can be.
  • Tysons Corner's impervious surfaces, like parking lots, contribute to environmental issues by causing rapid runoff and pollution of waterways.
  • Loudoun County countered aggressive development by leveraging local concerns about traffic, taxes, and schools to halt proposed growth.
  • Arlington County in Virginia showcases smart growth principles, focusing on high-density living around mass transit stations to reduce traffic and environmental impact.
  • Remaking Tysons Corner to prioritize mass transit and pedestrian-friendly design offers a chance to improve stormwater management and environmental conservation efforts.

01:46:45

Global Water Pollution Crisis: Urgent Action Needed

  • Water bodies worldwide are showing alarming signs of pollution, including dead zones, intersex fish, and health risks for humans, emphasizing the need for public engagement to address these issues effectively.
  • The restoration of polluted water bodies like Puget Sound and Chesapeake Bay requires a holistic approach that combines efforts to ensure clean water, air, and land, highlighting the urgency of taking action within the next 10 to 20 years to prevent irreversible damage to the planet.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.