Military Historian Reviews the Best Movie Battle Scenes of All Time

History Hit・2 minutes read

Veterans recommend watching Saving Private Ryan's opening scene for a realistic depiction of D-Day, while military expert Dan Snow selects favorite battle scenes for their realism, including Alexander the Great's Battle of Gaugamela. The film showcases the brutality and chaos of ancient battles, the innovative tactics of Robert the Bruce, and the clashes between cultures during the French Indian War, highlighting the struggles and sacrifices of soldiers in historical conflicts.

Insights

  • **"Veterans of D-Day praise Saving Private Ryan's opening scene for its realistic portrayal of the chaos and intensity of the battlefield."**
  • **"Native American fighting skills and adaptation to North American terrain posed challenges for European forces during the French Indian War, showcasing the effectiveness of indigenous tactics in combat."**

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What battle scene is recommended for realism?

    Saving Private Ryan's opening scene

  • What innovative tactics did Robert the Bruce use?

    Trenches and long pikes

  • What battle is analyzed for historical accuracy?

    The Battle of Gaugamela

  • What did Native Americans use in combat?

    Rifles and muskets

  • How did the British adapt to North American terrain?

    Mix of European and indigenous fighting styles

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Realistic Battles in Hollywood History: Analysis

  • Veterans of D-Day recommend watching the opening scene of Saving Private Ryan for a realistic depiction of the battlefield.
  • Dan Snow, a military history expert, selects six favorite battle scenes from Hollywood history for their realism.
  • The Battle of Gaugamela in 331 BC, featuring Alexander the Great, is analyzed for historical accuracy and inaccuracies in the film.
  • Darius's multicultural army, including Greeks and various other troops, faces Alexander's forces in a brutal clash.
  • Alexander's strategic maneuver against the Persian army at Gaugamela is depicted, leading to Darius's vulnerability.
  • The Battle of Gaugamela is portrayed as chaotic and dusty, reflecting the obscurity and confusion of ancient battles.
  • The Outlaw King's Battle of Loudon Hill showcases Robert the Bruce's innovative tactics against heavily armored English knights.
  • Robert the Bruce's use of trenches and long pikes to counter English cavalry is highlighted in the Battle of Loudon Hill.
  • The Last of the Mohicans depicts a British column in the American frontier during the French Indian War, emphasizing the clash of cultures and fighting techniques.
  • The film's portrayal of a massacre of British prisoners by the Huron tribe reflects the brutal reality of the colonial period's warfare.

17:37

Indigenous tactics in North American warfare.

  • Captain and Below would be on foot with their men in battle, while women and children supported the army with cooking, laundry, and other tasks.
  • Native Americans allied with the British in the French Indian War ambushed both sides due to the unfamiliar terrain in North America.
  • Native Americans traded, stole, or were issued guns by the British or French, becoming skilled in their use for hunting and combat.
  • Native American fighting skills, fitness, and agility were effective in close combat against the British, who were used to open-field battles in Europe.
  • Native Americans sometimes adopted European children, raising them as their own, showcasing cultural exchanges during the war.
  • Rifles with grooves for greater speed and accuracy were used alongside muskets in battles, enhancing shooting precision.
  • The British faced challenges adapting their tactics to the wooded, broken terrain of North America, requiring a mix of European and indigenous fighting styles.
  • The Battle of the Crater during the U.S. Civil War depicted trench warfare and the failed Union attempt to break the Confederate siege lines.
  • African-American troops were withdrawn last minute from a crucial attack, leading to disastrous consequences for the Union forces at the Battle of the Crater.
  • The depiction of warfare in "All Quiet on the Western Front" showcases the transition from medieval to modern warfare, emphasizing the brutal realities faced by soldiers.

35:15

Revolutionary depiction of D-Day in film

  • The opening scene of Saving Private Ryan is highlighted as a revolutionary moment in filmmaking, depicting the intense and realistic chaos of soldiers landing on Omaha Beach during D-Day.
  • The film showcases the bravery and self-control of the soldiers as they face the brutal realities of war, with accurate details like the cold English Channel and the challenges of the beach terrain.
  • Despite some inaccuracies for dramatic effect, the film effectively portrays the struggles and sacrifices of the soldiers during the D-Day landings, particularly on Omaha Beach.
  • Saving Private Ryan's depiction of the Omaha Beach landing, although intense and powerful, focuses on the bloodiest part of D-Day, overshadowing the relatively less challenging experiences on other beaches during the invasion.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.