LoginGet started

Is Software Dev Over?

Theo - t3․gg・50 minutes read

Devon, the first AI software engineer, showcases advanced capabilities, but human engineers still outperform in issue resolution. Concerns arise about efficiency and potential improvement in Devon's processes, sparking a debate on AI's role in software development and adherence to standards.

Insights

  • Devon, the AI software engineer, showcases advanced reasoning and long-term planning capabilities, but can only resolve a small percentage of issues in a GitHub repo, highlighting the continued superiority of human engineers in problem-solving.
  • Concerns are raised regarding the efficiency of AI systems like Devon, indicating a need for improvement in task completion times and overall performance, as well as highlighting the ongoing debate surrounding AI's role in software development and adherence to industry standards.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • How capable is Devon, the AI software engineer?

    Devon, the AI software engineer, is highly capable in resolving GitHub issues, creating projects, debugging errors, and deploying websites. It can learn from blog posts, fix bugs, and handle various tasks efficiently. However, it can only resolve 13 to 14% of issues in a GitHub repo, indicating that human engineers still hold superiority in certain aspects.

  • What are the concerns regarding AI technology in software development?

    Concerns regarding AI technology in software development include potential inefficiencies in processes, the need for improvement in task completion time, limitations in simulating complex scenes, and risks associated with the early stage of AI technology. There are also criticisms about AI usage for presentations and concerns about the size efficiency of AI frameworks.

  • Who introduced Debon, another AI software engineer, for comparison?

    Neil introduced Debon, another AI software engineer, for comparison of audio quality. Debon's usage for presentations was criticized for lack of typing during demos, highlighting potential areas for improvement in AI technology.

  • How does Cognition AI combine different AI models for progress?

    Cognition AI combines models like GPT 4 with reinforcement learning techniques to make progress in AI technology. The AI assistant can maintain state through tasks, unlike other systems that derail quickly, showcasing unique ways to combine models for efficiency and advancement in technology.

  • What tools are commonly used on the website mentioned in the Summary?

    The website mentioned in the Summary uses tools like analytics, Hotjar, and webflow, with hardcoded dates and entries on their blog. The CTO found a broken upload button and recommended using Upload Thing for file management. Google Docs and Google Forms are also commonly used for various purposes, including partner meetups and domain issues, showcasing a diverse range of tools utilized for website functionality.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Devon: AI Developer Raises Job Concerns"

  • Devon, an AI developer, is causing concern among engineers about AI taking over their jobs.
  • New developers are advised not to worry about AI taking their jobs as it can be seen as an opportunity to enter the software field.
  • Cognition Labs introduced Devon as the first AI software engineer, capable of passing engineering interviews and completing real jobs.
  • Devon is an autonomous agent using its own Shell Code editor and web browser to resolve GitHub issues, surpassing previous models in issue resolution.
  • Despite Devon's capabilities, it can only resolve 13 to 14% of issues in a GitHub repo, indicating that human engineers are still superior.
  • Devon can create projects, debug errors, and deploy websites, showcasing advancements in reasoning and long-term planning.
  • Devon's ability to learn from blog posts and fix bugs is demonstrated, taking around 42 minutes to implement knowledge from a blog post.
  • Devon's assistance in fixing bugs in a Python repo took an hour, involving setting up the repo, reproducing the issue, and identifying the bug.
  • Devon's process of identifying and fixing the bug involved replacing integer division with true division and verifying the results.
  • Concerns are raised about the time taken by Devon to complete tasks, indicating potential inefficiencies in its processes and the need for improvement.

14:00

AI Software Engineer Debon: Limitations and Concerns

  • Neil introduces Debon, an AI software engineer, for comparison of audio quality.
  • Debon's AI usage for presentations is criticized for lack of typing during demos.
  • Concerns arise about the early stage of AI technology and its risks.
  • OpenAI's cautious approach to releasing AI tools is commended.
  • Debon's limitations in simulating complex scenes are highlighted.
  • Matt Bilman, CEO of Netlify, showcases Debon building a basic to-do app with flaws.
  • Ryan Carniato, creator of Solid JS, questions Debon's performance and size efficiency.
  • Debon's use of React, Chakra UI, and Frame Remotion is noted, raising concerns about library inclusion.
  • Comparison of Debon's app size with other frameworks like Spelt, Preact, and Solid is made.
  • The debate on AI's role in software development and adherence to standards is discussed.

26:21

"AI Innovations: Top Engineers and Breakthroughs"

  • One of the founders of a coding company was a top engineer at Scale AI, an early but successful AI company.
  • Yan, a Harvard student, requested to keep his school status ambiguous due to parental concerns.
  • The Woo brothers, renowned for their coding skills, have excelled in international competitions.
  • The company has made a breakthrough in AI reasoning, surpassing predictive capabilities.
  • Devon, an AI system, can handle numerous tasks without losing coherence, unlike other systems.
  • Devon can build a website in 5-10 minutes and recreate games efficiently.
  • A co-founder of a stealth AI startup aims to advance technology significantly.
  • Cognition AI combines llms like GPT 4 with reinforcement learning techniques for progress.
  • The AI assistant can maintain state through tasks, unlike others that derail quickly.
  • Cognition AI's technology remains mysterious, with unique ways to combine models for efficiency.

37:14

"Tech company improves website functionality and design"

  • The Dom and the react debugger have a prop called after signing URL, which redirects based on the value set.
  • The website uses tools like analytics, Hotjar, and webflow, with hardcoded dates and entries on their blog.
  • The CTO found a broken upload button and recommended using Upload Thing for file management.
  • Google Docs and Google Forms are commonly used for various purposes, including partner meetups and domain issues.
  • Maris is a company from the current Y Combinator batch, offering quick project scaffolding for developers.
  • The website offers a feature to rewrite descriptions using Marble's capabilities for better outcomes.
  • The code review of the website's functionality found it passable but with room for improvement, especially in code organization and unused imports.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.