Is Democracy Doomed? The Global Fight for Our Future | Timothy Snyder | TED

TED・2 minutes read

Democracy should be viewed as a verb, not a noun, with individuals needing to actively commit to it rather than assuming its inevitability due to external forces. Recognizing historical patterns and the relationship between democracy and risk is crucial in guiding actions and decisions to combat threats like tyranny and climate change.

Insights

  • Democracy should be seen as an active process rather than a static system, requiring personal commitment and resistance against external influences to thrive, as highlighted by the historian of Eastern Europe and Ukraine.
  • The intertwining of democracy, historical patterns, and personal risk underscores the necessity of recognizing past lessons, resisting nostalgia-driven politics, and actively defending democratic principles against threats like fossil fuels and climate change for a sustainable future.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What does the speaker emphasize about democracy?

    Democracy should be viewed as a verb.

  • How does the speaker highlight the importance of resistance for democracy?

    Ukrainians' resistance against Russian invasion showcases the necessity of defying larger forces for democracy.

  • What historical knowledge is crucial for democracy?

    Historical knowledge and ethics are crucial for bridging the gap between complacency and the struggle for democracy.

  • How does the speaker address the fear of the future in relation to democracy?

    Fear of the future often overshadows democratic principles.

  • What is the speaker's book "On Tyranny" about?

    The speaker's book "On Tyranny" serves as a guide to resistance.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Democracy as Verb: Historical Patterns and Risk"

  • The speaker, a historian of Eastern Europe and Ukraine, questions the concept of democracy, emphasizing that it should be viewed as a verb rather than a noun.
  • Democracy is portrayed as an internal desire for people to rule, not an external entity influenced by larger forces like capitalism.
  • The belief that democracy is inevitable due to external factors has led to a decline in democracy globally, with the speaker highlighting the importance of individual commitment to democracy.
  • The Ukrainians' resistance against Russian invasion showcases the necessity of defying larger forces for democracy, emphasizing the need for personal risk and commitment.
  • Historical knowledge and ethics are crucial in bridging the gap between complacency and the struggle for democracy in the United States.
  • Fear of the future often overshadows the importance of democratic principles like counting votes and representation, leading to a sense of democracy slipping away.
  • The speaker's book "On Tyranny" serves as a guide to resistance by highlighting the importance of recognizing historical patterns and the relationship between democracy and risk.
  • Throughout history, chaos has often accompanied technological advancements, such as the invention of books and the internet, emphasizing the need for understanding historical patterns.
  • Traditionally, those advocating for democracy have also emphasized the necessity of taking risks, dating back to ancient Greece, where democracy was linked to physical risk.
  • The speaker stresses the importance of recognizing historical patterns and the relationship between democracy and risk in guiding actions and decisions in the current moment.

12:42

"Democracy's Fragility and Resilience Against Tyranny"

  • Democracy is not assumed but believed to be better, although it requires significant effort and often fails historically.
  • The speaker emphasizes the importance of conviction in democracy over external forces.
  • The book "The Road to Unfreedom" explores how tyranny thrives in Europe, particularly in Russia, and discusses two types of tyrannical politics: inevitability and eternity politics.
  • Inevitability politics suggest a single future, leading to a denial of alternatives and potential for worse outcomes.
  • Eternity politics focus on nostalgia and deny the future, often leading to denial of science like climate change.
  • The politics of eternity can lead to a politics of catastrophe, denying climate change and setting up for worse consequences.
  • Comparing the present threats to democracy with historical moments like world wars and the Great Depression, the speaker notes the importance of recognizing patterns and the possibility of recovery.
  • The need for proactive and defensive democracy, updating mindsets, and changing algorithms to combat misinformation and support democracy is emphasized.
  • Investigative reporting is crucial for challenging narratives and providing surprising facts that can correct false narratives.
  • Fossil fuels, particularly oil, play a significant role in threatening democracies globally by collapsing the future and hindering the essential aspect of democracy needing a future for negotiations and balance.

24:40

Climate change threatens democracy and global stability.

  • Climate change will push individuals to prioritize their own needs over democracy, leading to a lack of thriving democracy.
  • Hydrocarbon oligarchy concentrates wealth, distorts conversations, and influences global events like Russia's actions in Ukraine.
  • Democracy struggles to coexist with hydrocarbons due to the wealth concentration and resulting political influence.
  • Existing alternatives to democracy, like China and Russia, perform worse on key criteria such as corruption and voter disinterest.
  • Imperfect as it is, democracy provides a framework for improvement and human freedom, contrasting with other flawed systems.
  • Teaching children about democracy involves discussing its challenges, showcasing past examples, and modeling democratic behavior.
  • The interconnectedness of freedom, democracy, and climate change highlights the importance of fostering democracy for a secure future.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.