I Bought 8 Pounds of Magic Cards from a Goodwill Auction

MTGGoldfish Unboxings・2 minutes read

Purchased a collection of Magic cards for $400, hoping for valuable cards but finding mostly basic lands and random rares. Despite disappointment in the deck composition, the most valuable card found was a $25 Yu-Gi-Oh card, leading the player to realize they may have overpaid and are unlikely to recoup their investment.

Insights

  • The purchase of 8 pounds of Magic cards for $400 from a Goodwill auction resulted in the discovery of various valuable cards like rares, mythics, foil lands, and sought-after cards like Windswept Heath, Fire Dragon, and Scourge Wolf, hinting at potential value within the collection.
  • Despite the excitement of finding valuable cards, including notable ones like Fireball, Wolf of Devil's Breach, and Priest of Titania, the individual realizes they may have overpaid and are unlikely to recoup their investment, with the most valuable card being a Yu-Gi-Oh card worth $25, underscoring the risk and uncertainty involved in such purchases.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What was discovered in the fat pack boxes?

    Various cards, including rares like Fire Dragon and Scourge Wolf.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Treasure Trove: Magic Cards Haul Exceeds Expectations"

  • Purchased eight pounds of Magic cards for $400 from a Goodwill auction.
  • The listing included mixed Magic the Gathering cards with sleeves, sold for $43 more than desired.
  • The collection contains rares and mythics, indicating potential value.
  • Decks and hard shells suggest a curated collection rather than random cards.
  • Hope for valuable cards in the decks, not just dual decks.
  • Unpacking revealed four fat pack boxes and a Pokemon deck box.
  • Fat pack boxes contained various cards, including rares like Fire Dragon and Scourge Wolf.
  • Discovery of foil lands, valuable cards like Windswept Heath, and a mix of decks.
  • Identified a monogreen infect deck with functional but not highly valuable cards.
  • Found additional random cards, including Yu-Gi-Oh cards and a variety of decks.

14:08

Assorted card collection with potential Pokémon value.

  • The collection includes various decks, loose cards, and a Pikachu deck box.
  • A box of sleeves is found, which seems to be a dud and likely headed for the trash.
  • Sorting through loose cards reveals lands, random rares, and artifact lands.
  • The loose box appears to contain mostly basic lands, with some valuable cards like fetch lands.
  • Decks like "Bless vs. Cursed" and "Oath of the Gatewatch" are explored, with varying card values.
  • The collection includes decks focused on exalted creatures and a potential Elf deck.
  • A peculiar mix of cards is found, including a Poison Mirr deck and various artifacts.
  • The final box, a Pokémon deck, is anticipated to carry significant value.
  • Notable cards like Fireball, Wolf of Devil's Breach, and Priest of Titania are discovered.
  • The collection's value hinges on the contents of the Pokémon deck, which is expected to be crucial.

29:50

Disappointing Elf Deck from Goodwill Auction

  • The individual is surprised to find a deck of elves splashing red for Fireball and Earthquake, considering it potentially the worst elf deck ever purchased.
  • The deck includes cards like Cage Sun, Earthquake, and Zenos, with the player expressing confusion over the choices made in the deck construction.
  • Despite the disappointment in the deck's composition, the player continues to draw cards like Huntmaster and Thornweald Archers, hoping for better draws.
  • The player reflects on the purchase of 8 pounds of Magic cards from a Goodwill auction, realizing they may have overpaid and are unlikely to recoup their investment, with the most valuable card found being a Yu-Gi-Oh card worth $25.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.