LoginGet started

History, genocide and Israel’s war on Gaza: Mehdi Hasan & Benny Morris | Head to Head

Al Jazeera English・45 minutes read

Israel seeks to dismantle Hamas's military strength and secure the release of hostages following the October 7th attack, amid a devastating humanitarian crisis in Gaza where casualties surpass 38,000. While some argue the conflict lacks genocidal intent, concerns about potential war crimes and the impact on Palestinian civilians continue to shape the contentious debate surrounding the situation.

Insights

  • Israel's military operations aim to dismantle Hamas and secure hostages following the October 7th attack, but these actions have led to a humanitarian crisis in Gaza, with over 38,000 Palestinian deaths and more than a million displaced, raising significant concerns about the consequences of such military strategies.
  • Historian Benny Morris defends Israel's actions by arguing they do not constitute genocide, contrasting them with historical genocides and suggesting that the death toll would be higher if there were intent to exterminate Palestinians, while also acknowledging that war crimes may have occurred, complicating the narrative of the conflict and its historical context.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is the definition of genocide?

    Genocide is the intentional act to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group, in whole or in part. This can include killing members of the group, causing serious bodily or mental harm, deliberately inflicting living conditions intended to destroy the group, and imposing measures to prevent births. The term was coined during World War II and is defined in international law, particularly in the Genocide Convention. Understanding genocide involves recognizing the systematic nature of these acts and the intent behind them, which distinguishes it from other forms of violence or conflict.

  • How can I improve my mental health?

    Improving mental health can involve several strategies, including regular physical activity, maintaining a balanced diet, ensuring adequate sleep, and practicing mindfulness or meditation. Engaging in social activities and building strong relationships can also provide emotional support. It's important to seek professional help when needed, whether through therapy or counseling, as mental health professionals can offer tailored strategies and coping mechanisms. Additionally, setting realistic goals and practicing self-compassion can foster a positive mindset and resilience against stressors.

  • What are the signs of a healthy relationship?

    Healthy relationships are characterized by mutual respect, trust, honesty, and open communication. Partners should feel safe expressing their thoughts and feelings without fear of judgment. Support for each other's goals and interests is crucial, as is the ability to resolve conflicts constructively. Healthy relationships also involve maintaining individual identities and independence, allowing both partners to grow together and separately. Recognizing these signs can help individuals assess the quality of their relationships and make necessary adjustments for improvement.

  • What is the purpose of human rights?

    The purpose of human rights is to protect the inherent dignity and worth of every individual, ensuring that all people can live freely and with equality. Human rights provide a framework for justice and accountability, guiding governments and institutions in their treatment of individuals. They encompass a wide range of rights, including civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights, which collectively aim to promote well-being and prevent abuses. By establishing standards for behavior, human rights serve as a foundation for peace, security, and development in societies.

  • How do I start a healthy diet?

    Starting a healthy diet involves making gradual changes to your eating habits. Begin by incorporating more fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins into your meals while reducing processed foods, sugars, and unhealthy fats. Planning meals ahead of time can help you make healthier choices and avoid impulsive eating. Staying hydrated is also essential, so aim to drink plenty of water throughout the day. Additionally, consider keeping a food diary to track your intake and identify areas for improvement. Consulting with a nutritionist can provide personalized guidance and support in achieving your dietary goals.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Gaza Conflict: Casualties and Historical Perspectives

  • Israel aims to dismantle Hamas's military capabilities, end its governance in Gaza, and secure the return of hostages following the October 7th attack, which resulted in significant casualties.
  • Since October 7th, over 38,000 Palestinians, including 15,000 children, have died, and more than a million have been displaced, rendering Gaza uninhabitable according to the UN.
  • Historian Benny Morris, known for documenting Israel's past actions, defends the current military operations in Gaza, arguing that the situation does not meet the definition of genocide.
  • Morris compares the current conflict to historical genocides, stating that the intent behind Israel's actions differs significantly from the systematic extermination seen in true genocides.
  • The International Criminal Court (ICC) is investigating potential war crimes by both Hamas and Israeli leaders, with evidence reportedly collected against Israeli officials, including the Prime Minister.
  • Morris acknowledges that war crimes may have occurred during the conflict but insists that the war itself is not a crime, contrasting it with Hamas's actions on October 7th.
  • Human Rights Watch reported that on October 31st, Israeli forces attacked a residential building, killing 106 civilians, including 54 children, without evidence of military targets nearby.
  • Morris argues that if there were genocidal intent, the death toll in Gaza would be significantly higher, suggesting that the numbers reported by Hamas may not be accurate.
  • The discussion touches on the historical context of Zionism, with Morris asserting that Zionists initially sought a Jewish state but later accepted partition proposals, which Palestinians rejected.
  • The debate highlights differing perspectives on the conflict's history, with Morris emphasizing that Zionists have consistently sought compromise while Palestinians have often refused.

13:16

Ethnic Cleansing Justified in Historical Context

  • The discussion centers on the justification of ethnic cleansing, with a quote stating that historical circumstances can validate such actions, particularly in the context of Jewish survival in 1948.
  • The speaker argues that Jewish communities faced annihilation threats from Arabs, legitimizing the expulsion of Arabs from Palestine as a defensive measure against potential genocide.
  • The speaker claims that ethnic cleansing is not universally regarded as a war crime, suggesting a preference for it over the massacre of their own people.
  • The conversation highlights the historical context of Arab attacks on Jewish communities starting in 1947, framing Jewish defensive actions as pragmatic rather than ideological.
  • The panel discusses whether Zionism can be classified as colonialism, with differing opinions on its implications and historical context, particularly regarding the treatment of Palestinians.
  • Diana, a Palestinian lawyer, asserts that many human rights organizations classify the situation as genocide, criticizing the Israeli narrative and emphasizing Palestinian suffering.
  • Emanuel, an international relations lecturer, argues that Israel is the only Middle Eastern country where Arabs enjoy freedoms, countering claims of widespread persecution.
  • Daniel, a former peace negotiator, emphasizes the need for acknowledgment and redress of Palestinian rights to achieve peace and security for both Palestinians and Israelis.
  • The discussion reveals a demographic shift in Israel towards the right, influenced by higher birth rates among religious populations and ongoing security concerns.
  • The conversation concludes with a critique of Benny Morris's controversial statements about Palestinians, raising questions about the feasibility of peace with those who hold such views.

27:03

Arab World Violence and Controversial Perspectives

  • The speaker claims the Arab world exhibits barbaric behavior, citing Syria's civil war, where approximately 500,000 people were killed by the regime suppressing an uprising.
  • Sudan is mentioned, highlighting violence against Black individuals in Darfur, illustrating ongoing ethnic conflicts within the Arab world.
  • In Libya, the speaker notes internal violence, including bombings at funerals, emphasizing the chaotic state of affairs in the region.
  • The speaker argues that labeling the entire Jewish world as barbaric would be anti-Semitic, contrasting it with their views on the Arab world.
  • Israeli Arabs are described as a potential fifth column, with the speaker asserting they identify largely with the Palestinian cause, posing a long-term threat.
  • The speaker discusses murder rates, stating that Israeli Arabs have murder rates 100-200% higher than Jews, particularly in cases of honor killings.
  • The speaker is accused of making racist comments regarding the nature of Palestinian society, which they defend as factual observations.
  • A controversial suggestion is made about Israel considering nuclear options against Iran to prevent nuclear armament, which the speaker claims is misrepresented.
  • The speaker emphasizes the need for Israel to act against Iranian nuclear facilities, arguing that Iran's intentions threaten Israel's existence.
  • Panelists discuss the implications of Israeli policies and the perception of Palestinians, highlighting the complexities of identity and historical narratives in the region.

39:59

Normalization of Violence in Israel Gaza Conflict

  • The discussion highlights the normalization of violence and genocide, particularly in the context of Israel's actions since October 7th, which are justified by the initial attack on that date.
  • Qatar's long-term financial support for Hamas is criticized, raising concerns about its role in the ongoing conflict and the fate of 120 Israeli hostages still held by Hamas.
  • The Israeli government, particularly under Netanyahu, is accused of incompetence for previously supporting Hamas, which has led to significant civilian casualties in Gaza.
  • The concept of genocide is debated, with claims that Israel's military actions result in mass civilian deaths, equating to a systematic crime rather than isolated war crimes.
  • The discussion includes accusations against Israel for imposing a total siege on Gaza, depriving 2.3 million civilians of essential resources like water, food, and medicine.
  • Claims of starvation in Gaza are contested, with one participant arguing that while malnutrition exists, there is no evidence of deaths due to starvation, despite reports of famine conditions.
  • The conversation concludes with reflections on empathy and the complex feelings of Palestinian children witnessing violence, emphasizing the dual blame on both Hamas and Israeli actions.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.