Foundations - Slab vs. Pier and Beam - Which is better?
Matt Risinger・19 minutes read
Slab foundations are durable but challenging to upgrade, contrasting with pier and beam foundations that offer flexibility, ease of insulation, and simple relocation options for homeowners in Austin, Texas. Pier and beam houses, like the Springdale Farms house, provide a traditional vented crawlspace with insulation options, making them a practical choice for those looking for future adaptability and comfort.
Insights
- Pier and beam foundations, like the one chosen for the Springdale Farms house in Austin, offer greater flexibility for future relocation due to their design, allowing for easier disconnection of utilities and transportation via a semi-truck.
- While slab foundations are common and durable, pier and beam foundations provide advantages like ease of insulation, repair, and remodeling, making them a preferred choice for homeowners seeking versatility and comfort in their homes.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
What are the benefits of a pier and beam foundation?
Pier and beam foundations offer advantages such as ease of insulation, repair, and remodeling compared to slab-on-grade foundations. They provide options for unconditioned crawlspace insulation, spray foam, or batt insulation. Additionally, pier and beam houses are more comfortable on the feet due to the slight flexibility of the wood flooring. They also allow for easier future relocation by simply disconnecting plumbing, cutting connections, and lifting the house onto a semi-truck for transport.
How are post-tension slabs constructed?
Post-tension slabs are common in production builds, with tensioned cables holding the slab together. This method involves pouring concrete and then tensioning steel cables to add strength to the slab. Post-tension slabs are durable and widely used in construction projects.
What is the difference between slab-on-grade and pier and beam foundations?
Slab-on-grade foundations involve pouring concrete directly on the ground, with the structural slab often serving as the finished floor. On the other hand, pier and beam foundations consist of piers supporting beams, creating a crawlspace for the house. Pier and beam foundations offer more flexibility for insulation, repair, and remodeling compared to slab-on-grade foundations.
Why are slab foundations challenging to upgrade or repair?
Slab foundations are challenging to upgrade or repair because they require invasive work for any modifications. Since the concrete is poured directly on the ground, any changes or repairs to the foundation would involve significant disruption and reconstruction of the slab. This makes it difficult and costly to make alterations to a slab foundation.
What type of insulation is used in a conditioned crawl space?
In a conditioned crawl space, insulation is typically placed on the perimeter for air conditioning purposes. This type of insulation helps regulate the temperature in the crawl space and eliminates the need for floor insulation. Insulating the perimeter of the crawl space ensures that the area remains conditioned and ready for framing, providing energy efficiency and comfort for the house.
Related videos
Real Stories
Slab City, California: Last Free Place in America? (Extraordinary Place Documentary) | Real Stories
VeggieTales Official
VeggieTales | The 3 Little Pigs 🐷 | Making Wise Decisions!
Vox
Why shipping container homes are overrated
Simple Living Alaska
Pulling Off Concrete Forms | New Home for the Sawmill
Interesting Engineering
How bridges are built over water?
Summary
00:00
Texas Construction: Slab vs Pier Foundations
- The construction job site in Austin, Texas is about to start framing a new house with a slab on grade foundation.
- Slab on grade foundations are common in Texas for the past 20 years, with concrete poured directly on the ground.
- Another foundation type to consider is a pier and beam foundation, which will be discussed in detail.
- Slabs are durable and straightforward, with the structural slab often serving as the finished floor.
- Post-tension slabs are common in production builds, with tensioned cables holding the slab together.
- Rebar slabs, preferred by the speaker, involve beams and rebar grids for added strength.
- Slab foundations are challenging to upgrade or repair, requiring invasive work for any modifications.
- Pier and beam foundations involve piers supporting beams, creating a crawlspace for the house.
- Unvented crawlspace acts as a short basement, with insulation on the perimeter for air conditioning.
- The conditioned crawl space eliminates the need for floor insulation, making it ready for framing.
13:48
Flexible Pier and Beam Houses in Texas
- The owners of the Springdale Farms house in Austin, Texas, wanted a house that could be easily moved in the future, leading them to choose a pier and beam foundation for flexibility.
- The underside of the house reveals a traditional vented crawlspace with piers, beams, and floor joists made of two by tens and two by twelves, constructed similarly to houses from the 1950s but with closed-cell foam insulation.
- Pier and beam houses are preferred for their ease of insulation, repair, and remodeling compared to slab-on-grade houses, offering options like unconditioned crawlspace insulation, spray foam, or batt insulation.
- Additionally, pier and beam houses are more comfortable on the feet due to the slight flexibility of the wood flooring, and they allow for easier future relocation by simply disconnecting plumbing, cutting connections, and lifting the house onto a semi-truck for transport.
