EVERY Scranton Strangler Theory - Iceberg

Mulverine・2 minutes read

George Howard Scub was convicted as the Scranton Strangler, but doubts arose about his guilt, especially for Toby, who was considered a suspect alongside Creed, Gabe, Robert, Bob Vance, David Wallace, Dwight, Jim, and Michael. The theory doesn't have a definitive answer due to the diverse character traits and actions of each suspect, leaving the Scranton Strangler's identity a mystery.

Insights

George Howard Scub was confirmed as the Scranton Strangler by the creators and writers of the show, settling the mystery around his identity despite initial doubts, particularly from Toby.
Various characters like Toby, Creed, Gabe, Robert California, and even Bob Vance were theorized to be the Scranton Strangler due to their intriguing character traits, criminal histories, and mysterious behaviors, showcasing the complexity of fan theories and the depth of analysis viewers engage in.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

Who was convicted as the Scranton Strangler?
George Howard Scub
Why is Toby Flenderson a suspect for the Scranton Strangler?
Unrequited love, self-defense training, dark fantasies
Why is Creed Bratton considered a suspect for the Scranton Strangler?
Mysterious, psychopathic traits, criminal past
Why is Gabe Lewis considered a potential Scranton Strangler?
Awkwardness, obsession with horror movies, darker tendencies
Why is Robert California linked to the Scranton Strangler theory?
Mysterious, manipulative, cryptic motives

Related videos

Summary

00:00

"Scranton Strangler: Toby or Creed?"

The Scranton Strangler was caught and trapped in his house, leading to a high-speed chase and eventual capture.
The identity of the Scranton Strangler was a subject of fan theories, with some believing it to be one of the Dunder Mifflin employees.
George Howard Scub was convicted as the Scranton Strangler, but doubts arose about his guilt, especially for Toby.
The creators and writers of the show confirmed that George Howard Scub was indeed the Scranton Strangler.
The Scranton Strangler only strangled victims but did not kill them, leaving them once they passed out.
Toby Flenderson is a popular suspect for being the Scranton Strangler due to various character traits and actions.
Toby's unrequited love for Pam, self-defense training, and obsession with crime novels are cited as evidence for the Toby theory.
Toby's manipulation of the jury, potential framing of Scub, and dark fantasies are part of the Toby theory.
Creed Bratton is another suspect for being the Scranton Strangler, given his mysterious and psychopathic character traits.
Creed's ambiguous job status, criminal past, and erratic behavior contribute to the theory of him being the Scranton Strangler.

14:00

"Scranton Strangler Theories: Ashwin, Creed, Gabe"

Ashwin is a peculiar individual known for unethical behavior and leading cults.
Creed is revealed to be a wanted criminal involved in drug trafficking, endangered species meat trade, and LSD theft.
Fans speculate Creed's gleeful demeanor during arrest hints at more crimes, possibly including murder.
Creed is suspected of being the Scranton Strangler, a theory supported by his erratic behavior and criminal history.
Gabe Lewis is considered a potential Scranton Strangler due to his awkwardness, obsession with horror movies, and darker tendencies.
Gabe's traumatic past and insecurity are theorized to lead him to commit crimes, including creating snuff films.
Robert California, a mysterious and manipulative character, is also linked to the Scranton Strangler theory due to his cryptic motives and dark desires.
Robert's affluent background and manipulative abilities suggest he could have committed violent acts without detection.
The theory proposes that Robert framed another character, Scub, to take the fall for his crimes, leveraging his wealth to avoid consequences.
Bob Vance, a seemingly unrelated character, is briefly mentioned as a diversion from the darker theories surrounding Ashwin, Creed, Gabe, and Robert.

28:46

Bob Vance: Kindly Businessman or Criminal Enforcer?

Bob Vance, known for Vance Refrigeration, is portrayed as a kind and sweet guy, but there are hints of a darker side to him.
The actor behind Bob Vance, Robert Schaefer, also played a role in "Psycho Cop."
Bob Vance's protective nature towards Phyllis is evident, with threats of violence if anyone harms her.
Phyllis mentions allowing men to flirt with her at bars to provoke Bob into defending her aggressively.
Bob Vance's wealth is highlighted through his extravagant spending, including buying out the warehouse to keep the Scranton branch operational.
The theory suggests Bob Vance may have ties to a criminal organization, possibly as a Mafia enforcer turned legitimate businessman.
The Scranton Strangler theory implicates Bob Vance due to his mysterious wealth and connections, but it is debunked due to his military background.
Moes, Dwight's cousin, is briefly considered a suspect for the Scranton Strangler due to his eccentric behavior.
The theory of Ryan Howard being the Scranton Strangler is mentioned, but his character traits make it unlikely.
Andy Bernard is theorized as a potential Scranton Strangler due to his emotional instability and violent tendencies, but the theory is deemed implausible.

44:05

"Scranton Strangler: The Office Suspects"

David Wallace was in Scranton during a tumultuous time, leading to speculation about his mental state and actions.
After being fired from Dunder Mifflin by Saber, David Wallace spiraled into depression and odd behavior.
Wallace's identity crisis and resentment towards those who caused his downfall led to a theory that he could be the Scranton Strangler.
Despite his anger, Wallace couldn't confront those he blamed, leading to a moment of violence that gave him a sense of power.
This violent act led Wallace to create an invention called "Suck It" and evade suspicion due to his wealth.
Dwight Schrute is considered a suspect due to his violent tendencies, martial arts training, and erratic behavior.
Dwight's heartbreak and lack of prospects in love or career led to a theory that he could be the Scranton Strangler.
Jim Halpert's calculated pranks and mysterious past, along with Pam's cryptic warning, raise suspicions about his potential involvement.
Michael Scott's series of personal and professional failures, coupled with possible mental health issues, lead to a theory that he could be the Scranton Strangler.
As Michael matures and moves past his traumas, the theory of him being the Strangler loses credibility.

58:33

"The Office" fans theorize Michael's redemption plan.

Fans speculate that Michael's criminal actions were necessary to get his life back on track, with some suggesting he orchestrated Toby's presence on the jury, although the feasibility of such a scheme is questioned. Theories derived from shows like "The Office" can be both problematic and intriguing, catering to those more interested in the possibility rather than the plausibility of their validity.

Try it yourself — It’s free.